On March 18, 2020, Bar Marco owner Justin Steel was delivering meals door-to-door to loyal customers of his Strip District restaurant.
Just two days earlier, then-Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf ordered all restaurants closed for on-premise dining for two weeks as part of his plan to mitigate potential public health consequences stemming from a then-novel coronavirus known as COVID-19.
“When we first shut down it was, ‘What do we do? How long is this going to last and how will we keep things going?’” Steel says.
Over the next couple of years, the hospitality industry navigated a roller coaster of social distancing measures and fluctuating indoor dining closures as vaccination availability and new virus mutations created shifting safety protocols. Restaurant operators and staff had to find flexibility in keeping up with a worried — and sometimes overeager — dining public and figure out which mix of personal touches and technological innovations would be most helpful to keep business going.
All along, inflation added another layer of stress for business owners and restaurant employees.
Five years after COVID-19 first shuttered dining rooms, the restaurant industry in Pittsburgh and across the U.S. has largely recovered in sales — but operates on new terms.
Read More
Once-optional technology (online ordering, delivery integration, QR codes) is now common, though it’s still evolving as consumer preferences shift. Consumer behavior has changed, with more people enjoying restaurant food at home and rearranging their dining schedules around weekends or special occasions. Operations have been overhauled to be leaner and more flexible as restaurants face a new labor landscape and cost pressures.
“The immediacy of the concerns coming out of COVID has somewhat waned,” says Joe Massaro, president of the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association. “When you dig a little deeper, we're still seeing the effects five years later,” he says.
Fewer closings than you might think
The region lost a bunch of notable restaurants in the wake of the pandemic. Surprisingly, however, Allegheny County didn’t see a substantial shift in the average number of restaurant closings per year (somewhere around 750 establishments) compared to the five years before the pandemic.
In fact, a significantly lower number of closings, 539, were reported in 2020, though Allegheny County officials attribute the decrease to businesses not self-reporting closures.
“In 2020, the Food Safety Program (FSP) was focused on enforcing the COVID mitigation orders and conducting COVID assessments. At the time, confirming voluntary restaurant closings was not a priority for inspectors,” Amanda Mator, program manager for Allegheny County Health Department’s Food Safety Program, says in an email.
She also notes that the county extended a grace period for late fees on permitting, “which is typically another way the county finds out if food businesses have permanently closed.”
Mator says the slightly higher-than-average number of closings in 2021 is likely a result of the county playing catchup with the data.
“Towards the end of 2021 and into 2022, FSP started receiving closing notifications from business owners and began following up on unpaid permit fees,” she says.
Federal, state and local funding, including millions of dollars from the U.S. Small Business Administration’s Paycheck Protection Program and the Restaurant Revitalization Fund, helped keep restaurants afloat through the darkest months of the pandemic.
“Most operators have used all of their capital coming out of COVID, so now they aren't in a position to purchase new equipment or invest as much as they want in staff training,” Massaro says. “The question now is: How do we get past the effects of the pandemic and grow again?”
Higher baseline prices
Everything is just more expensive now.
Restaurants run on tight profit margins, typically between 3% and 5%. The biggest lingering issue affecting restaurant recovery remains inflation. According to data from the National Restaurant Association, food costs have risen 29% and labor 31% in the past four years, while restaurant prices increased by an average of 27.2% between February 2020 and June 2024.
“The industry is going through a lot of big changes right now because of the continued rise in the cost of ingredients. Everybody is talking about eggs, but that's just one small part of it,” says Aimee DiAndrea, co-owner of DiAnoia’s Eatery, Pane e Pronto and Pizzeria Davide, all in the Strip District.
Those aren’t the only costs that have skyrocketed. Supplies such as linens and flatware are up 20%, credit card swipe fees increased 32% and utilities have hiked too.
“Prices aren't going down for anything anytime soon,” says Steel.
Diners have grudgingly accepted it, but industry operators worry that prices can’t rise much higher without alienating customers.
“People understand the negative effects of inflation, credit card fees going up, energy prices up and rent is up. But you can't just counter that any longer with menu price increases,” Massaro says.
Operators now get creative by raising the price of one item while keeping another steady, using a single ingredient in multiple dishes instead of unique components for each, adjusting costs across multiple businesses or rethinking plate composition.
Restaurants streamlined menus due to labor and supply chain issues as well. According to the National Restaurant Association, 96% of restaurants experienced supply delays or shortages at the peak of the pandemic, and 75% adjusted their offerings in response. Because prices remain volatile, many have kept those changes. Curated menus remain a popular option for chefs to streamline operations.
When we eat
Operating hours, overall, tend to be shorter. And people are dining out earlier in the evening.
“Everybody used to want a 7:30 reservation. Now it's 5:30, 6, 6:30. You say 7:30 or 8, and people go ‘Oh, no,’” says Carmela Giaramita, co-owner of La Tavola on Mount Washington since 1994.
“That’s the biggest change. After 9 p.m., it’s dead. Forget about it,” says her husband and business partner, Joe Giaramita, who first slung pizza in Pittsburgh in 1965.
Although Pittsburgh hadn’t been a late-night town in years, there remained a smattering of all-hours diners and bars that opened at 6 a.m. to serve third-shift workers. Now, there are no locally owned 24-hour sit-down eateries left in or near the city. (IHOP in Squirrel Hill South is the place to go if you’re looking for a pre-dawn meal.)
Independent restaurateurs, facing tight labor and sometimes unpredictable customer traffic, often choose to go dark on traditionally slow days, including Mondays and Tuesdays.
“A lot of people went through big life changes,” says Kolin Smith, general manager of Apteka. “The pace is different now. We’re open fewer days a week and close at 10. Everyone is out the door much earlier than they were.”
The pace appears to be picking up, albeit slowly. Online reservation service OpenTable reports that “Wednesday is the new Friday,” with an 11% increase in midweek meals last year.
Although the heyday of the 24-hour diner is over — the last vestiges in the city such as Ritter’s ended all-night service in 2020 and PileZ, an attempt at a 24/7 eatery, closed in January after less than a year in business — there is some anecdotal evidence that late-night demand is picking up, with the introduction of after-hours service at Downtown’s Bae Bae’s, Saturday nights at The Vandal and spots such as Little Corner Grill House.
Drinking habits have changed
One way many restaurants make up for low margins on food is by selling alcohol; bar profit margins can hit as high as 80%. Post-pandemic, many restaurant goers are drinking less overall, and more deliberately when they choose to imbibe.
According to a blind survey by Toast, 29% of people 25 and over typically don’t drink alcohol when they are out.
“That’s a whole segment of profit contribution that is sinking significantly,” Massaro says. “The younger generation in particular isn't drinking as much.”
At Apteka, drinks averaged 37% of sales in 2018 and 34% in 2019. In 2023 and 2024, the percentages dropped down to 33% and 31%, respectively.
Smith attributes the 6% overall decline since 2018 to factors including lifestyle changes as a result of the pandemic, a significant improvement in alcohol-free drink options and an overall post-pandemic shift in the nature of Apteka.
“We were in our 20s when we started this. We had DJs a lot of nights and carved out a space that was there for drinking culture and later nights,” he says. That included the popular Sunday night wind down Lonely No More, where Apteka’s ambitious cocktail program took center stage.
Nowadays kompot, a traditional Eastern European beverage made from steamed fruit (picked or foraged at its peak season), sugar and carbonated water is Apteka’s number one selling beverage “by a lot.”
“It tastes fresh and it’s beautiful, and people are excited to order it. It’s something we didn’t have on the menu before the pandemic,” Smith says, noting the nonalcoholic menu is vastly expanded to include foraged tea blends and house-made sodas. “We go out of our way to make it special for people who don’t want to drink alcohol.”
When people do drink, Smith says, they tend to explore Apteka’s natural wines, often opting for full bottles. Like many Pittsburgh restaurants, Apteka added a takeaway wine shop when on-premise dining was restricted. Smith, along with owners Kate Lasky and Tomasz Skowronski, built a list of hard-to-find (at least in Pennsylvania) natural wines primarily from Eastern Europe.
“People ask a lot for recommendations for drinks and they are remarkably open-minded when I suggest things that they might not know about,” he says. “Part of the reason they are coming to the restaurant is because they want to have that guided experience.”
Delivery delivers
One of the most profound post-pandemic shifts has been the sustained demand for delivery and takeout. When dining rooms closed in 2020, off-premise dining in the form of carryout, curbside pickup and delivery became a lifeline for restaurants.
Consumers, out of necessity, embraced online ordering and third-party delivery apps in unprecedented numbers. That habit has declined a bit since the height of the pandemic but remains strong. Even with dining rooms fully open, many Americans continue to order takeout way more often than in 2019.
The National Restaurant Association’s 2024 report notes that 67% of millennials and 63% of Gen Z adults regularly order delivery or takeout.
Nearly half of restaurants say off-premise dining makes up a larger share of their business now than prior to the pandemic. The number is higher for fast-casual and quick-service restaurants, but 43% of full-service establishments report a permanent uptick in takeout and third-party delivery.
“Takeout wasn't part of our restaurant before COVID, and now it is a big part of our business,” says DiAndrea.
It’s likely COVID accelerated this trend more than defined it. It’s simply much easier with today’s technology to have food delivered to your home or workplace or scheduled for pickup at a specific time than it was five or 10 years ago; that drawer of menus from Chinese takeout and pizza delivery spots is a thing of the past for many.
“What can we give them on-premises that they can't find in their house? It all comes down to offering an experience,” Massaro says.
Tipping never really shifted
Touch screens now prompt diners to tip for seemingly every transaction, making it feel like tipping culture should have shifted significantly. Yet nationwide data from Toast indicates that tipping habits haven’t changed much — prior to, during or after the pandemic.
The average tip at full-service restaurants was 19.6% of the bill in the final quarter of 2019 and 19.3% in the final quarter of 2024, with Pennsylvania averaging 20.5% at the end of last year. Tipping at quick-service restaurants has shown a slightly higher fall off, with tips at 16.5% and 15.8% during the same periods, with Pa. landing at 16.1%
According to Investopedia, Gen Z diners are the least likely to tip at quick service and fast casual establishments.
QR code overload
QR codes were everywhere in the early part of the pandemic. The patterned squares were seen as a convenient, contactless solution viewed to aid in sanitation. By late 2020 and through much of 2021, scanning a QR code at the table to view a digital menu had become commonplace.
Most diners, however, reacted negatively, with some finding these menus challenging to navigate and many disliking the idea of more screen time during social interactions. According to a 2024 survey by U.S. Foods, 90% of diners prefer print menus over QR codes, a rise from 74% in 2023.
Nevertheless, QR code menus are here to stay, particularly with more casual concepts. Digital menus offer restaurateurs easy menu updating features, such as adding specials and pulling off sold-out items. There’s also cost savings in not having to reprint menus.
One thing you’re almost certainly going to see more of: QR codes on the bill, allowing for quick, easy payment.
Forward momentum
While meal kits and other DIY ideas have largely fallen by the wayside, other ideas that rose to prominence in the early 2020s have stuck around.
Uncertainty of demand and capacity during reopening led many restaurants to adopt reservation requirements or ticketed dining experiences. Cancellation fees for no-shows or last-minute cancellations, once rare, are now more common, especially at high-demand restaurants. This change, while sometimes irksome to customers, has helped independents reduce revenue loss from unpredictable customer attendance.
Pop-ups exploded as a survival strategy for chefs during COVID. The trend has cooled a bit, but the notion of utilizing space when a restaurant would otherwise be closed carries on.
Staffing is back to pre-pandemic levels, but still hasn’t recovered from the loss of generational knowledge.
Stronger online presence for restaurants via multiple social media channels, direct online ordering and digital branding are non-negotiable for most establishments, particularly those that cater to younger demographics.
And importantly, people want to continue to reconnect in deeper ways.
“They’re going out to have a whole experience,” Smith says. “You see an intense desire for people to be out and have a great time at a restaurant with the people they are there with, and with the staff too. I don’t take that for granted at all, because being in a room with all of these people is something that’s very special.”
OpenTable claims in its 2025 trends survey that 54% of restaurant goers plan to dine out more often this year. Group experiences look to be on the rise as well — 43% of respondents are looking for larger group meals and 42% are hungry for experiential dining such as tasting menus and themed dining experiences.
“Those special communal tables are back, which is great to see,” says DiAndrea
The train keeps moving
Justin Steel’s time as a door-to-door delivery guy didn’t last very long. He and his staff pivoted several times, offering some takeout options such as braised meats and later moving into an outdoor dining era in the restaurant’s previously underutilized courtyard.
“We struggled hard through a couple of winters,” Steel says.
Bar Marco reopened for indoor dining in early 2022 with a $45, two-course prix-fixe menu. It was a tough decision for Steel because he knew it would change the tenor of the restaurant from a place where people would stop by for various reasons (a quick drink and a snack after work, a lingering meal where more friends would join partway through, a nightcap, etc.) to destination dining.
“We are a small restaurant already, and for a time we were even shorter because of the distancing restrictions, so we had to guarantee a certain check average to make sure we could stay open,” he says.
Steel plans to move Bar Marco back to an a la carte model in the next few weeks. He says he feels the momentum has shifted enough to move back to a place where they can move forward rather than just doing the best they can to get by.
“In 2019, there was a pulse to this place. It was like a train going a little too fast on its tracks, but in a way that felt really good,” he says. “It feels like we're getting more nights like that back. We can feel the pulse again. But it's a little different, and probably always will be.”
Sono Motoyama contributed reporting for this story.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.