Justin Severino was the talk of the town in 2015.
Born in Ohio and trained under some of the finest chefs in California, Severino brought back a butcher’s box of culinary knowledge from the West Coast that helped push Pittsburgh dining forward into its modern era. His first restaurant, Cure, garnered accolades near and far from the moment it opened on New Year’s Eve 2011.
A few years after opening Cure, Severino and his wife and business partner, Hilary Prescott-Severino, decided to branch out with a regional Spanish-influenced concept inspired by the couple’s trip to various parts of the country.
“I remember thinking, ‘There's nothing like this in Pittsburgh as we were eating through places like Asturias and San Sebastian,’” Severino says.
A prominent Lawrenceville property owner, Lee Gross of A-1 Realty, was an enormous fan of Cure and had already spoken with the couple about a space in Lower Lawrenceville where he’d hoped they would open a new restaurant. It previously housed an office, which gave the pair a chance to develop their vision from scratch.
“We signed a lease when we came back,” he says.
Severino, who has a background in construction, enlisted fellow restaurant owner Sam DiBattista of Vivo and pal Brandon Masi of Mitre Box to help build the taverna-style space.
He also brought Nate Hobart, then 24 and Severino’s right hand at Cure, along as a partner and chef de cuisine. Now, Hobart runs the day-to-day operations of Morcilla’s kitchen and has grown into one of the most respected restaurant proprietors in town.
“The intention from the start was for Nate to have the involvement he has today,” Severino says. “We had Cure at the time, and that was very centered around my involvement. Hilary and I were then going to do some other things, some that happened and some that didn’t.”
Straightaway after Morcilla’s December 2015 opening: heaps more praise, local and national. Perhaps even more than the love shown to Cure, which closed in 2019.
“We were the hot new thing after the hot new thing, right? In the beginning, a lot of it was about the PR, the story and the hype,” Prescott-Severino says.
“Our goal from the start, though, was for Morcilla to be like Dish. We wanted to be the small, cozy restaurant that people would keep coming back to.”
Morcilla’s vibe is quite different from the beloved South Side Italian spot, but over the past 10 years the Lawrenceville restaurant has settled into a harmony that puts consistency at the forefront.
Many of the initial small bites that made Morcilla a hit are still popular in 2025.
Among them: setas a la plancha, crisped mushrooms served with gooey egg and shallots on bread; matrimonio montadito, marinated anchovies, crushed tomatoes, garlic, lemon and olive oil, as well as other pintxos, featuring fist-pounding anchovy preparations; and oxtail montadito, a wickedly indulgent two-biter of braised oxtail, caramelized onion and Mahón cheese on a baguette.
Over the years, Hobart and his team have made slight changes to two of Morcilla’s signature large-format shareables — Laurel Hill Farm trout with fried artichokes, salsa verde and charred lemon and arroz con pitu de caleya (roasted chicken with calasparra rice and cider) — but both have been staples since the early days. A newer addition, smoked beef short rib, comes with a side set that changes with the weather.
“People now come here expecting a consistent experience, back and front of house,” Hobart says. “We still tweak things and we still work on new dishes, but we don't need to take huge swings. We've been doing this for 10 years and we have all these dishes that people love. Why not continue moving forward with that as the base?”
For the past five years, Hobart’s evolution has been in the broader world of the restaurant. Once squarely ensconced in the kitchen, he emerged as a regular front-of-house presence during the COVID-19 pandemic and has stayed there.
“I was uncomfortable when I first started doing that, but the customer-facing aspect and getting to know the regulars is now my favorite thing about this,” he says.
Severino has spruced up Morcilla’s physical space over the years, though generally in ways too subtle for most customers to notice. The most significant shift happened early, when the standing-room-only bar gave way to a more traditional space with seating. A 2018 fire prompted several improvements, including adding much-needed soundproofing and relocating the pintxos station from the bar to the kitchen to free up more space for customers.
Severino still consults with Hobart on the menu, but stepped away from the daily operations of Morcilla a few years back to focus on Salty Pork Bits. His since-closed charcuterie wing was one of fewer than 20 USDA-certified, heritage-style meat curing operations in the country, and while it helped fund Morcilla through the pandemic, the hoops involved in keeping the small business running proved too much for the long term.
He’s also worked as a consultant with restaurants on both coasts and is now working as a partner on a project called Electric Bowl in Washington, D.C.
Last year, Severino and Hobart also took the show on the road, developing a menu for a restaurant called Rojo by Razzle Dazzle on a new Virgin Voyages cruise ship called Brilliant Lady. Many of the menu items are similar to those offered at Morcilla.
Prescott-Severino, the curator of the wine list for Morcilla’s exceptional drinks program, remains the essential, if mostly behind-the-scenes, force that keeps the whole operation running.
“We've really settled into Morcilla now. It's not about the hype, it's about providing a really beautiful evening that makes people feel good,” Prescott-Severino says.
3519 Butler St., Lawrenceville; morcillapittsburgh.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.