Table manners have evolved over the years, always with the goal of making eating in public pleasant and sociable for everyone.

While modern dining reflects a shift toward casualness, inclusivity and personal preference, even the most seasoned diner can feel a little unanchored when it comes to table manners and fine dining.

These tips and advice from those who work in the industry can help make your next dining experience go a little more smoothly.

Put your phone away

Nearly all etiquette experts agree that you should put your phone on silent in a restaurant and not take or make calls at the table. But they disagree on whether it’s OK to have your phone on the table or to text or scroll in a white tablecloth restaurant.

Advertise with us

The Emily Post Institute says it’s bad manners to use your phone at the table, whether it’s for texting, checking social media or taking calls. While enjoying a meal, it’s polite to be present and engaged with others at the table.

But it’s OK for diners to have their phones on the table, says Moses Cunningham, a Mt. Lebanon resident who has been a server for over 30 years in fine dining establishments, including the renowned Bookbinder’s Seafood House in Philadelphia. However, he says it has been “eye-opening” to see the number of people who are on their phones in restaurants these days.

“It doesn’t bother me that they have their phones, but I am surprised that they would go out for a good meal and get so caught up in their electronics,” he said.

Scott Offenbach, managing partner and owner of Ruth’s Chris Steak House in Downtown Pittsburgh, also is not fazed by cellphones at the table, especially with little diners.

“One positive is that little kids can be entertained and not be disruptive to others,” he said. “I think it’s good to expose children to fine dining every now and then and to teach them dining manners.”

Advertise with us

Saturday and Sunday are family nights at Ruth’s Chris. While the restaurant does not have a children’s menu, they do offer child-friendly options such as hamburgers, chicken fingers, shoestring fries and buttered pasta.

Even when kids aren’t around, cell phones are often out.

“I always wonder when I see people on their phones whether they have anything to talk about,” Offenbach said.

Elbows off the table?

While your grandmother may have corrected you for resting your elbows on the table during meals, it’s OK these days, experts say.

The Emily Post Institute says it is acceptable to have your elbows on the table before, between and after courses, and Cunningham and Offenbach agree.

Advertise with us

However, be sure to keep your elbows away from dishes and tableware, Emily Post noted. You may find gravy or steak sauce on them.

Where is your napkin?

Most people know your napkin goes in your lap once everyone is seated. But what if you get up? Cunningham recommends placing it to the left of your plate or hanging it over the back of the chair.

Resting it on the plate or the seat of the chair risks transferring food smears to your chair or clothes. “And if you drop your napkin on the floor, please ask for a new one,” he said.

When you are finished with your meal and ready to leave, Offenbach agrees that the back of the chair or next to your plate are good spots to leave your napkin.

Chew on this

During the COVID-19 epidemic, many people got away from eating out and some forgot it’s bad manners to talk with your mouth full or chew with it open. No “see-food” here. It’s not worth alienating your fellow diners.

Advertise with us

Who orders first?

Cunningham said that he always takes women’s orders first. However, he has sometimes seen them defer to the host. The benefit for guests is that they can take their cues from someone who’s eaten there before.

“Personally, I like my guests to order first so that they can get what they want,” he said.

Offenbach suggests letting hosts order first since they are the ones paying for the meal.

Emily Post says it is most important to be considerate of others and to avoid any awkwardness and discomfort when ordering. It is considered taboo to order something more expensive than the host, although Offenbach said he has seen it happen on more than a few occasions.

Dressing for dinner

Another COVID casualty was the idea of dressing up for dinner. Ruth’s Chris Steak House does not have a dress code, and most fine dining establishments do not either.

Advertise with us

While you don’t need to be “dressed to the nines,” Emily Post recommends taking into consideration other diners at the restaurant and dressing appropriately. In general, that means a collared shirt and trousers for men and a nice blouse with pants or skirt for women.

If something is not right

If your steak isn’t cooked to order, your scallops come cold or you’re not happy with your choice, discreetly get your server’s attention and let them know so they can make it right.

“It’s not good for any guest to fight through food they don’t like,” Cunningham said. “We can always exchange it.

“We want people to have a good experience, and my goal is to do whatever I can to ensure that occurs.”

Offenbach agreed.

Advertise with us

“People should feel comfortable going into a restaurant and letting the server know if something isn’t right,” he said.

“We want people to be honest and give us a chance to correct it. Our goal is to provide good hospitality.”

Both Cunningham and Offenbach said the most important thing is for diners to feel that they were heard and valued.

“We can’t make it right if we don’t know about it,” Cunningham said.

How long to linger?

Your meal is finished, you’ve had dessert and coffee and paid your bill. But you’re having a good time and don’t want to leave. Is it OK to stay longer?

Advertise with us

There is no time limit at his current restaurant, Cunningham said, but he believes that once the check is presented and paid, the experience is over.

If you do want to stay awhile, he suggests ordering dessert, a shared plate or a round of cocktails. At the very least, it’s good manners to ask the server if someone else is waiting for the table.

Offenbach has a different philosophy.

“When we first opened Ruth’s Chris Pittsburgh, [founder] Ruth Fertel visited us and said, ‘When someone comes into the restaurant, they’ve bought the table for the night.’

“Now if the whole dining room did that, that would be an issue. But generally, it evens out,” he said.

Advertise with us

While the Emily Post Institute doesn’t specifically address the issue, its experts suggest that after the bill is paid, it’s best to thank the host and say goodbye. This allows others waiting for a table to enjoy a meal and it gives the server the opportunity to accommodate another party that evening.

What about tipping?

While tipping is always a controversial subject, it is appreciated and expected if the service is good and diners had an enjoyable experience. Tips often account for more than half the income of servers and bartenders and tips are sometimes shared with cooks and other workers.

At Ruth’s Chris Steak House, servers make $2.83 per hour, so tips make up most of their income.

How much to tip varies depending on the guest, the quality of the service and whether a standard gratuity is included on the bill.

One thing is certain: If the server did everything they could to give you a pleasurable experience, do not penalize them for something that the kitchen or someone else did, especially if they did their best to rectify it.

Advertise with us

While a standard tip is 15-20% of the pre-tax amount of the bill, Cunningham encourages guests to consider the service they received rather than the amount of the bill when determining the tip.

“If I’ve gone above and beyond to give you a good experience — an extra glass of wine, a free side dish — I wish people would consider that. On the other hand, if I’m not attentive to you, or you don’t feel that I gave you excellent service, the tip should reflect that as well.

“Servers should be present or in eyes’ view within a certain amount of time so that they are available to the guest,” he said.

The Emily Post Institute encourages diners to not only tip generously for excellent service, but also to treat servers with respect. A tip does not make up for being inconsiderate.

Tip discreetly and use cash if possible, the experts say. That way It goes immediate to the server or staff, and they don’t need to wait to see it in their paycheck.

Advertise with us

While dining etiquette will continue to evolve with the times, the emphasis will always be on giving diners a pleasurable experience.

“Use us for information,” Cunningham said. “We are there to give you an honest opinion about the food and what will give you the most enjoyable evening out.”

Abby Kirkland (abbykirkland77@gmail.com) is a freelance writer living in Mt. Lebanon.