There’s a genre of restaurants that embraces the inherent theatricality of dining out with exuberant flair. You’ll find this aesthetic-minded ambition in places like the maximalist landmark Serendipity 3 in New York City, the immersive Tonga Room in San Francisco and a multitude of restaurants on the glittery Las Vegas Strip.

In Pittsburgh, that mantle is now being taken up at Palm Palm, a lavish new production from Herky and Lisa Pollock and Ed and Amanda Smith, the team behind Downtown Instagram-favorite Ritual House.

“Palm Springs meets Palm Beach meets Pittsburgh. What we’re doing is heightened, but it should feel genuine to our guests,” Herky Pollock says.

The restaurant, opened earlier this month in Shadyside, combines saturated design — including two jewel-box, private dining rooms — with a mix of culinary nostalgia and “coastal cuisine.” Its attachment to any particular geography, however, is looser than the broader ambition of the owners to provide guests a couple hours of escape from the sometimes chaotic realities of living in the United States in the mid-2020s.

Advertise with us

After absorbing a heavy dose of pre-opening hype drifting through my social media feeds, I arrived on a Monday night curious to see how Palm Palm holds up in practice. When restaurants like this work, they deliver a well-formed set piece that allows us to participate as active observers enjoying a good meal amidst the razzle-dazzle. When they don’t … well, what a letdown.

Straightaway, it was clear Palm Palm delivers the visual side of the bargain.

The restaurant occupies a corner of Shadyside once home to the pan-Asian restaurant Plum, which closed in 2018 and sat empty until now.

Now, it’s a high-gloss fantasy. It’s not quite Palm Springs, not quite Palm Beach — more a projection of mid-century nostalgia and leisure filtered through the eyes of well-traveled Pittsburghers who grew up in the East End and decided to bring the party back home.

One of two private dining rooms at Palm Palm. (Samara McCallum / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“It’s meant to feel like old things feel new again,” said Lisa Pollock as she led a pal and me through the restaurant after dinner.

Advertise with us

She helped envision the interior design with the kind of detail often missing in new openings, even the bigger budget ones, including hiring two budding artists from England to gild some of the ceilings and walls in a gold- and silver-leaf extravaganza.

A small detail I appreciate: The bathrooms get as much attention as the rest of the space. I go to a lot of restaurants, and this tends to be the place where the illusion drops; they are expensive to renovate and easy to de-prioritize when a budget gets tight. Here, hunter green tile gleams, and the Slim Aarons photography theme extends to the restroom walls.

All the stage setting is only worth it if the spectacle holds up beyond the glitz and glamor of the gilded ceilings and bespoke birdcage bar shelves, because Pittsburgh’s dining landscape now spans a wide range of perspectives and price points. In an era when value and substance matter as much as presentation, Palm Palm needs to offer meals that will help it stay busy after the initial buzz.

Palm Palm bills itself as coastal, though the concept leans more on sensibility than sourcing. Palm Springs, after all, is a desert town more than 100 miles from the nearest ocean and has long had a more widespread dining rubric than “fresh fish of the day.”

Just as at Ritual House, Ed Smith is the restaurant’s executive chef.

Advertise with us

Smith’s eclectic menu favors small plates meant for sharing, though there are a good number of larger-format steak and seafood dishes as well. Some dishes play it straight. Others reimagine childhood memories through an upscale filter and a few take a contemporary spin. Vegetarians, take note: There's a lot for you to like here.

“We tried to create a concept based on the way we eat when we dine out,” says Herky Pollock. “We like restaurants where we can order the whole left side of the menu and share plates. It’s an experience, that’s what’s most important. Sharing foods with friends and family is really important.”

On my initial visit just after opening weekend, I found the loose framework generally a strength, but sometimes a pitfall. When the kitchen was focused, the results were satisfyingly playful, sometimes even eye-opening. When it wasn’t, the ambition felt as unmoored as the blueberry chimichurri sauce served with a room-temperature flat iron steak.

Palm Palm puts a playful spin on a classic pairing with its grilled cheese & tomato soup dumplings. (Samara McCallum / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The grilled cheese and tomato soup dumplings exemplify Smith’s best instincts. A quartet of them were lined up in spoons atop a wooden serving tray, delicate wrappers filled with tangy tomato puree, a buttery, oozing cheese and brightly herbaceous garnish. The novel starter called to mind after-school snacks and sick-day lunches, but as if they were composed by someone with a chinois instead of my mom.

“Truffled Spaghettios” sounded like a gimmick to me, but landed as pure indulgence: tender pasta rings in a rich, truffle-laced cheese sauce. Naming the dish after the mealy noodles in tinny tomato sauce borders on satire, but works exquisitely as a shareable you have no intention of sharing with anybody else.

Advertise with us

Pastry chef Giovanna Henrique’s lineup of desserts deliver a similar mix of whimsy and joy. All four I tried were vibrantly eye-catching (some actually glittery), layered and balanced. The Brazilian-born artisan of sweet finishes is a rising star Pittsburgh ought to keep its eyes on.

Other dishes were solid but could be pressed further once the kitchen settles into a rhythm.

Lettuce wraps have a vintage flavor profile and a satisfying kick, but our plate was delivered with just three small pieces of lettuce, not enough for the portion on the plate. I think this could fairly be chalked up to opening week learning curve, and the kitchen did deliver more promptly on request.

Sushi tots served as a fun spin on spicy tuna rolls transformed into stoner tater tots, with crisped sushi rice subbing for the potatoes.

Not every dish at Palm Palm has found its footing. The flat iron steak was the most confusing plate of the evening. With its chewy texture, muddled sauce and no accompaniment, it landed well short of its $50 price point.

Advertise with us

Bluefin tuna steak, cooked ruby rare aside from a nice sear, is a stronger choice for a large plate. An 8-ounce portion of high-quality loin was sliced thin and dressed with pistachio, sesame and sweet soy, with a generous serving of seasoned sushi rice a solid pairing.

Caviar-topped pomme frites also missed the mark. The spiralized potatoes arrived gummy, the aioli had off notes and the overall effect of the commercial caviar was more muddled than luxe. Mussels, while built on a sauce with a pleasant tropical profile, were undercut by tired, sandy shellfish. A few frites or a slice of bread from the in-house bakery to sop up the broth might have helped redeem the dish.

Palm Palm’s beverage program is led by Sarah Hoffman, a respected vet in Pittsburgh’s hospitality scene. One cocktail came across as overly saccharine in the first few sips, but settled into something more balanced and airy. Another landed well from the start. Both were stunning to look at and have me excited to work my way through the rest of her bespoke menu. Hoffman’s wine list is thoughtfully curated but the beer list feels like an afterthought.

Pastry chef Giovanna Henrique’s desserts are must-gets. (Samara McCallum / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Service at Palm Palm is notably strong for such an ambitious operation with a platoon of new hires. The restaurant employs more than 100 staff members, only four of whom transferred from Ritual House.

The team is enthusiastic, if sometimes verging on charmingly overly rehearsed. That’s fine. It’s early in the restaurant’s run and there’s a sense that everyone wants to get it right; in a room that leans theatrical, that level of care matters.

Advertise with us

Back-of-house handled pacing smartly, and the front-of-house crew hits marks that sometimes go neglected: proper silverware swaps, a clean table reset during a tour of the private dining rooms and attentive (if sometimes overbearing) check-ins. Even when we asked our server questions that didn’t have immediate answers, his response was direct and followed by prompt follow-through.

“We root our restaurant group in hospitality and taking care of the customer. It’s incumbent on us to make every single person feel welcome here. Everyone should be comfortable,” Herky Pollock says.

Palm Palm isn’t aiming for subtlety. Its mission is to dazzle and entertain for the time you’re there.

“I feel like I’m on a road trip right now,” my pal said part-way through our meal.

On opening weekend, the diverse crowd in the dining room was peppered with people dressed as if for vacation — statement prints, linen suits, coordinated handbags and a few with lighting systems attached to their iPhones.

Advertise with us

In spite of some flaws, there’s something refreshing about a restaurant that aims so unabashedly for joy, even if its particular aesthetic won’t land for everyone. A little glitter goes a long way right now.

“Life is stressful. Life is tense now. There are a lot of external pressures that are out of our control,” Herky Pollock says. “If you can take a vacation from your life, experience some joy and forget what’s going on in the world for an hour or two, we’ve done our job.”

5996 Centre Ave., Shadyside; palmpalmpgh.com