A bottle of 110-year-old Pennsylvania rye that was stashed in the late Richard Mellon Scaife’s cellar is expected to sell for at least $10,000 at an auction of rare whiskeys and experiences.
The 1909 bottle of Overholt is one of the most coveted items up for bid in the second annual fundraiser for the Speed Art Museum in Louisville, the Bourbon state’s official art museum. The Art of Bourbon event on Thursday is sold out, but interested parties can still bid online. As of Tuesday morning, the top bid for the Overholt rye was $2,900, not including a 15 percent premium for online bids.
It’s totally worth it, says bourbon writer/collector and auction curator/emcee Fred Minnick.
“It’s extinct,” says Mr. Minnick. “There’s only a handful of these bottles left.”
He helped acquire some Overholt rye for Bottle & Bond Kitchen & Bar in Bardstown, Ky., where you can try the 1909 or the 1908 for — sit down for it — $1,250 per shot.
The stuff is reputed to have an extraordinary rich flavor.
“It tastes like Thanksgiving in a bottle,” according to notes with the online auction listing. “Vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg and caramelized apples are some of the predominant notes.”
But this Overholt has an even richer story, going back to 1800 when the Overholt family settled in Westmoreland County and fired up a distillery that soon was commercially cranking out Pennsylvania Pure Rye Whiskey. In that village of West Overton was born Henry Clay Frick, who went on to become a Pittsburgh industrialist. Frick bequeathed his shares in the expanded Overholt distillery to fellow industrialist Andrew Mellon in 1919.

Before Prohibition started in 1920, the story continues, Mellon and his brothers set aside some of the best old stuff for themselves. They had a stash laid in before Mellon had to sell his shares in the distillery when he became the U.S. Treasury secretary.
Several cases of those bottles were passed down to Scaife, the billionaire publisher of the Tribune-Review, and after he died, several cases were auctioned by Christie’s in 2015. Six wooden cases were purchased by Louisville’s Marc Abrams, who gave this one to the art museum to auction. As he says in the auction notes, “it remains today one of the best reviewed, most sought after and rarest old whiskies known.”
Mr. Minnick says he’s keeping a keen eye on the spirits world for these rare bottles, which he says were labeled for the Mellon family’s private consumption. There are other cues and clues to prove their provenance, but “I don’t want to give away too many secrets.”
He confirms that sealed bottles like this one “should taste exactly the same as when it was bottled.”
And that’s the alluring part, because there’s no one left alive who can say what that taste was like. Mr. Minnick reminds us that the rye and barley used to make it were different, the water was different, even the wood for the barrels was different.
“It’s really a fascinating study of what used to be, not just in whiskey, but in the whole country.”
So this quart bottle in particular is truly a big deal? “Dear God, yes,” he says.
Interestingly, West Overton Village & Museums just started making whiskey there again on a small still. The historic site plans to work the resulting white whiskey into its learning experiences, but it also will age some in barrels to eventually sell. It’s one of the stops on the new Whiskey Rebellion Trail that tells tourists the story of Pennsylvania rye and its recent comeback.
In the meantime, the Old Overholt brand, complete with Henry Overholt’s frowning face on the labels, is still being made (but in Kentucky) and marketed by Beam Suntory.
Other rarities in Thursday’s auction of 54 lots include eight Pappy Van Winkles (a group of five is expected to go for $15,000) and the chance for the winning bidder and nine friends to make their own barrel of Maker’s Mark, which is throwing in a piece of Dale Chihuly glass art (estimated to go for $20,000 to $25,000).
Mr. Minnick says you never know who might win an auction for a rare bottle such as the Overholt. It could be a known collector, but it also could be an anonymous person who just wants to splurge. He hopes whoever does win will open and drink it with friends.
“At the end of the day, these things are meant to be enjoyed.”
To bid online, visit https://www.proxibid.com/Menish-Auctions/Art-of-Bourbon/event-catalog/167482. For more information on the event, go to www.speedmuseum.org.
Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.
Correction: This story originally misidentified the Mellon brother had to sell the Overton distillery when he became U.S. Treasury Secretary: Andrew Mellon.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.