Why open a restaurant when you’re already juggling several successful businesses?
Ask Brian Mendelssohn, co-owner and proprietor behind the just-opened Main Street Diner in the basement of Lawrenceville Market House on Butler Street.
Mendelssohn and his brother, Irwin, own Botero Devolopment and operate Lawrenceville Market House, which houses several small Pittsburgh-based retail businesses.
They opened Oliver’s Donuts, a bakery and cafe in the lobby of the Market House, in early 2022, and Fulton Commons, a co-working space and commissary kitchen in Manchester, in 2019.
The Mendelssohns also own Bierport Tap Room and Row House Cinema on the other side of Butler Street and are in the process of revamping the Hollywood Theater in Dormont into a second Row House.
“We always had to utilize the space down here to make the Market House work financially,” Brian said. “It isn't a good space for retail businesses. So what can we do with it?"
Read More
He felt like a traditional restaurant wouldn’t be a good fit for the subterranean space, which has breezy high ceilings but no windows. Creating something thematic, but not overly kitschy and still family-friendly, felt like the best approach.
He landed on the idea of opening a classic Main Street-style diner, but wrapping it around a design inspired by filmmaker Tim Burton.
“If you like ‘Beetlejuice’, you’ll love it here,” Mendelssohn says.
The opening menu is pretty straightforward. Think burgers, chicken tenders, milkshakes and the like. And Mendelssohn plans to expand the diner’s offerings with items such as meatloaf as the new kitchen staff settles into its rhythm.
An early standout is the diner’s pierogi, crafted from his Polish mother-in-law’s recipe (and named “Marta’s Pierogies” in homage to his wife). Hand-rolled and pinched, the dumplings have a tender-crisp skin when pan fried, and are stuffed generously with nicely seasoned potato and cheese filling.
Main Street also added a tavern-style burger to serve in tandem with the smashburger originally offered at Simply Burgers, the takeout window that preceded the diner.
It’s meant to hearken back to the fantastic burger sometimes served as a special at Smoke Barbeque Taqueria, which is closing Sept. 16. (Botero Development owns the building that houses the popular restaurant.)
"I loved that burger so much. So many people did. This is an ode to it. I wanted to make sure a burger that's like it stayed in the neighborhood," Mendelssohn says.
Opening his first restaurant presented a litany of new challenges for Mendelssohn, who says the establishment is still a work-in-progress.
“We've had the kitchen open for more than a year as Simply Burgers, but when you add an expanded menu and full service, there are a lot of details you need to get right.”
He found encouragement in an unexpected place.
When Kickback Pinball Cafe closed in April up the block, the Mendelssohn brothers purchased the machines.
“The restaurant was ready, but I was hesitating to open because, frankly, I was scared to do it. When the owners of Kickback got in touch, I jumped on it. I can't imagine this neighborhood without a true pinball arcade,” he says.
Mendelssohn is an avid pinball player who even participated in the Professional Amateur Pinball Association’s massive championship tournaments. They were held annually as part of Replay FX arcade conventions at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center until the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
“[Pinball] solved some problems for me. It took away tables — which will make service easier — and it added an extra element and one that's family friendly,” he says.
Bars offering arcade-like amenities such as pinball, video games and duckpin bowling has become a popular way to have a night out. Pittsburgh sports several of them including Coop De Ville, Shorty’s and Barcadia, but drinks are at the forefront and games are seen as an amenity.
Mendelssohn looks at the setup through a more old-school lens; the full bar program is there as an amenity to the games and the meals.
“We're not trying to be neo-nostalgia, but it does fit that definition in some way. It's not an ode to the past. It's picking great things we had in diners and arcades and making it something relevant for today.”
Mendelssohn says that brunch service is expected soon, with lunch and late night on weekends a longer-term goal. Look for pinball leagues and tournaments, too.
“If you're 35 and want to have a drink or two, it's great. If you're 16 and live around here, it's welcoming for you. If you have a family, you'll feel good coming here,” he says.
4112 Butler St., Lawrenceville; mainstreetpgh.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.