Pittsburgh’s end-of-year restaurant opening boom is getting another dose of good news with Kristin Butterworth’s return to the region as the executive chef of soon-to-open Cork & Crust at The Oaklander Hotel in Oakland.
“It all happened pretty fast. This is home and, when The Oaklander opportunity presented itself, it felt synchronistic,” Butterworth says. “I’m excited to come back. There are so many talented chefs in this city and it is something special to be part of that.”
Butterworth’s lauded career began with humble beginnings at southwestern Pennsylvania spots such as Luigi’s, a small Italian restaurant in Clymer, Indiana County. It rapidly grew in scope and stature. In 2010, Butterworth landed a gig as chef de cuisine at Lautrec at Nemacolin in Farmington, a property she’d worked at early in her career, following a run as sous chef for the famed Patrick O’Connell at his Inn at Little Washington.
There, she earned heaps of accolades, including the restaurant’s rare rating as a Forbes Five-Star and AAA Five-Diamond. She was the first woman and, at 29, one of the youngest chefs in the country to achieve the double honor. Butterworth also landed three James Beard Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic semifinalist nominations at Lautrec while building deep relationships with farmers near the resort, which is located about 60 miles south of Pittsburgh.
“The biggest thing, and that’s always been my philosophy, is that the food should tell a story. Anybody can serve chicken, but what’s going to be special about what you’re getting at this restaurant?” she says.
“Food is an emotional thing. You remember your nonna’s spaghetti or the tuna casserole your mom made. It gives you something to think about and to remember.”
Butterworth, by then executive chef in charge of culinary operations at Nemacolin, moved on at the beginning of 2024. She most recently was executive sous chef at Sea Island Resort in Georgia, marking a return for the chef, who spent a few years early in her career at the Five-Star, Five-Diamond resort.
With Cork & Crust, Butterworth will look to her early Italian roots in her mother’s kitchen and her training in 2002 at the Italian Culinary Institute for Foreigners in Costigliole d’Asti.
“There’s always been a strong Italian background in my food. I went to school for it, but I’ve never run a restaurant entirely devoted to it,” she says.
She has just started developing the menu, but guests can expect seasonal, frequently changing, “solid, composed food for everyone,” with deep Italian influence and a strong connection to local purveyors, including some who already work with Spirits & Tales, the hotel’s long-standing restaurant.
The kitchen will include a wood-burning oven for pizza and other dishes.
“I’m planning on reconnecting with people I used to work with,” such as Footprints Farm in Fayette County, “and meeting new people. The Oaklander already has a strong tie to pulling in local purveyors that speak to Pittsburgh.”
Her expectation is that Cork & Crust will draw both hotel guests and others. The dining room will be on the ground floor of the building. The Oaklander’s hotel lobby and Spirits & Tales are on the 10th floor.
Butterworth is working from Georgia and plans to arrive in Pittsburgh in mid-November. If construction stays on track, she’ll be able to start staff training Dec. 1, with an opening anticipated later in the month.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.