The parking garage beneath Gateway Center was a sight to behold for financial adviser Jim Meredith on Sunday mornings in the 1990s when he was broadcasting his weekly radio show for Hefren-Tillotson.

Steelers players were required to stay overnight at the former Hilton Hotel for home football games.

“There were all these incredibly expensive tricked-out cars in the parking garage,” Mr. Meredith said. “Every one of these cars must have been valued at about $100,000. Even the rims and tires on some of these cars would have cost $5,000 each.

“You just knew these cars were owned by young men full of testosterone,” he said. “And that is what a young man who has lots of money will do with it.”

Advertise with us

For young, highly paid professional athletes able to earn more money in one season than many Americans will earn in a lifetime, spending money lavishly often comes with the territory. But if history is any indication, not long after players leave the game that made them rich and famous, many will end up broke.

Broke millionaires

Most people shake their heads in disbelief when they hear a former NFL or NBA star whose career earnings may have topped $200 million is down on his luck financially, in bankruptcy court, in trouble with the IRS, or facing hundreds of thousands of dollars due in back child support.

“I don’t judge ex-athletes too harshly — even those players who snagged gigantic sports contracts and huge endorsement deals — because I realize that they can wind up broke for many reasons,” said Lynnette Khalfani Cox, founder of AskTheMoneyCoach.com, based in Mountainside, N.J.

“For starters, athletes in the U.S. are just like the rest of the American population when it comes to a lack of basic financial literacy.”

Advertise with us

Sports Illustrated magazine estimated in 2009 that 78 percent of NFL players are bankrupt or facing serious financial stress within two years of ending their playing careers. And, the magazine calculated, 60 percent of NBA players are broke within five years of retiring from the game. There is no shortage of high-profile examples from all major sports.

Former NFL wide receiver Terrell Owens blew through nearly $100 million in 15 seasons and ended up busted. Former NBA star Antoine Walker frittered away $110 million. Former golf champion John Daly wasted $50 million to $60 million gambling. And who could forget the two white Bengal tigers boxing legend Mike Tyson bought for $140,000? The monthly cost of caring for them was $4,000 per tiger.

How does it happen?

Matt Helfrich, president of Waldron Private Wealth, a Bridgeville-based financial advising firm that represents athletes and high-profile celebrities across the U.S., said numerous factors contribute to the financial ruin of successful athletes. Many stem from the sense of entitlement that comes from being told their whole lives how great they are.

He said the top three most common ways that rich athletes pour money down the drain include owning multiple homes, getting tangled in bad investments and buying private jets.

Advertise with us

“During their careers, athletes and entertainers are used to private flying,” Mr. Helfrich said. “They want to carry over that lifestyle after their career is over. But they don’t understand the costs associated with it or the waste that can be incurred by not structuring the costs properly.

“Also, they buy homes for themselves, vacation homes, and homes for their friends and family members. All of the homes have carrying costs with them,” he said. “There are taxes, maintenance, landscaping, cable and staffs. That’s even before considering if they paid too much.”

Professional athletes tend to be less interested in mundane investments such as stocks and bonds. They prefer sinking money into exciting yet risky businesses such as nightclubs, restaurants, start-up ventures and commercial real estate.

“We try to understand what amount of money they will need to have in the bank to support their lifestyle when their playing career is over,” said Mr. Helfrich, whose firm manages $1.4 billion in client assets. “We try to determine that number now and what they need to be saving out of their paycheck so they can get to that number.”

Having it all

Advertise with us

But athletes don’t always follow a financial adviser’s advice, said Paul Brahim, CEO of BPU Investment Management, Downtown.

“They live beyond their means,” he said. “They want the giant houses and flashy cars. They want to own the next shiny thing rather than engage in the basic blocking and tackling of financial planning and asset management.

“Pro athletes have a huge challenge, though. Most of us save for a lifetime. They have an eight- or nine-year window,” Mr. Brahim said. “They have to prepare for the rest of their lives in eight or nine years of their playing career.

“Instead of preparing for the rest of their lives while they are playing, they live like they will play forever.”

A manager at one major Pittsburgh bank who asked not to be identified said sports agents often have such tight control over players that even financial advisers handling their investments don’t have access to them. Advisers find themselves working through agents rather than with the player directly, depriving the player of needed guidance.

Advertise with us

Other challenges? Ms. Cox of AskTheMoneyCoach.com said taxes regularly trip up current and former athletes because they really are entrepreneurs and thus have to treat their earnings as if they are self-employed. If they fail to set money aside for taxes — a common mistake — they will definitely run into trouble with Uncle Sam or state tax authorities.

And then there’s the problem of saying “no” to friends and relatives asking for cash or loans.

“Many athletes grew up in low- to moderate-income households, and once they start making gobs of money, they don’t want to be ‘selfish’ or accused of forgetting where they came from,” Ms. Cox said.

“So they find it incredibly difficult to establish financial boundaries with people they’ve known their whole lives.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591