On the subject of the importance that good timing plays in life, American icon Willie Nelson once mused, “The early bird gets the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.”
That bit of wisdom could well apply to the career trajectory of Brian Keyser, both in a literal and metaphorical sense. It ended up with him getting the cheese.
Mr. Keyser’s hotly anticipated homage to fromage, Casellula @ Alphabet City, a cheese-centric restaurant, opened Jan. 20 on the North Side at the old Masonic Hall on West North Avenue. It’s part of City of Asylum’s Alphabet City project, and the Pittsburgh offshoot of his Casellula Cheese & Wine Cafe, which opened in Manhattan in 2007 to bring handmade cheeses from all over the world to New Yorkers.
How he got there is a classic intersection of timing and luck that took the 48-year-old California native from a film industry career in Los Angeles at age 27 tod one in fine dining in New York, where he found his true calling.
An English major at UCLA, he was working in production for Disney animation. By his estimation, it was a dream job for someone under 30 and put him on a fast track in the entertainment industry — except for one crucial detail: He hated it.

“I just woke up one morning and realized I was completely miserable and I didn’t want to keep my job or my apartment,” he said.
Read More
He’d always wanted to live in New York and he “had friends that lived there so I had a floor to crash on.” One friend worked at Danny Meyer’s iconic Union Square Café, which it is among the most important restaurants in modern New York and American history.
“He started doing something in New York that no one in New York was doing — greeting customers with a smile and pampering them.”
Mr. Keyser scored an interview and got the job.
“It just fell together beautifully. I didn’t know what I wanted to do with the rest of my life at 27. The restaurant business is great for people like that. And to my absolute surprise I fell in love with it.
“I thought waiting tables was going to be this thing I was going to be ashamed of doing, but that I had to do it until I went back to law school or theater school or something like that,” he said.
“I was working with some of the best people in the business. I started learning about wine and what real fine dining food was, and real high-quality service was. By accidents of luck, I landed in the best possible place I could’ve to learn about the restaurant business.”
He went on to prominent French restaurant Chanterelle, where his crash course in cheese was purely financially motivated.
“They had a cheese course as part of the fixed-price menu and we were required to learn all the cheeses because we had to present at the table. You didn’t get a full cut of the tip pool until you passed your cheese test.”
“I was like most people, I knew cheddar and American singles and mozzarella on pizza. But I really had no interest in cheese. I didn’t get cheese on my sandwiches. I didn’t really like cheese, or I thought I didn’t like cheese. And then I got to taste all this different array of … all these beautiful cheeses. It was like a whole new world opened up to me.”
He’d go on to help open another Danny Meyer restaurant, The Modern, where he was hired as a waitstaff captain. Prior to opening, the chef had some cheese distributors bring in samples.
“I went to the chef and said, ‘I don’t know what you have going on with the cheese program, or who’s in charge of it.… I know a little about cheese but I’d love to learn more.’
“This is the week the restaurant is opening, so it’s chaos everywhere and he says “YOU ARE IN CHARGE OF THE CHEESE — I DON’T EVER WANT TO HEAR ABOUT IT AGAIN!” and he walked away. I never talked to him about it again.”
A few years later, he developed his plan for Casellula, which opened in the Hell’s Kitchen section of Manhattan in 2007. Approaching a decade — an eternity in New York restaurant years — it continues to enjoy a sterling reputation.
In 2015, Mr. Keyser decided to open a second restaurant. He was negotiating a deal in Nashville when he stopped in Pittsburgh for dinner with a friend. That led to a meeting with City of Asylum co-founder Henry Reese and the beginning of a conversation that led to Cassellula @ Alphabet City.
“It felt similar to our neighborhood in New York, Hell’s Kitchen, which 10 years ago was very much a neighborhood in transition — a mix of cultures, families that have been here for generations and yuppies moving in,” he said.
“I didn’t know Pittsburgh at all. Now that I’m spending a lot of time here and getting to know the neighborhoods, it’s a great city with great people. I’m really happy to be here.”

He quickly learned of the decades-long effort to revitalize the corner of West North Avenue and Federal Street and the old Garden Theater.
“I’d rather be one of a few new things on the North Side in a neighborhood that’s just starting to get exciting in terms of commercial, shopping, restaurants, than be just another bar in Lawrenceville, or just another restaurant in East Liberty. I like those neighborhoods, but I also like the idea of doing something a little more challenging.”
As in New York, Casellula @ Alphabet City’s focus is on cheese plates drawing from five categories of cheese — fresh, bloomy and soft-ripened, washed, pressed and cooked, and blue. Mr. Keyser plans on at least 25 varieties at any one time and pairing them with more than 70 fine wines. The 60-seat restaurant also features small plates, salads and sweets. Much of the product comes from a Cleveland-based distributor, but he’s discovered and will incorporate local products such as Goat Rodeo cheeses from Indiana Township.
Beaver Falls native Andrew Hill, most recently the sous chef at Station in Bloomfield, does the cooking. A graduate of Pennsylvania Culinary Institute, he also has cooked at Ten Tables and Craigie on Main in Boston.
The menu includes a few classics from New York City that define Casellula, including its famed Pig’s Ass Sandwich, one of the Village Voice’s 100 favorite dishes in New York. It pairs Shelburne Farms Cheddar and French Fol Epi with bread and butter pickles and chipotle aioli. There’s also a cavatelli with pork belly, Calabrian chilies, tomato and Pecorino-Romano and mac ‘n cheese made with three cheeses (Fol Epi, Comté and chevre) and topped with pork lardons and caramelized onions.
“What we try to do is give people a cheese plate that is beautiful and enjoyable just on its own, but can give people an opportunity to learn. We’ll answer any questions you have about cheese.”
“I’ve been the guy who just looked at the cheese list and said ‘I don’t know’ and moved on. I know where they’re coming from. I’ve been there.”
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.