5 Generation Bakers — known for its signature Jenny Lee Swirl Breads and other baked goods and mixes — has expanded its footprint in Pittsburgh with the grand opening Wednesday of a breakfast place in Moon.
The menu at Jenny Lee Breakfast Nook, located at 1014 Brodhead Road, features the bakery’s famed breads in sweet and savory dishes including breakfast sandwiches, gourmet grilled cheese, French toast and smash burgers. They also have a small selection of soups, salads and side dishes that include house-made chips and loaded potato salad. Nothing costs more than $14.
The restaurant will also serve as an outlet for other baked goods, including seasonal breads, while open every day except Monday from 7 a.m.-2 p.m.
Scott Baker, 5 Generations president and founder, hopes the new venture is just the beginning of getting more of the bakery’s products into customers’ hands.
“I want to find more outlets for the bread,” he said.
Jenny Lee products are sold in thousands of businesses and restaurants, as well as in the bakery’s retail shop on Chartiers Avenue in McKees Rocks.
So, he thought, why not open a restaurant with the Jenny Lee name?
“People would always tell us it [Jenny Lee’s cinnamon swirl bread] makes the best French toast,” said Baker, who grew up working at his family’s Jenny Lee Bakery, which was in business from 1875 to 2008. He opened the rebranded McKees Rocks-based spinoff 5 Gen in 2010.
After years of thinking about it, Baker pitched the idea to some of friends in the lead-up to last year’s Picklesburgh fest. Within 24 hours, they all agreed to be a part of the venture and, a year later, the six business partners — RJ Carrabbia, Rich Bufalini, Rocco Bufalini, Jason Stevens, Jack Hunt and Baker — were ready to launch in the space that formerly held A Taste of Ita-Lee. Combined they have more than 200 years of experience in the restaurant business.
Stevens, who has been working in restaurants since he was 16, previously cooked at Sarafino’s, Con Alma and Pizza Roma. Carrabbia, the general manager, ran Krazy Dogz hot dog shop on East Carson Street on the South Side for three years before opening the small family diner Broadway Brunch in McKees Rocks in 2014. The COVID-19 pandemic forced its closure in 2021.
Carrabbia said he was drawn both by the brand, which is iconic in Pittsburgh, and the catering work he’s done over the years for Baker, a lifelong friend. After four years out of the restaurant business — he worked in contracting after the pandemic — he was also eager to get back to cooking and serving customers.
That Baker was looking to launch a restaurant at exactly the same time he was thinking about opening another hot dog shop was happenstance.
“It all just kind of fell in place,” Carrabbia said.
“It’s not every day that a company like Jenny Lee knocks on your door and asks you to do something with them,” he noted.
Baker said it’s sort of homecoming for him to be working in Moon since he grew up and went to high school there.
“My heart is tied to this community,” he said.
A small detail included in eatery’s front desk counter pays homage to both sides of his family. His cousin Tom Buckle crafted it using screws left behind by Baker’s maternal grandfather, Al Milletary, who was a construction worker.
Carrabbia noted that the restaurant doesn’t have servers — food runners bring food to the tables. Customers can dine in as well as order out.
“We don’t want to make fast food. We want to make good food fast,” he said.
The partners hope to open three more breakfast spots in the next year. They also want to eventually do pop-up dinners, Carrabbia said.
Food Editor Gretchen McKay contributed to this story.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.