When choosing their next project, most developers call in experts, do lots of market research, line up financing and crunch the numbers. Brian Mendelssohn sits down with a few of his Lawrenceville friends and ponders this question: "What is missing in this neighborhood?"

Two years ago, the answer was Tender Bar + Kitchen, a prohibition-themed restaurant opened by Jeff Catalina in an 1870s bank at 43rd and Butler streets. Mr. Mendelssohn's company, Botero Development, owns the building, and he lives in one of five apartments above the restaurant.

Last summer, the missing piece was Row House Cinema and Atlas Bottle Works, a small movie house attached to a beer store. Mr. Mendelssohn, a lifelong movie lover and craft beer geek, owns the building and the businesses.

"I wanted to add value to the neighborhood," he said. "I live here. I would want this here."

Advertise with us

On a recent weekday, some 20-somethings were browsing the beer selection as pedestrians walked under an interactive theater marquee whose lights followed their steps. Inside the 83-seat theater, couples and families settled on couches or plush movie seats for a singalong showing of "Grease." Some held beers, others popcorn topped with locally sourced butter.

"We take a crafty, handmade, artistic approach to community development," said Mr. Mendelssohn, 38. "It's not a get-rich-quick scheme."

Five years ago, he and his ex-wife, Rebecca Morris, were runners-up in the PG Renovation Inspiration Contest for their rehab of an old Isaly's into her Wild Card shop with two apartments above. Last year, he won again for rehabbing a Lawrenceville row house. A Miami native who came to Pittsburgh to study materials science and engineering at Carnegie Mellon University, Mr. Mendelssohn believes he has a greater impact with commercial development.

"Retail acts as a catalyst for overall development ," he said.

He envisioned a restaurant when he bought the former Arsenal Bank on Butler Street. Despite other uses, its grand details and 15-foot ceilings were still intact.

Advertise with us

In March 2012, Mr. Mendelssohn used the building for one of three "loft bashes" to raise money for Bike Pittsburgh. About 800 people partied prohibition style in the third-floor ballroom. One was Mr. Catalina, who liked the raw space and the theme. Soon, he and Mr. Mendelssohn had worked out a 10-year lease for a 3,000-square-foot dining space and kitchen on the first floor and restrooms and a private dining room in the basement. Its décor honors the building's banking history and the speakeasy spirit of the early '30s.

Mr. Mendelssohn's more recent project was very different. The 1860s building at the corner of Butler and Main streets started as an artists' "crash pad" and later held a department store, convenience store and other businesses before Mr. Mendelssohn's company bought it in early 2013.

"I chose this building because of its prominent location," he said. "It had been remodeled 15 times. It was like a blank canvas."

Original plans called for an old-fashioned 18-room hotel and an ice cream shop. But Botero Development couldn't get financing for the hotel, so the plan evolved into a theater and beer store with six apartments above.

Mr. Mendelssohn, whose favorite movie genre is 1960s and '70s Japanese samurai flicks, chooses the theater programming with help from his staff.

Advertise with us

"My competition is the suburban megaplex or staying at home and watching Netflix," he said. "The experience has to be magical."

The adjacent beer store is an extra draw for some movie-goers. It is unique for the way it's laid out -- by brewing style -- and for a selection that ranges from Millvale's Draai Laag Brewing to Scotland's Skull Splitter ale. It will soon have nearly 20 taps, and its 500 bottle brands are expected to grow to 1,000 by 2016.

"Our demographic is people who love movies and beer," he said.

Some regular customers are born-and-raised Pittsburghers, while others are suburbanites drawn to Lawrenceville's funky vibe.

"Change is difficult for some Pittsburghers to handle," Mr. Mendelssohn said. "But this young population embraces it and the way we're doing it."

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978