Welcome back to peak ice cream season, Pittsburgh. With the prolonged heat wave this July, we need some sweet relief.
For the past two years, we’ve offered a list of five spots that we love: Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream, Page’s, Antney’s Ice Cream, Hank’s Frozen Custard and Mexican Food and Mitch’s Barbecue in 2022 and Happy Day Dessert Factory, Tastyland, LaScola’s Italian Ice and Custard, Mercurio's and Treat Down the Street last year.
Here are five more places to add to your list.
Leona’s Scoop Shop at Lawrence Hall
Katie Heldstab and Christa Puskarich founded Leona’s Ice Cream in 2014, biking their signature array of ice cream sandwiches around town to farmers markets and festivals. Over the next decade, the dynamic duo built a miniature empire with their products, which are treated with an enzyme to make them lactose-free.
You’ll find packaged Leona’s ice cream sandwiches, with flavors such as black sesame on salted tahini chocolate chunk, coffee on snickerdoodle and Key lime on graham in branded cases or the freezer section of more than 70 locations ranging as far from Downtown as Wheeling, W.Va.
Heldstab and Puskarich opened their first scoop shop in Lawrence Hall on Butler Street in Lawrenceville in May.
The duo’s signature cookie sandwiches are still available, but fans old and new now have the option to order scoops as well. Rotating flavors such as the vibrantly purple, marshmallow-ish ube and a speckled cinnamon spin that recalls breakfast cereal are available to be eaten in-house or via takeaway from the street-facing window.
A bonus: You’re in a food hall with four restaurant concepts and a full bar.
4609 Butler St., Lawrenceville; leonaspgh.com
Glen's Frozen Custard
There’s less air in frozen custard than in ice cream, which gives it a texture that melds the smoothness of soft serve with a denser texture than a scoop. Frozen custard, which typically also includes egg yolks, is particularly popular in Midwestern cities like Milwaukee and St. Louis. We tend to favor a broader mix of ice cream family styles in Western Pennsylvania, though frozen custard is a longstanding part of that mix.
Glen’s Frozen Custard, opened in 1948, is one of the mainstays of Pittsburgh summertime fun. It's just what I look for from a classic era roadside custard stand: a wide selection of frozen treats available in cones, cups, sundaes, splits, floats and sandwiches (here called Glenwiches).
Glen’s opened a production facility earlier this year in Lower Burrell, where it now produces a wide variety of seasonal and staple flavors. Whitehouse cherry is on the menu for the rest of July, and chocolate peanut butter cup is served in August.
A bonus: The older location in Springdale has miniature golf. The relatively newer Cheswick location, opened in 2010, offers a menu of diner-style dishes and dine-in seating.
Springdale: 400 Pittsburgh St.
Lower Burrell: 2796 Leechburg Road
PaPa J’s Twin Plaza
Just like frozen custard, gelato also ranks high among Western Pennsylvania’s favorite ice cream treats. This is somewhat due to the region’s large population of people boasting Italian heritage and because a well-made gelato is downright dreamy.
My go-to move when craving gelato in Pittsburgh is to make a beeline for the indulgently delicious offerings at Papa J’s in the Strip District, where gelato is prepared with attention to detail in Italian-made machines. Owner Michael Troiani added the confection to Papa J’s roster when he reopened the business, which closed in Carnegie following a catastrophic fire in 2018, in the Strip District in 2022
The establishment’s traditional Italian flavors, such as hazelnut and pistachio, are wickedly delicious. Both taste true to sense memories that drew me back to my first time enjoying them in Italy. (If you haven’t had a proper pistachio, you’re in for a real treat; cheaply-made versions tend to have a chemical flavor.)
Also on the menu are rotating selections like wild cherry. In this case, Papa J’s takes something often given to oversweetness and offers a bite with a slightly sour, almost cheesecake-like base enlivened by bright, sweet ribbons of cherry running through it.
A bonus: Grab a cut or two of Papa J’s excellent Roman-style pizza for takeaway or a seat in the dining room for a meal.
2016 Smallman St., Strip District; papajs.com
Meccha Matcha
Are you looking for ice cream with a kick? Head to Meccha Matcha in Squirrel Hill. The mini-chain, which specializes in frozen treats made with the Japanese powdered green tea matcha, opened its third location in April (the others are in Texas and California).
You’ll find three levels of caffeination (and corresponding notes of bitterness) in the soft serve and scoops. Level one offers 85 milligrams., about as much as a cup of coffee, and level three kicks things up to a pretty wild 255 mg per serving.

There are alternatives if you prefer to avoid getting jacked up on ice cream. Weekly soft-serve specials, such as sweet and floral lavender, and scoops, including one featuring the aromatic pandan plant native to Southeast Asia, provide a soothing stand-in to the shop’s signature flavor.
A bonus: The bright Murray Avenue spot with ample seating offers three grades of ground Japanese matcha (culinary, ceremonial and hojicha).
2000 Murray Ave., Squirrel Hill; mecchamatcha.com
SpectroDolce Confectionary
One of the region’s most charming ice cream counters is inside the Monroeville Mall. That’s where you’ll find SpectroDolce, an offshoot of Autism Employment Network. The South Side-based nonprofit offers various life-changing services to people on the autism spectrum, including an opportunity for individuals to learn essential workplace skills at the Monroeville confectionery.
SpectroDolce serves Perry’s Ice Cream. The Erie County, N.Y., business started scooping more than 100 years ago and prepares 75-plus flavors for wholesale and retail sales. SpectroDolce offers 15 choices ranging from vanilla and cookie dough classics to specialty items like “Deep Sea Treasure” (a caramel ice cream studded with salty twirls and caramel truffles) and Oregon blackberry cheesecake.
You can get the silky, smooth ice cream in scoops (even as a flight of flavors), cones or whipped into a milkshake.
A bonus: SpectroDolce’s primary focus is preparing and selling confectionery such as chocolate truffles, gummy candies and gourmet fudge. Also, you're in a weird throwback mall.
711 Mall Circle Drive, Monroeville; spectrodolce.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.