No Western Pennsylvania brewery medaled in this year’s Great American Beer Festival, but a Northeastern Ohio brewpub and brewery with Pittsburgh roots is proud to have cleaned up, even if with some controversy.

Fat Head’s, which started on Pittsburgh’s South Side, won five medals — more than any other brewing company in the country — in this year’s competition in Denver. Those medals went to two different locations, which figured into the Brewers Association later issuing a “correction” that took away from Fat Head’s an additional award.

When the results first were announced Saturday afternoon during the annual festival in Denver, Fat Head’s Brewery and Saloon in North Olmstead, Ohio, also was named mid-sized brewery and brewer of the year. But the Brewers Association later in the day gave that award to Karl Strauss Brewing Co. of San Diego, which it said had mis-classified itself as a brewpub instead of a brewing company in the competition.

“It’s very confusing,” Fat Head’s Matt Cole said today. He explained that companies like his with multiple locations are required by the rules to compete at the level of their largest location. So even though the North Olmstead location is a large brewpub, it had to compete as a mid-sized brewing company, as did Fat Head’s Brewery in nearby Middleburg Heights, Ohio. (Fat Head’s also has a brewpub in Portland, Ore., in addition to its original Fat Head’s Saloon on Carson Street.)

Advertise with us

Had he been able to enter North Olmstead as a large brewpub, as he’d tried to do, its medal haul would have made it GABF’s large brewpub and brewer of the year. But that award went to the Austin (Texas) Beer Garden Brewing Co., which won two medals.

“All of us with the Great American Beer Festival and the Brewers Association deeply regret this error,” the BA said about reassigning the mid-sized brewing company award in a news release Saturday night.

Mr. Cole said he will be talking to trade group officials about the issue on Monday and hopes to involve other breweries so such a situation doesn’t happen again. “I think I have a legitimate beef,” he said, in wanting each brewery or brewpub to be judged according to its own actual size.

Judges this week rated a record 7,227 competition entries (up from 6,647 entries in 2015) from 1,752 breweries hailing from 50 states and Washington, D.C. In Saturday’s ceremony at the Colorado Convention Center, they awarded 286 bronze, silver and gold medals in 96 beer categories covering 161 different beer styles (including all subcategories). Two hundred fifty four brewers were awarded medals.

Fat Head’s Brewery and Saloon won three medals: Bronze for Fresh or Wet Hop Ale for its IBUsive; silver for Other Strong Beer for its Black Muddy River; and gold for German-style Wheat Ale for its AlpenGlow.

Advertise with us

Its sister Fat Heads Brewery won two medals: Bronze for Imperial India Pale Ale for its Hop JuJu and silver for American-style Black Ale for its Midnight Moonlight.

Imperial India Pale Ale was the second-most-entered category, with 211 entries, following American-Style India Pale Ale with 312 entries, in this 30th festival, sponsored by the Brewers Association.

Fat Head’s Brewery initially tweeted, “Having a hard time putting what this means to us into words. We have the absolute best team and everyone had a hand in this award. Thank you.”

Mr. Cole said he and his colleagues were bummed out to give back the mid-sized brewing company and brewer of the year award, but still very happy at how they did. “We won more medals than any other brewery in the country. We’ll get back up on that stage again.”

Go here for the complete list of winners and more information.

Advertise with us

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.

Clarification (Oct. 9, 11:25 a.m.): This story originally reported that Fat Head’s also had won mid-size brewing company and brewer of the year, but that was before that was overturned by the Brewers Association later that day.