The chicken Milanese now served at Cafe Notte is a straightforward delight: a pounded breast, evenly breaded, fried to a crisp and centered on a plate with a tangle of peppy arugula and a wedge of lemon.

It’s one of the stronger dishes on the new menu at the family-owned Italian restaurant, which recently underwent a top-to-bottom reinvention spurred by an upcoming appearance on a long-running restaurant makeover show. (The family is bound by a nondisclosure agreement preventing them from speaking about the specifics until it airs.)

Cafe Notte’s mid-July relaunch comes with a significantly condensed menu and a complete redesign of its Emsworth space.

“We went from a spaghetti and meatball-type place to something more upscale,” co-owner Jerry Santucci says. “It feels like we’re starting fresh again.”

Advertise with us

There are a few holdovers: the dedicated staff, the iconic signage on Route 65, the old fireplace and the signature fiber-optic starscape ceiling of the restaurant Santucci, his wife, Debbie Santucci, and her son, David Mielnicki, built from scratch in 2010. Once the furniture for the spacious patio arrives in a couple of weeks, everything else will be new.

Mielnicki says his mother, prompted by a steady decline in business over the past years, reached out to the show’s producers after seeing a casting call promoted on local outlets.

“There are places shutting down left and right, and even more that are struggling. We were in the same place,” he says. “We were relying on private events to keep afloat because we weren't getting regular business like we used to. There would be Wednesdays where we’d have just a couple of tables all night.”

The revamped space feels cleaner and more energized, with each area offering a distinct vibe. A set of family photos lines the entrance to remind guests of the restaurant’s family-focused nature. Other walls are decorated with archival images of the building’s past lives as a gas station and motorcycle shop, alongside historic photos of Pittsburgh. Santucci went the extra mile and worked with a friend to install new flooring after the show’s crew left, too.

The menu, designed by the show’s celebrity chef host and culinary team, retains Cafe Notte’s Italian roots while incorporating local produce and sharper technique. It is streamlined to maximize efficiency in the small kitchen and showcase high-quality ingredients.

Advertise with us

“They took what my kitchen staff was capable of and designed a menu that was airtight,” Santucci says. “Fresh — all fresh. Nothing frozen, nothing reheated.”

The kitchen now looks to nearby Wexford Farms and Our Neighborhood Farmstead for its seasonal produce. Minestrone soup, chock-full of vegetables such as summer squash and kale, elevates the Italian staple with enough substance and nuance that it might be one of Cafe Notte’s signature dishes.

Porchetta, hearty with braised kale and lentils and tied together with a zingy salsa verde, was another highlight of a visit shortly after the changeover. It’s worth noting the braised kale and salsa verde appear across several dishes, a smart move to help the kitchen stay grounded while adapting to the new vision.

“We have an obligation from the show to serve this menu, but this is more than just what’s in the contract,” Santucci says. “We can't make all these changes and not execute with perfection.”

Still, the transition comes with a few bumps. On Friday, a miscommunication with Cafe Notte’s new seafood purveyor led to a delivery of eight red snapper filets instead of 8 pounds, forcing Santucci into a last-minute run to Robert Wholey & Co. in the Strip District.

Advertise with us

“It's challenging to do it all fresh. You depend on your purveyors a lot more,” he says.

Fried zucchini — which arrives as a tangle of tasty shoestring-thin frites — might catch diners off guard, too, as the preparation veers away from the long, wavy planks we typically associate with the dish in Pittsburgh.

And, Santucci says, some longtime regulars are bummed about their favorite dishes getting the chop.

“I get it, there's going to be pushback because people have been coming here for years and they like what they like,” he says.

Overall, though, Santucci says the response has been positive and he’s seen an influx of new customers.

Advertise with us

He’s been in contact with the show’s team in hopes of making a few minor tweaks. He’d like to drop the side of soft polenta with pistachios, which hasn’t been selling, and add a pounded, bone-in veal chop Milanese, which would offer more choice without creating a disruption of flow since it uses the same prep as the existing chicken dish.

As a diner, I’d like to see either iteration of that dish come with a small side. While splitting the primary components of main courses from the sides is becoming more standard in high-end restaurants, it’s the sort of price-padding most of us wouldn’t want to see creeping into family-run establishments such as this one. (All in all, the restaurant is still reasonably priced, with starters in the $10 to $15 range and entrees from $18 to $30.)

The family can’t say when their episode will air, but think it should hit the airwaves sometime this autumn or winter. In the meantime, they’re embracing the new outlook.

“When we first opened the restaurant you have this passion to cook, to serve, to make people thrilled with your food. After a while, it becomes a j-o-b like any other one. We're reincarnating. We're still Cafe Notte, still an Italian restaurant, but we're at the next level now,” Santucci says.

8070 Ohio River Blvd., Emsworth; cafenottepgh.com