What makes a coffee shop cool? Is it the atmosphere, the drinks, the food or the people?
All of the above, and it helps if they are a neighborhood meeting place and showcase local artists, musicians and ingredients. Here’s a look at some of our favorites. Grab a cup and enjoy!
4121 Main, Bloomfield
Kira Hoeg and Thommy Conroy opened in March in what had been Mr. Conroy’s art studio. A pair of bay windows at the entrance, built-in shelving and a coat of white paint — even on antique tin ceilings — has transformed this nook into a bright, warm space that also includes Mr. Conroy’s greenery and arrangements.
As a barista at Marty’s Market, Ms. Hoeg built a following on cappuccinos and lattes with bright, floral notes and velvety milk that’s the perfect temperature. Here, she uses beans from Heart Roasters of Portland, Ore., and sells linzer tortes, flaky croissants, delicate cakes and other indie-baked pastries.
Check out the Spirit, a Danish espresso machine made by Kees van der Westen. One of only a handful in the United States, it has more horsepower than most and a very consistent pour.
4121 Main St., Bloomfield. 412-708-4500. 4121main.com
Caffe D’Amore, Lawrenceville
Sarah Walsh just opened this shop, but coffee geeks know she’s an excellent barista. She built her reputation at pop-ups, Marty’s Market and her stand at the Pittsburgh Public Market, both in the Strip District.
Her brick-and-mortar space is a charming, red-painted storefront with tons of light, where customers can order a very good cappuccino or a maple latte with a sandwich, brought in from Steve’s Deli in the Strip District.
5400 Butler St., Lawrenceville. 412-330-1418. caffedamorepgh.com
Constellation Coffee, Lawrenceville
Former Tazza D’Oro barista Amy Weiland opened on Penn Avenue in 2013. She serves coffee from Ceremony Coffee Roasters of Annapolis, Md. The beans are blended for balance and acidity, and the ones she’s brewing now come from Ethiopia, Kenya and Guatemala. In addition to coffee, the shop offers artisan chocolate, handpies, scones and various sweets.
Terrific light and a private back room make it conducive for working and reading.
4059 Penn Ave., Lawrenceville. constellationcoffeepgh.com
Espresso a Mano, Lawrenceville
Owner Matt Gebis has been fueling the growth of the city’s coffee culture since he opened his Lawrenceville shop in 2009.
Of all the coffee drinks he serves, Mr. Gebis prefers the shop’s namesake, which, in Pittsburgh, is moving from a luxury drink to an everyday beverage, in part, due to his care.
Several factors ensure a perfect espresso beyond a skilled barista, of which there are many who work here. Sourcing has always been important, whether it’s single-origin or a blend. The shop uses beans from Verve in Santa Cruz, Calif., Counter Culture in North Carolina, Forty Weight in Colorado and Coava in Portland, Ore.
The roast is also key, along with freshness. Beans need to be fresh-ground, not too fine and not too coarse. Then there’s the brewing, with temperature and time key factors. And of course, there’s gear. At the shop, baristas make coffee with a La Marzocco, which some consider the BMW of espresso machines.
3623 Butler St., Lawrenceville. 412-918-1864. espressoamano.com
Biddle’s Escape, Wilkinsburg
Returning from a weekend away, proprietor Joe Davis found that a customer had repaired a wobbly table on the second floor of this eclectic cafe. “That happens a lot,” he says. “It’s like a living thing on its own.”
Opened in May 2012, his place is more than its selection of 175 teas, 30-40 coffee drinks, smoothies, signature drinks, breakfast items, snacks and Food Truck Wednesdays. It has become a community center with music and poetry readings, literary nights, political workshops, women’s business networking events and running group meet-ups. In warmer months, a garage-door window opens to an outside deck where patrons can read, chat or listen to live music.
Mr. Davis, 45, a Baltimore native, fills the place with a rotating array of artifacts collected in his travels. “Everything we do is always a work in progress,” he says. “It’s so much fun. It’s just fun.”
401 Biddle Ave., Wilkinsburg. 412-999-9009. www.biddlesescape.com
Lili Cafe, Polish Hill
On the corner of Dobson and Hancock is a red-brick coffee shop whose menu features changing brunch options, coffees and espresso. The cafe is known for its vegan and vegetarian food options and supports local artists by hanging their art. The colorful walls give the space a welcoming atmosphere.
Coffee prices range from $1 to $3 and every few months, local bands turn the shop into a performance space.
3138 Dobson St., Polish Hill. 412-682-3600. www.facebook.com/lilicoffeeshop?fref=ts
Anchor and Anvil Coffee Bar, Ben Avon
When Andy Theobald opened in 2014, his goal was to make Anchor and Anvil a gathering place in Ben Avon. He’s succeeded. Regulars include everyone from moms who just dropped the kids at school, to workers getting their caffeine fix on the way to the office, to knitting groups, book clubs and retirees who like to hang out at its half-moon bar.
Set in a 1925 car dealership, the shop has super-high ceilings, black-and-white photos on moss-colored walls, large tables and plenty of books to peruse by the fireplace. The beans are from MadCap, a small-batch roaster in Grand Rapids, Mich. There is a changing selection of baked goods from Enrico Biscotti Bakery in the Strip District (scones, croissants, biscotti and macaroons) along with soups and sandwiches. Saturdays feature house-made monkey bread.
The fluorescent lighting is a bit harsh and unnecessary considering all the sunlight that comes through enormous showroom windows at the front. But the couches and chairs are comfy, and the view of Church Avenue is entertaining.
7221 Church Ave., Ben Avon. 412-772-8569. anchoranvilcoffee.com
Generoasta, Marshall
Opened by former Steeler Eric Ravotti, Generoasta pairs good coffee and good works, donating a portion of profits to a changing list of charities. They roast beans in-house and offer substantive meals and snacks, including a bacon-and-egg wrap for breakfast and TED for lunch. That stands for Thanksgiving Every Day, with turkey, swiss, cranberry chutney and stuffing.
Yes, there are sweets and not just the baked variety. The “lavish lattes” with chocolate or caramel sauces, frozen coffee drinks and granitas are truly decadent. Neil Walker likes the iced latte with soy milk. And if you’re looking for a place to spread out, this place is just right.
901 Warrendale Village Drive, Marshall. 724-330-7007. generoasta.com
Coffee Buddha, Ross
Michael Witherel opened in an old Dutch Colonial-style house in 2011 to give locals the kind of hangout he didn’t have as a kid in nearby West View. “I wanted it to feel like you’re walking into a buddy’s house.”
A giant fish tank topped by a big-screen TV welcomes you at the door. Upstairs, there’s a study, a game room equipped with foosball and a meditation room. Outside, there’s a zen garden and a dog-friendly porch and patio.
The PGH Taco Truck and other mobile food vendors regularly set up in the parking lot and there’s a giant food truck roundup the last Saturday of the month. The shop also hosts open-mic poetry nights, a drawing club, live music with local artists, and after hours on weekends, a BYOB club for the over-21 crowd.
The beans come from Commonplace Coffee Co. in Indiana, Pa.; it also has a selection of Tupelo Honey Teas. All syrups are made in-house, along with many of the baked goods. Others are from Schorrs Bakery.
964 Perry Highway, Ross, 412-837-2595. thecoffeebuddah.com
Simpatico Espresso, Downtown
Due to construction at the former Alcoa Building, this place hasn’t been easy to get to recently, but it’s worth the effort. Owner Ward Payne serves the wares of several local roasters, including La Prima Espresso, 19 Coffee and Commonplace. If you’re serious about coffee, order single-origin bean brewed on its fancy Trifecta single-cup brewer.
His little “bodega,” which has been open for nearly a decade, also has smoothies and shakes. A favorite is the emerald original kale “veggie fusion shake,” which includes pineapple, lemon and banana. The stand also offers sweets from several local bakeries.
Mr. Payne is proud to be open on weekends and to offer his hot drinks in ceramic mugs for those who want to sit down for an old-fashioned coffee break.
611 William Penn Place, Downtown. 412-287-7598. simpaticoespresso.com
Commoner Corner, Downtown
This corner of The Commoner restaurant has original coffees and drips, a small range of Caffe Vita drinks, fresh-pressed juices and stuff with cool names like Black and Gold Chocolate Ice Cream and Butter Shake. Here, the food is a draw, including sandwiches made with house-smoked meats and fresh-baked pastries.
The prices for some of the food and drinks are on the high side, but the quality makes it worth an extra couple bucks.
458 Strawberry Way, Downtown. 412-230-4800. www.thecommonerpgh.com/the-commoner-corner/
Cafe de Noir, Brookline
Formerly Cannon Coffee, Cafe de Noir has been in operation since Sept. 1 on a bustling stretch of Brookline Boulevard. For now, owner Elias Kassab has kept many of the old place’s signature touches — the worn but comfy tables and chairs, the art on the walls, the fish tank and, most remarkably, Hermes, the bearded dragon occupying a place of honor in the front window.
What has changed from Cannon is a switch to LaPrima beans and the addition of salads and a deli case for sandwiches. Baked goods feature two different kinds of Mr. Elias’ homemade baklava: walnut and cashew.
Open mic events are on hold for now, “but we’re thinking about evening events. Maybe we can invite young people who can play guitar or sing,” Mr. Kassab said.
802 Brookline Blvd., Brookline. 412-563-0202.
Big Dog Coffee, South Side
In 2008, classical musicians Cortney and Nikolay Ivanov opened this shop in the 120-year-old former Kohler Bakery. The couple, formerly of the Dallas Opera orchestra, moved back to her roots — her parents run the Morning Glory Inn down the street.
It’s not just the Intelligentsia “direct-trade” coffee from Chicago and other brews and teas that draw college students and others. The shop offers grab-and-go items like muffins, scones and homemade doughnuts plus organic rolled oatmeal with fresh fruit and seasonal gelato from artisan Mercurio Mulberry Street. In warmer weather, patrons sit in the hidden courtyard amid climbing honeysuckle, morning glories, clematis and hydrangeas.
Mrs. Ivanov, who grew up with a Newfoundland dog, chose the shop’s name. “We just like the laid-back confidences they have,” she said. At the moment they own two large German shepherds, Rada and Bentley.
“We have the feel of a living room,” she said. “In the winter, when the fireplace is lit, it’s super cozy. We make it a great place to study.”
2717 Sarah St., South Side Flats. 412-586-7306. bigdogcoffee.net
The Beehive, South Side
Whether you’re bohemian, psychedelic, punk or hipster, The Beehive has buzzed as the standard-bearer for Pittsburgh’s coffee-counterculture for just under a quarter-century. It still is today, offering inexpensive grub — sandwiches, soup and snacks, often vegan — to the starving (or just budget conscious) artist and student set. Founders Scott Kramer and Scott Zumoff have built a mini-empire that includes the Lava and Tiki lounges, and multiple Double Wide Grill locations.
If the eye-popping artwork on the walls or disco ball and trippy metal sculptures hanging from the ceiling don’t wake you up, the locally roasted coffees from 19 Coffee Co. in Washington, Pa., and Zeke’s in East Liberty certainly will. Also try a scoop of gelato, a Mexican hot chocolate or an Irish coffee with whiskey, as they have a full liquor license, too.
1327 E. Carson St., South Side Flats. 412-488-4483
Delanie’s Coffee, South Side
Though they made their fortune on a bass-throbbing club, South Side-based AMP’d group has made an easy switch to casual dining, art and Arabica. General manager Randy Recker has been in charge since Delanie’s opened in 2011.
The cafe hosts quarterly art shows and local artists’ work lines the brick walls of the handsome two-floor former architect’s studio. They are the sole area distributor for noted Brooklyn roaster Toby’s Estate. Organic juices pressed on site and gourmet grilled cheeses are among the menu items not to be missed.
1737 E. Carson St., South Side Flats. 412-927-4030
Black Forge Coffee House, Allentown
This coffee shop opened on the neighborhood’s main drag in early August as part of a boomlet of new indie businesses. It serves locally based Zeke’s Coffee, baked goods from Three Fifty Bakery + Kitchen, tea from Gryphon’s and vegan bites from Onion Maiden, a soon-to-open vegan spot in a so-far undisclosed location.
Black Forge is a hangout by day and a performance space at night, with open mic hours and local bands.
1206 Arlington Ave., Allentown. blackforgecoffee.com
Blue Canary Coffeehouse, Castle Shannon
Rena and Stephen Antosz opened this second location of their Ambridge coffeehouse in August in Lebanon Shops. The space, like the couple, is very colorful and artsy.
They were one of the first in the region to serve “nitro coffee” — cold-brewed coffee that is kegged and pressurized with nitrogen gas for a lightly effervescent effect that makes it look like beer. One variety is even flavored with hops. They have two dedicated nitro taps and one for non-nitrogenated cold brew.
Blue Canary also serves a full range of hot and cold coffee drinks brewed with Nicholas Coffee beans. They have house-made syrups and sauces for flavoring house-made sodas, as well as ice cream and treats such as milkshakes, floats and fruit smoothies. They also serve apple dumplings and gluten-free cookies that they source from local businesses.
The artwork around the counter and on the walls is by Angela Fullard, who works as a barista, too. There’s also work by other local artists for sale.
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd., Castle Shannon. 412-344-7100. bluecanarycoffeehouse.com
Uptown Coffee, Mt. Lebanon
On weekends, the lines are practically out the door, but no one seems to mind waiting for drinks made from LaPrima beans or the cinnamon buns, pecan rolls, biscotti, pumpkin cheesecakes, big shortbread cookies and chocolate cupcakes topped with shiny ganache — all made on the premises from scratch.
Owner Elizabeth Boyd is celebrating the shop’s 20th anniversary this year, offering treats and made-to-order sandwiches to everyone from municipal officials to students from nearby elementary and middle schools who rush in for milkshakes after school.
723 Washington Road, Mt. Lebanon. 412-563-8563. Uptowncoffeepgh.com
Commonplace at Voluto, Garfield
A pioneer in Pittsburgh’s coffee culture, Commonplace offers distinctive roasts at its namesake shops as well as restaurants and coffee bars that buy wholesale.
Voluto is a notch above, as are siblings in Squirrel Hill, Larimer and its soon-to-open North Side location. With a surgeon’s precision, its baristas strive for a perfect cup every time. In the Garfield shop, terrific natural light, good snacks and an occasional visit from a food truck are additional draws.
5467 Penn Ave. Garfield. 412-661-3000
61C Cafe, Squirrel Hill
From blueberry-pineapple-pear-banana smoothie to ginger-apple juice to espresso con panna to latte mocha to a monstrous English toffee cookie to baklava to Yerba Mate tea, there are plenty of choices brewing at 61C Cafe.
The cafe, which sits on busy Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill, opened 22 years ago and has a sister coffee shop — 2-year-old 61B Cafe in Regent Square. The well-lit 61C Cafe has chalk boards that highlight the coffee, tea, hot chocolate, fresh juice and smoothie selections, a small oven where manager and baker Keith Kaboly makes muffins and monstrous cookies, and about 25 two-seat tables.
When a regular requests a hot chocolate that includes everything on the shelf, Kathleen Hospodar knows better, instead whipping up a drink with frosted mint and amaretto syrups, mocha, chocolate syrup and cream that makes him one happy man. The cafe also sells coffee beans from Tanzania, Costa Rica, India, Mexico, Colombia and Ethiopia.
61C Cafe, 1839 Murray Ave., Squirrel Hill. 412-521-6161.
61B Cafe, 1108 S. Braddock Ave., Regent Square. 412-871-3013.
Tazza d’Oro, Highland Park
Opened in June 1999, the shop whose name means “cup of gold” brings the community together through multiregional beans from Counter Culture Coffee, one of the largest roasters in the country. More than half the materials used to make its drinks and freshly baked pastries come from local, independent vendors and farmers.
The well-trained baristas and Verve coffee roasters from Santa Cruz combine to make this one of the best espresso bars in Pittsburgh. Its freshly brewed drinks can be experienced at their Highmark or Carnegie Mellon University locations or at this comfortable cafe shaded by two leaning trees.
1125 N. Highland Ave., Highland Park. 412-362-3676. tazzadoro.net
Zeke’s, East Liberty
This modern yet rustic space is the place for everything from hot macchiato to black peppermint tea, and the baristas have raised lattes to the level of art.
That’s something to remember when the drink options become overwhelming. No matter which one you choose, the freshly brewed coffee and other drinks are always good.
6015 Penn Ave., East Liberty. 412-670-6231. zekescoffeepgh.com
La Prima Espresso Co., Strip District
Opened in 1988 by Sam Patti, this cafe has a sweet, creamy cappuccino ($3.50) that goes well with a buckeye, croissant or apple melee. Sip your coffee, freshly squeezed orange juice or chocolate egg cream while standing at one of five round tables, or sit at an outdoor table and watch John, Ernesto, Tony and Tony play a card game called scopa.
La Prima also sells “drunken beans’’ aged for two months in oak barrels formerly used by Wigle Whiskey. They’re $19 for 12 ounces.
205 21st St., Strip District. 412-281-1922. laprima.com
21st Street Coffee and Tea, Strip District
Skilled and personable baristas serve Intelligentsia coffee, first-rate cappuccino ($3.75) and Kilogram organic tea with delectable pastries from La Gourmandine and Bella Christie.
This shop has oak floors, comfortable blue Eames-inspired chairs and sweets ranging in size and price from Itty chocolate bars (85 cents), to caramels made at Vermont’s Big Picture Farm, to Askinosie ($9) and Mast Brothers chocolate bars. The milk is from Brunton Dairy, a family-owned business in Beaver County. Owners Luke and Alexis Shaffer also have a Downtown location at 3 PNC Plaza by the Fairmont Hotel.
2002 Smallman St., Strip District. 412-281-0809. 21streetcoffee.com
Allegheny Coffee & Tea Exchange, Strip District
Once called Fortune’s, the cafe and store were purchased in 2012 by Daniel Nolan and his son, Eric, the general manager.
Six nitro taps dispense cold-brewed coffee pressurized with nitrogen. “It’s a complete beer system. There’s just coffee in it,” says Eric Nolan, who plans to offer 32-ounce growlers of cold-brewed coffee starting the day after Thanksgiving. It might go well with Highlander grog, coffee with a whisper of whiskey.
The on-site roaster handles 40 pounds of beans at a time and if you prefer tea, they carry the Stash brand plus 40 varieties of Ceylon tea. This fall, try pumpkin lattes flavored with real pumpkin pie filling.
2005 Penn Ave., Strip District. 1-866-569-5865. alleghenycoffee.com
Prestogeorge, Strip District
Cozy and a tad narrow, Prestogeorge has an old-fashioned feel from the constant hum of the roaster that turns out 600-800 pounds daily. The 35-year-old shop supplies coffee to many local restaurants and ships its coffee, loose teas and gift baskets around the world. At the deli, 39 gourmet sandwiches and lunch are served until 3:30 p.m.
Now run by Stan Prestogeorge, it boasts 37 varieties of coffee, 80 flavored coffees, 10 kinds of biscotti and 300 varieties of loose tea sold by the pound, half-pound or quarter-pound.
1719 Penn Ave., Strip District. 412-471-0133. prestogeorge.com
Carnegie Coffee Co., Carnegie
Developer Craig Cozza, pharmacist Greg Romeo and his wife, Ashley Comer, opened two years ago in a stately former post office shared with his pharmacy. For those nostalgic for a cup of Illy coffee like they had on their last visit to Italy, this is your spot.
It’s also a great place to pull up an armchair for a few quiet moments of reading on a rainy day. Or stop by for Sunday brunch from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Dishes such as Nutella waffles or bratwurst sell for under $10.
132 E. Main St. Carnegie. 412-275-3951. facebook.com/CarnegieCoffeeCompany
Crazy Mocha, various locations
Owner Ken Zeff does not drink coffee, but that does not deter loyal customers at more than 30 Crazy Mocha locations, many of them in underutilized buildings or spaces. Fifteen years ago, Mr. Zeff bought his first shop, then called Dancing Goats Coffee in Shadyside. He changed the name and kept the mascot.
Today, customers enjoy a range of coffee drinks from latte with a shot of flavor to a regular cuppa joe. The newest location opened in October at 309 Smithfield St. in the Wintergarden at One PPG Place.
Visit crazymocha.com for locations
This story was written by Post-Gazette staffers Melissa McCart, Gretchen McKay, Bob Batz Jr., Dan Gigler, Marylynne Pitz, Arthi Subramaniam, Virginia Linn, Chase Lang and Maria Sciullo.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.