Just days after news of 40 North at Alphabet City’s sudden closure broke earlier this week, the restaurant's next steps were announced in an email written by Kathy Bzdziak, CFO of 40 North LLC, the management company that leases the restaurant space. The correspondence was sent to the City of Asylum’s email list.

The restaurant will reopen in several weeks as Alfabeto, a modern approach to Northern Italian cuisine under the purview of executive chef Maurizio Esposito.

The abrupt announcement marks the end of a heralded restaurant run by a two-time James Beard semifinalist, while its owners pursue a new vision for a space that has held three restaurants in seven-plus years.

Bzdziak said that the company wanted to move in a new direction because sales were lagging.

Advertise with us

City of Asylum, the nonprofit dedicated to providing “sanctuary to endangered writers and artists,” owns the North Side building and operates an attached performance venue and bookstore. It is not involved in the day-to-day operations of the restaurant space beyond coordinating with the staff about upcoming performances.

Esposito, chef de cuisine at Fish nor Fowl in Garfield for the past seven months, came to Pittsburgh with nearly 36 years of experience running fine dining and high-end restaurant kitchens, primarily in Melbourne, Australia, along with stints in cities including London, Paris and Florence, Italy.

“I’ve been at this a long time and I’m looking forward to bringing my modern approach to Northern Italian food to Pittsburgh,” he says.

Esposito notes that the menu at Alfabeto, which is expected to open by the end of August, will be highly seasonal.

“It’s a funny word because sometimes things can be in season for just a few weeks,” he says, noting how he was impressed with Western Pennsylvania's brief but delicious springtime run of ramps and morel mushrooms.

Advertise with us

Esposito is a pedigreed chef with more than enough experience to helm a prestige restaurant in Pittsburgh, but there’s also a personal connection to the new venture: Esposito’s wife, Caro Llewellyn, became City of Asylum's executive director in January.

Bethany Zozula, 40 North’s executive chef, says she was expecting the LLC’s owner, Douglas “Woody” Ostrow, to come in on Sunday afternoon to discuss how to pay the staff during a scheduled closure for floor renovations in early August.

Instead, she says, he came in just five minutes before the expected start of the evening’s dinner service to let her know that there would be a forthcoming change of concept and that her services wouldn’t be needed after the upcoming week, which she was asked to work before a week of severance pay kicked in.

Zozula, a two-time James Beard award semifinalist (and one of very few women executive chefs in Pittsburgh) who’d helmed the kitchen since it opened in 2021, says she found the offer offensive.

Ostrow, currently in China according to Bzdziak, wasn’t available for comment.

Advertise with us

“I believe what City of Asylum does for writers and the community is incredibly important, and the bookstore is part of what makes Pittsburgh great, but the disrespect that is being shown in this ‘refresh’ is astounding,” Zozula says.

Staff at the restaurant say they were informed of the decision moments after Zozula, and received a similar offer.

“Then he [Ostrow] said we would close for a few weeks and reopen as a Northern Italian restaurant, anyone who works there can apply, and most people would be rehired,” says one former employee, speaking on the condition of anonymity, citing concerns about a potential unemployment settlement lawsuit.

“I’m not here for a smear campaign, but we were fired. We did not walk out. We were verbally asked to leave. It’s not decent behavior,” they say.

Bzdziak declined to comment on exactly what happened that day, July 28. “I don’t want to put words into people’s mouths since I wasn’t there,” she says.

Advertise with us

“The menu wasn’t changing a lot. We just wanted to have a new direction to boost business and get a fresher clientele,” Bzdziak says.

Zozula notes that she recently spoke with Ostrow about summer menu changes and told him she was happy to continue the dialogue.

“We just made it through winter, which is a tough time to change menus when you’re a restaurant that highlights locally grown produce.

“ In the growing season, we change the menu constantly, even if it’s just a little bit,” Zozula says, noting that even as headline items such as chicken or steak remained consistent, other components the dishes were served with, including sauces, could change as often as daily during the peak growing season.

“It’s also not strange for a restaurant to have a consistent menu,” she says. “You want people to talk about a dish they loved and return with friends to get it again.”

Advertise with us

Esposito says he wasn’t part of discussions about the rationale behind a change of concepts.

“All I can say in regards to that is that Woody Ostrow asked me to come in to do something that he was very passionate about,” he says, adding that he hopes people will allow Alfabeto to stand as a new restaurant.

“I’m just excited about being able to cook beautiful food and respect the ingredients of Pennsylvania, and to give guests a beautiful experience,” he says.

Correction (made Aug. 3 at 4:30 p.m.): An earlier version of this story misspelled the name of the restaurant replacing 40 North at Alphabet City. It will be called Alfabeto.