Beneath the sleepy, small-town facade of Harmony, secrets lurk.

And the intrigue goes beyond the ghosts that reportedly haunt an old inn, or that it was the childhood home of “X-Men 97” villain Bastion.

Within its four-block historic district designated a National Historic Landmark, Harmony harbors some surprisingly modern treats, including a TikTok latte sensation at its charming bakery and an ice cream “cloud” dessert invented by a Willy Wonka-style inventor. A gluten-free creperie, a historic inn and a brewery are all within walking distance.

About 30 miles north of Pittsburgh in Butler County, this tiny borough (population under 1,000) rewards slow wandering. A main street of historic buildings, a creekside landscape and a tight cluster of food destinations make it easy to spend an afternoon grazing your way through its 0.4 square miles.

Advertise with us

Johann Georg Rapp and his Harmony Society founded the town in 1804 as a religious communal experiment by German pietists seeking freedom from persecution. The Harmonists built an industrious settlement — with mills, vineyards and workshops — before relocating to Indiana and later returning to settle in Ambridge, Beaver County.

Before they left Butler County, the Harmonists sold the town to a Mennonite blacksmith, and the influence of Mennonite settlers remained strong until the early 20th century. Though the population shrank and farmland was sold off, the historic core remains intact, with buildings named after original families and a layout that reflects its communal origins. (Visit the Harmony Museum, which offers walking tours, to learn more.)

Its more well-known Butler County neighbor today is Zelienople, or, a little farther, Cranberry.

Lagerhaus Bakery

It’s on the map: social media sensation raspberry Danish latte at Lagerhaus Bakery (byhannahnicole)

Lagerhaus Bakery is owned by brothers Mark and Gary Rodgers, who run a stock brokerage across the street, but has been helmed by 26-year-old Ashley Heintz since January 2025. With both a bachelor’s degree in entrepreneurship and a baking and pastry certificate, Heintz places the emphasis on homemade baked goods and inventive coffee drinks.

“Everything’s very much from scratch, made fresh every day,” the Brighton Heights resident said.

Advertise with us

The bear claws are “to die for,” one admirer told me, and the cinnamon rolls are “an old family recipe,” Heintz said. Included in the lineup are also lemon and blueberry bars, coffee cakes, cookies, muffins, brownies and German apple cake.

The bakery is also a coffee destination, including for its viral raspberry Danish latte. The inventors of the latte, a small Midwestern coffeeshop called Little Joy Coffee, decided to share its recipe online. Little Joy also offers to put cafes that carry the drink on an online map. Lagerhaus is the only coffee shop in the Pittsburgh area that is on that map.

“It’s a house-made raspberry syrup with a cream cheese cold foam,” Heintz explained. “And yeah, it’s just delicious.”

I recommend getting the iced, not the hot, version. It’s exactly the kind of drink that gets people to detour off I-79.

“We had a couple people come up that saw us on the map and they traveled out from Pittsburgh,” Heintz said.

Advertise with us

Other house favorite drinks include banana bread and carrot cake lattes, both with cream cheese cold foam.

“A goal definitely in the near future is to start making all of our syrups,” she said.

Heintz touts Harmony as “the cutest thing ever,” as well as her shop’s family atmosphere. It is staffed during busy times literally by Heintz’s family.

“A lot of the people you’ll meet on Saturdays, that’s my mom and sisters,” she said.

Neff Haus

Cookie Butter Cloud, at Neff Haus, with real Lotus Biscoff cookies (courtesy of Neff Haus)

Once you’ve had your coffee fix, you can’t miss Neff Haus, an ice cream shop with something extra. It’s owned by Sam and Julie Hopkins, a married couple who had a business restoring historic properties. Neff Haus was one of their projects.

Advertise with us

Sam said he decided upon completion, in 2021, that he wanted to sell ice cream in the building.

“I didn't want to just open up an ice cream shop and say, ‘We got sundaes and floats.’”

Thus Neff Haus, or as the website would have it, “The Legendary Neff Haus Ice Cream Shop,” was born.

The thing to know about Hopkins is that he is an “inventor by nature.”

“I have 40 domestic and international patents, so I just invent, invent, invent.”

Advertise with us

While 80% of his inventions are technological, he said, some are culinary. Among them are his “clouds,” whose ingredients he would not reveal. However, he did say it was “dairy-based” and strewn with morsels of cake.

It is a nonfrozen dessert topping over soft-serve ice cream in flavors like strawberry pretzel salad, toasted almond torte and cookie butter cloud.

In addition, the shop makes its own cookie dough; not for Hopkins those industrial pellets of dough. The shop’s “meltys” are warmed cookie dough, topped with ice cream. All desserts use premium ingredients, he says, such as Ghirardelli chocolate and real vanilla.

The ice cream itself comes from “one of the world’s most advanced ice cream machines,” Hopkins said, which is not only self-pasteurizing (and thus more sanitary than most machines) but also pumps “millions and millions of tiny bubbles” into the ice cream, making it extra creamy.

The “legendary” shop has found its fans to the tune of 100,000 visitors last year.

Advertise with us

Though today Hopkins is an enthusiastic promoter of Harmony and its history, he never visited when he was growing up in East Liberty and Highland Park.

As he describes it, “Harmony is very much a Hometown, USA. Everybody knows everybody.”

Harmony Inn

Potato pancakes at the haunted Harmony Inn (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

If you’re pacing yourself, consider a walk along Connoquenessing Creek.

But if you’re still hungry — or need something beyond sweets — you’ll find other stops along the way: a cozy crepe spot, a lively brewery and a centuries-old inn with German fare (and a ghost story or two).

Operated by North Country Brewing Co., the Harmony Inn blends traditional German fare — pretzels, spaetzle, schnitzel — with a broader modern menu.

Advertise with us

Some guests come for the atmosphere. The building once operated as an actual inn, and its layout still reflects that history, with dining rooms spread across former sleeping quarters. It also carries a local reputation for being haunted — by ghosts like a young girl in a white gown and a spirit known as Louie, along with poltergeists and toy soldiers that move on their own.

“The building’s actually haunted,” Heintz said. “People have had interactions with it.”

While the ghosts may exist, I can confirm that I did not see any humans transformed into cyborgs in Harmony, as depicted in the “X-Men 97” animated series.

Harmony’s real secret is that it is quietly plugged into a larger food conversation.

Where to eat in Harmony

Harmony Inn. A woody bar and dining area are so comfy and welcoming that you’d never guess ghosts have been sighted there. German fare is offered in the former bedrooms of the historic inn. Large, dog-friendly outdoor bar and patio, sometimes with live music.

Advertise with us

230 Mercer St., northcountrybrewing.com/the-harmony-inn

Lagerhaus Bakery. House-made baked good and coffee drinks, including the famed raspberry Danish latte. There’s both indoor seating and a patio in the back.

307 Mercer St., lagerhausbakery.com

Neff Haus. Soft-serve ice cream in 23 flavors, “cloud” desserts and “meltys.” Be prepared for a line during prime time. An adjoining popcorn shop and a patio in the back. No indoor seating.

220 Mercer St., neffhaus.com

Advertise with us

Union Brothers Brewing. Opened in 2020 by Zach and Leah Waltz in bordering Jackson, the brewpub was conceived as a hometown gathering place. The current location, a larger space on Mercer Street in Harmony, offers pub fare (burgers, wings, poutine, Bavarian pretzels) alongside a rotating tap list of about 20 beers. Outdoors, a large beer garden with fire pits, games and often live music.

270 Mercer St., unionbrothersbrewing.com

Wunderbar Coffee & Crepes. A large variety of savory and sweet gluten-free buckwheat crepes highly recommended by the manager of the neighboring Lagerhaus Bakery. Italian-inspired coffees, gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches and salads. It also has a location in Bellevue.

253 Mercer St., wunderbarharmony.com