Seven Pennsylvania distillers gathered with a small crowd in Washington, Pa., to honor history — and to make a little, too.

This was Thursday afternoon at Liberty Pole Spirits, the Hough family-run distillery in this town that was one of the hotbeds of the Whiskey Rebellion of 1794. Yes, this gathering has a back story spanning 225 years.

After the Revolutionary War, the new nation’s government started taxing whiskey that farmers made with rye they grew. The farmers protested and didn’t pay it. President George Washington led troops to Western Pennsylvania to make them.

Seven Pa. distilleries create a reserve rye for the Whiskey Rebellion Festival

The Houghs, who named Liberty Pole for the poles of protest rebels raised, are big into the history of Pennsylvania rye whiskey. The distinctly spicy spirit was produced in massive quantities at distilleries across the state, especially in the 1800s, before it faded away. They’ve been helping other new-breed craft distilleries to bring it back, ever since theirs opened in 2016 during Washington’s annual Whiskey Rebellion festival.

Advertise with us

An idea for a fundraiser for this July’s 10th-annual festival was to invite the state’s best makers of Pennsylvania rye to collaborate on a special reserve blend of rye that could be sold to raise money for the event. Ellen Hough invited six other distilleries and was delighted when they all said yes.

So here they were seated around a rustic table in her distillery’s cozy tasting room, which was packed with state, county and local officials; festival volunteers; costumed re-enactors; media; and others. On the table were 12 sets of 12 stemmed whiskey glasses — 144 little glasses — as well as bottles of rye brought by each distiller. They were, clockwise around the table:

• Jim Hough of Liberty Pole.

• Andrew Martin of Thistle Finch in Lancaster.

• Unable to make it was Ed Belfour of Red Pump Spirits, also in Washington, so he was represented by his friend Lori Dominick.

Advertise with us

• Mike Smith of Barrel 21 in State College.

• Mark Meyer of Wigle Whiskey in Pittsburgh.

• Herman Mihalich of Dad’s Hat in Bristol.

• Rob Cassell was still on the road from New Liberty in Philadelphia.

Master of ceremonies Kevin Hough, one of the Hough’s two adult sons who work at the distillery, started without Mr. Cassell, introducing to the crowd the distillers as well as the tasters sitting with them:

Advertise with us

• Aaron Hajduk of Pittsburgh Whiskey Friends.

• Tripp Kline, co-chair of the Whiskey Rebellion Festival.

• Max Miller of Raise Your Spirits.

• Jeremy Noah of Pennsylvania Libations.

• And Jon Maielli of the Those Dram Yinzers podcast, who was wired up and recording all this.

Advertise with us

With “some of the best distillers in Pennsylvania,” Kevin Hough announced.

“In the country,” Mr. Mihelic corrected, sparking laughs. And they were off.

Each distiller got to say a few words about that particular rye as each poured and passed a dozen tastes. Jim Hough, the dad, told everyone how Liberty Pole qualifies as “Monongahela rye” and is made with 61 percent rye and 13 percent each of malted rye, malted barley and wheat, the last of which being what sets it apart. “We think the wheat softens our rye a little bit.” The golden drams he was sending ’round had aged in a “char three” barrel for 19 months.

Mark Meyer from Wigle Whiskey tastes rye whiskey on Thursday at Liberty Pole Spirits in Washington, Pa. Seven distilleries across the state contributed rye whiskeys to create a special reserve Pennsylvania rye that will benefit this summer's Whiskey Rebellion Festival. (Steph Chambers / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The 11 present panelists sniffed, sipped, swirled, swallowed and sniffed again. They talked among themselves. And then it was time for them to vote with a thumbs-up or thumbs-down: Was this rye worthy of being in the 2019 Whiskey Rebellion Special Reserve?

The answer was a dramatically delayed but unanimous yes. Dad Hough dumped the rest of his bottle into a tall glass pitcher at the center of the table.

Advertise with us

Next was Mr. Mihalich, who described his nine-month-old made with just rye and 20 percent malted barley, saying, “Ours is a very strong expression of that malt.” He passed around glasses to be sniffed and sipped.

That rye made the cut, so he poured into the pitcher the rest of his bottle, along with some rye that was left in one of his glasses.

And so it went, around the table, to the tasters’ running commentary and comedy.

There was Pennsylvania rye “before there was Kentucky” and its famous bourbon, noted Mr. Meyer of Wigle, which, when it started in 2011, was named for a Whiskey Rebellion figure and inspired by that heritage.

Barrel 21’s Mr. Smith had labeled his bottle, as federal law requires, but with the proof and other particulars handwritten on a strip of masking tape. The contents were a blend of six barrels aged for two years. “Very floral,” Mr. Herman remarked. “Pretty.”

Advertise with us

“Getting a lot of candy — sweet,” offered Mr. Kline, who later, after they’d thanked Mrs. Hough and she very warmly thanked them back and they said the Ships Toast to everyone and to Pennsylvania whiskey, said, “This is the best Thursday afternoon EVER!”

Mr. Cassell arrived, shared his rye, which earned its inclusion, and so he added his and stirred the now filled pitcher. The Houghs handed out more glasses and poured everyone who wanted one a taste of this blend of seven ryes, which soon had folks nodding their heads: Good. The tasting room was getting even warmer.

The label for the 2019 Whiskey Rebellion Special Reserve Rye Whiskey. (Liberty Pole Spirits)

“Today,”  Mrs. Hough pronounced, “we are making a memory.”

On Friday, the distillers were to get back to work and make the big version of the blend, pouring the contents of the small barrels and kegs and even plastic buckets of the ryes they brought into a full-size, 53-gallon barrel that until recently held Dad’s Hat four-year-old rye. The rye will mingle in that until May or so, when another event will be held to bottle and label it. Then in June, people who pay $79.94 for one will get a 375-milliliter bottle.

Dad Hough suggests buying two: One to drink and one to keep. “This will never happen again.”

Advertise with us

They do plan to bottle another reserve blend next year, but that will be with more and different distillers and ryes.

Orders for the 2019 Special Reserve can be made starting April 10 at www.whiskeyrebellionfestival.com. This year’s festival, marking the rebellion’s 225th anniversary, runs from July 11 to 14 and will include a Whiskey Walk.

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.