Pittsburgh’s newest brewpub has a fleet of gleaming new kegs, but it’s decorated with some that are old and very dented.
Those are the ones that Matt McCullough used as a home brewer before he and co-owner Corey Gibbons decided to start their own brewpub. They committed earlier this week to “soft” opening their Dented Keg Brewing Co. Thursday and Friday in the Adams Shoppes in Butler County near Cranberry (the grand opening is set for Saturday). The space formerly was inhabited by a McGinnis Sisters Special Food Store.
Brewpub customers — there’s seating inside for about 100 — will be greeted in the entryway by kegs that are even more beat up than they were from brewing, thanks to a sledgehammer. “We exaggerated it a little bit,” acknowledges Travis McCullough, the brewpub’s designer and marketing guy and one of four McCullough brothers — natives of St. Marys in Elk County — who are part of the project.
Matt lives in Seven Fields within sight of the brewery. Travis and Brock live in Moon (though Brock is moving to the West Coast). Derek McCullough, who also lives in Moon, is overseeing the brewing, but in an unusual twist, the actual brewmaster is off-site.
That’s because Dented Keg is making its beer on a BrewSmart system. It’s made by Natural Brew, a Canadian-based company run by brewer Bryan Watson. He and his staffers supply customers with the concentrated wort — that is, the grain and hops “tea” that is the beginning of beer — and guidance for how to turn it into good beer. BrewSmart operators add plastic “pods” of various wort to the SmartBrew kettles with water, yeast and more hops and other flavorings to ferment and then the beer is transferred to the new kegs. It’s all per each brewpub’s own recipes. It’s just that the wort is “outsourced,” as Matt McCullough puts it. “That’s the only thing that changes.”
He likes the system’s small footprint, shorter turnaround time and simplicity. He knows some beer people won’t, and he’s already gotten negative feedback, such as “You’re the Easy-Bake Oven of brewing.”
“That’s all well and good, but come try our beer,” he says. “I see this as the future.”
He says this is the first SmartBrew in Pennsylvania, but there are now more than a dozen in the U.S. — including Stein Brewing in Mount Vernon, Ohio, with which he plans to collaborate — and about 50 total worldwide, with more on the way.
For Dented Keg’s opening, he’s planning to have 10 beers. The flagship is the only one with a name: 504 Pale Ale is named for an address where he once lived and sold to a guy who became a best friend. The brewpub also will be pouring a stout, lager, East Coast India pale ale, double IPA, apricot wheat, boysenberry wheat, and lemon and grapefruit shandies. There also will be three housemade ciders. Plus, the bar will serve a variety of Pennsylvania wines and spirits.
He’s also going to be brewing small batches from start to finish on his former home brewing system and will teach classes with it. Recipes that are a hit will be scaled-up, ordered as wort and fermented in the big 10-barrel SmartBrew tanks.
Dented Keg has a kitchen and plans to scale that up with its food menu, which starts with appetizers including Dented Kegs — tots with cheddar cheese, bacon and chive drizzled with sour cream or chili lime sauce ($10) and a charcuterie board ($14). There are a couple of salads that can come with grilled chicken or mahi (for $13 to $15), several sandwiches ($10 to $14) and sides, and a few desserts plus a kids menu.
“We’re calling it elevated bar food,” says Travis McCullough. “We want to keep it creative, fun and not boring.”
Along those lines, Dented Keg is offering hand-canned beer to go, but not 32-ounce “crowlers,” as other places do, but rather, 16-ounce cans as well as cute little 8-ounce cans, four of which will be marketed as a “flight to go.”
Matt McCullough thinks most customers won’t care where the wort comes from, but he’s glad he’ll still be making some of his own here, too. “What this allows us to do,” he says, “is still keep our hobby.”
Dented Keg’s address is 700 Adams Shoppes, Mars, PA 16046. The website is dentedkeg.com.
Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.
Explore the region’s breweries on the Post-Gazette’s interactive drinks maps at https://newsinteractive.post-gazette.com/drink-map.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.