Side by side, a Golden Russet and an Ashmead’s Kernel resemble identical twins.
The two apples are canvased in green-gold, streaked with occasional hints of blush. Both are layered with a rough, burnished tan overcoat. A casual grocery store shopper would be hard-pressed to notice the differences between them in a bin.
You won’t, however, find either of those apples at the local megamart. The divergence from their cosmetic similarities is a case in point for why Pittsburgh is lucky to have at least one orchardist who geeks out, hard, on variety.
“I’m a niche marketer. What I’m selling here is distinct. I can’t tell you how many times people told me I’ve ruined them from getting apples at the grocery store,” says Aaron Sturges, founder and chief apple guy at Sturges Orchard in Fombell, Beaver County.
Golden Russet is a little knobbier, with slightly wart-like bumps. The American apple, likely first discovered in upstate New York in the early to mid-1800s, is versatile. It’s tannic enough for cider, yet its sweetly acidic, juicy and crisp flavor makes for an excellent eating apple if you’re looking for complexity.
Ashmead’s Kernel is a 1750s English apple that smells like spring flowers and has a well-rounded, complex, full-bodied flavor that’s lemonade sweet, with a splashy burst when you bite into it. This variety is perfect for a late summer salad or as a base for feel-good juice with, say, carrots and celery.
Eating history

“This is an ongoing history you get to experience. A lot of what’s written down, you can’t live that. When you’re eating an apple developed or discovered by someone in the 1800s, you’re experiencing the same flavors that they are,” Sturges says.
Apples come in so many colors, shapes and sizes. Some are honey-sweet, and some are so tannic they’ll dry your sinuses with one bite.
“We tend to think of apples as eating them fresh or making a pie with them, but until the past century, they filled a huge number of roles in people’s lives. You would have some that might taste terrible fresh, but you’d ferment them into cider and they’re complex like wine,” says Rowan Jacobsen, the James Beard Award-winning author of the 2014 book “Apples of Uncommon Character” (Bloomsbury USA, $35).
Apples are the most diverse fruit in the world, yet our choices are generally limited to a handful of the more than 10,000 varieties that originated in the mountains of Kazakhstan and now span across the globe.
“American culture had thousands of varieties of apples, and some would be very specific to certain regions. They helped define the character of the region. They gave variety and character to the landscape and culture. They helped give a flavor to the place,” says Jacobsen.
Apples are compelling because they can be grafted onto rootstock to produce a perfect clone (the most common method, and the one Sturges practices); be cross-bred to produce new varieties from selected characteristics of other apples (a time-honored, sometimes time-consuming process that’s generated some of the world’s finest apples); left to luck (apple trees sprouted from seed grow into unique types); and, most recently, via genetic modification (a still uncommon, but likely to increase, segment of the market).
Perfect sugary apples

The reason you see so many of the same kinds of apples on repeat throughout supermarkets in the United States has a lot to do with research programs at institutions such as the University of Minnesota and the School of Integrative Plant Science at Cornell University.
“When we got industrialization and suddenly you could grow big, perfect sugary apples in the eastern desert of Washington state, many of the regional varieties disappeared,” Jacobsen says.
Now, we’re somewhere between niche appeal and a mass-market boom for varieties that focus on flavor, locality and even aesthetic appeal.
Apples are the perfect representative of this. Its trees are long-lived, typically at least 50 years, but sometimes as long as two centuries. It’s easy to pass a cutting (and a story) on to someone else who knows how to graft fruit and lives somewhere where the climate is favorable.
“There are so many of the old varieties that hung on in a field somewhere or behind a house and there’s been a new movement to find and share these varieties,” Jacobsen says.
Plus, most of the same university programs that cultivate new, commercial apples also serve as repositories and propagators of diversity.
75 varieties

When you talk about apples with Sturges, it feels like he wants to grow all of them.
He’s currently growing about 75 varieties of apples. Some, such as the crisp red-gold Holstein, discovered in Germany in 1918, are natural offshoots of older heirloom varieties that happened to turn out a new delightful apple from seed. Others, like the lovely dessert apple Sampion (Czech Republic, 1960s) and Hawaii (California, 1940s), an apple with a pastel-pink interior that Sturges says tastes like a pineapple, are representatives of the long lineage of apple breeding.
“This year, I put in another 200 trees. I really need to stop,” he says as he drives his truck through the 3,000 trees on his 65-acre apple farm. “But it’s hard to do that. There are some varieties, the smell and flavor, they bring you someplace special.”
Even the more common varieties — Sturges grows a limited selection of mass-appeal apples such as Fuji, Honeycrisp and Gala —seem to taste better when grown on a farm like his.
Picking for eating

“There’s a difference between picking for eating and picking for shipping. When apples are shipped in, they need to have something that has a lot of sugar and is firm,” he says. “But that complex flavor is never going to be there in the way a local apple is.”
All the apples he grows are for retail sale or cider, and you’ll find him or his two adult kids, Nate and Mariah, behind ever-changing stacks of wood crates at the Bloomfield, Lawrenceville and Bellevue farmers markets and a stand in the Strip District on Saturday mornings. Every year, his lineup grows more diverse.
“People are tired of eating the same basic varieties again and again,” he says. “Bloomfield, especially, people are curious about all the varieties of apples I sell. That’s starting to happen at all the markets now.”
The Finleyville native says his love of the outdoors eventually landed him in charge of the most diverse apple orchard in the region. He considered going into wildlife biology or environmental resource management in college, “but I sucked at zoology and did well in botany, so here we are.”
Instead, he pursued a degree in horticulture. Sturges began his career as a vegetable farmer, growing a few fruit trees mainly as a side project. Later, he realized he had it the other way around.
“The economics of vegetables aren’t great. There’s a lot of waste. Plus, a lot of other people are growing vegetables. And I’ve always loved growing fruit,” he says. “So why not grow fruit?”
First-generation farmer

Sturges expanded to 20 acres in 1989 while managing the trees at the farm across the street from his orchard. In 1997, he purchased an additional 45 acres.
“I’m a first-generation apple farmer. There were no trees on here at all,” he says.
The next generation may or may not follow in his footsteps, but they’ve always supported their father’s passion.
Mariah encouraged him to sell at the old Pittsburgh Public Market. And, if you visit the market in the next few weeks, you’ll find a variety of apples called “Mariah” with a note next to it reading, “My daughter started this tree.”
It’s generally just Sturges picking, though he currently has a bit of extra help from Amish workers as he moves through the peak of the season.
He says he’s inspired by some of the younger farmers at the Bloomfield Saturday market to keep pushing his research as part of the overall blossoming of flavor-forward, can’t-find-these-at-the-grocery-store expansion of Pittsburgh-area agriculture.
“When you go to Bloomfield market you see all these younger growers. And they’re really doing it, not buying in from elsewhere. You see someone like Joddo [Oddo, of Coldco Farm] working on all these different varieties and it’s inspiring,” he says.
‘Fruit guy’

As part of that push, Sturges might just transition his reputation from “the apple guy” to “the fruit guy.”
In June, while many farms were struggling to adapt to an early season heat wave mixed with a short drought, Sturges’ stand drew fruit lovers to a stunning sweet cherry season thanks to a California variety that doesn’t often produce as well here. Part of the benefit of a strategy of diversity is that you’ll almost always have a boom even if others bust.
This year, the Asian pears froze off early after the weather went cold again. However, peaches and nectarines with names such as Fantasia, John Boy and Autumn Glo kept his customers happy all summer.
So, how about those apples as we hit the peak of the season?
That, Sturges says, is the easy part.
“Ask me lots of questions. That’s what I’m here for,” he says. “There are plenty of places to get apples at the grocery store but if you want something with interesting flavor or history, I’m your guy.”
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.