Earlier this month, we celebrated Pittsburgh’s best new restaurant openings of 2022. Now we’re remembering the ones that closed.
Among them were an Italian restaurant treasured for its Sunday suppers, a vegan eatery celebrating the cuisine of the Levant and a pocket-sized farm-to-table luncheonette that helped redefine daytime dining in the city.
Pittsburgh lost one of its most beloved Eat’n Park locations in January when the Eat’n Park Hospitality Group closed its 45-year-old Murray Avenue restaurant.

Tim Tobitsch, Megan Lindsey and Matt Niblack opened a Downtown hot dog shop called Hot Dogma in Trinity Cathedral in 2004, rebranding the operation as Franktuary shortly after that. Tobitsch and Lindsey expanded Franktuary when they rolled out one of Pittsburgh’s first mobile food trucks in 2010. They opened a larger location of the brand, complete with an expanded menu that included more vegan options, a robust bar program and entertainment such as weekly trivia nights, on Butler Street in Lawrenceville in 2013. They closed the original Downtown spot in 2014 and reopened in Market Square in 2015; that location ran until 2017. They closed the Lawrenceville restaurant in January. William Penn Tavern, which operated in Shadyside from 2002 to earlier this year, now operates in the space.
Downtown lost a fixture in March when Sammy’s Famous Corned Beef closed its Liberty Ave. location which has been open for a little more than 35 years. Sam Firman’s establishment was beloved for its corned beef sandwiches but also its affordable pricing and as a place to stop in for a quick lunch bite or after work drink. At one point, Sammy’s had five locations in Pittsburgh, including four Downtown.
Pittsburgh then lost three plant-based restaurants and an esteemed establishment with deep roots in the local farm economy over four weeks in March and April. Although all four establishments closed for different reasons, none of them having to do with their menus (which all were delightful), the close proximity of the closings was dubbed by some on social media as “The Vegan Apocalypse.”
Read More
First came Viridis, a South Side establishment that offered a small menu of sandwiches and pastries. The restaurant opened in October 2021 and closed in March.

Shortly after that, B52 in Upper Lawrenceville closed. Owner/chef Omar Abuhejleh opened his vegan restaurant with a focus on the cuisine of the Levant in 2016. Informed by his Palestinian heritage, Abuhejleh offered some of the best hummus, falafel, red lentil soup and labneh in Pittsburgh. The restaurant also served a terrific breakfast, including an incredible version of long-fermented multigrain pancakes, and it also had a fantastic coffee program. All isn’t lost, however, as Abuhejleh continues to operate the outstanding (and, as of 2020, all vegan) bakery Allegro Hearth in Squirrel Hill, where you can sometimes find some of the beloved B52 dishes.
Bitter Ends Food opened in 2017 as Bitter Ends Garden & Luncheonette. The 17-seat restaurant quickly established a dedicated following for chef/co-owner Becca Hegarty’s fastidious dedication to turning peak-quality, locally sourced ingredients into a menu of seasonal soups, sandwiches, pastries and specials. That work translated into a succession of James Beard Award Rising Star Chef semifinalist nods for Hegarty, who pivoted to a takeaway model, with occasional popup specials, at the onset of the coronavirus pandemic. Although the restaurant closed on April 20, Bitter Ends left its mark on Pittsburgh: Hegarty is food director for Adda; former chef Ryan Chavara took over the Bitter Ends space, where he operates the delightful Thyme Machine food cart; and original co-owner and farmer Jason “Joddo” Oddo now operates the outstanding COLDCO Farm.

Just two days later, Reed and Co. ended its run. The Lawrenceville restaurant opened in 2016 and was best known for its juices, smoothies and power-packed bowls but also offered a vegan breakfast sandwich that stood shoulder-to-shoulder with any eggy breakfast sandwich in town.
Stagioni closed at the end of June. Stephen Felder and Cara DelSignore opened their Italian restaurant in Bloomfield in 2009 and moved the operation to larger digs on the South Side in 2012. DelSignore ran the front of house with gracious hospitality; it was easy to feel like you were a regular after just a couple of visits. Felder, the chef, offered a regular Italian menu with dishes such as made-to-order mozzarella, fantastic meatballs, terrific pasta dishes and pizza. Stagioni was celebrated for its Sunday Supper series and annual offerings such as the springtime ritual of Le Virtu, the 49-ingredient soup from the Abruzzo, and December’s Feast of the Seven Fishes.

2 Sisters 2 Sons closed at the end of August after two years of operation in a semi-residential, semi-industrial stretch in Sharpsburg. The restaurant was run by two sisters (Denise Josephs and Marlene Siddo) and two of their sons (Michael Brown and Kwasi Prince) and specialized in Jamaican cuisine, offering excellent renditions of jerk chicken, oxtails and brown-stew goat. The owners have switched to catering (which is how the business started) as they look for a new location.
The vestiges of Bloomfield’s Little Italy grew ever scarcer as 90-year-old Donatelli’s Italian Food Center closed in August and 49-year-old Lombardozzi’s went up for sale in September.
Two Regent Square restaurants, Square One Cafe and Istanbul Grille, also closed in September. Square One had a short run. It operated in the former Square Cafe space for two months before being folded back into the Square Cafe operation, which moved to East Liberty in September 2020. Istanbul Grille had a five-year run serving Turkish and Mediterranean cuisine in its space.

September also saw the end of Spring Hill Brewing’s four-year run. The small brewery with a grand view from the former Workingmen’s Beneficial Union building was a popular spot for group gatherings and events. It featured blazing fire pits that offered warm comfort for outdoor gatherings, a feature that was especially important when indoor dining was suspended to mitigate the spread of COVID-19.
Finally, although it’s not quite closed yet, Kretzler’s Tavern will conclude a 71-year run at the end of the year. The restaurant was best known for its fish sandwich and also offered an excellent rendition of a Turkey Devonshire.
This story was updated on Dec. 31, 2022 to reflect the March closure of Sammy’s Famous Corned Beef.
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.