In the early 2010s, a pack of ambitious young-gun chefs and restaurateurs ushered in a new golden age of dining in Pittsburgh that earned a lofty national profile the city had never before seen.
East End restaurants Dinette, Spoon and Legume had already set the tone for a renaissance. Meat & Potatoes re-established Downtown as a chic dining destination. Salt of the Earth and Root 174 pushed boundaries with innovative fare. In January of 2012, Justin Severino opened his much-feted Cure in Lawrenceville.
And, in the same month in the Strip District, four friends from Greensburg opened Bar Marco.
“I want that to be the X factor: That people just feel good when they're here.”
What started as a booze-centric cocktail and wine bar with small plates and snacks has evolved into one of the city’s best Italian restaurants. On New Year’s Eve, they’ll celebrate with a special menu that brings back some of their all-time favorite dishes. It’s a la carte rather than a prix fixe and reservations and proof of vaccination or a negative PCR test is required.
“We officially opened on January 2nd of 2012. So every year we do a New Year's Eve anniversary party, but obviously 10 years is a little bit more special,” executive chef and owner Justin Steel said. “We’re gonna reach back a little bit and try to think about some things that we've really enjoyed and create the menu from there.”
Each of those aforementioned restaurants was a sensation. But, be it due to the fickle nature of the restaurant industry or the grim reality of COVID, a decade later, Bar Marco is the only one that’s still going (Meat & Potatoes, closed since 2020, announced today they will reopen in February; Legume folded into sibling establishment Butterjoint).
“I think when we first opened, we wanted to be sort of like a very casual bar that served good food,” Mr. Steel said. “It took a couple years for us to get our legs under us, but I think finally we were able to really be the restaurant that we probably always should have been and wanted to be.”

Along the way, they did novel and buzzworthy dinners in their wine room, created a no-tipping model for their staff, were part of a contemporary red sauce resurgence, and gave a platform to some immense culinary talent they count as alumni.
Jamilka Borges was nominated for her first James Beard award while there and has become one of the most accomplished chefs in the city; Joey Hilty would open The Vandal, with Csilla Thackray coming over to lead the kitchen there (she’s now the chef-in-residence at Churchview Farm); and Sarah Thomas moved to New York and into some very rare air as a sommelier at Le Bernardin and is the author of the Kalamata’s Kitchen line of children’s books.
Mr. Steel’s original partners, his high school friends Kevin Cox, Michael Kreha and Bobby Fry, have since left the business
“Everyone got in this to start a restaurant and to have a restaurant succeed, and put the restaurant first. We were lucky that there wasn't a whole lot of ego, and everyone sort of left when it was their time. I'm just kind of the gatekeeper now.
“I feel very fortunate to still be here two years into this mess,” he said, referring to the pandemic, which has been devastating to the restaurant industry.
“We've always been fortunate, but we all work very, very hard. The staff that we have is super passionate. That cultivates the atmosphere where people feel good here. I want that to be the X factor: That people just feel good when they're here. I hope that that's why this place exists 10 years after we started.”
Dan Gigler: gdgigler@post-gazette.com; @gigs412 on Instagram and Twitter.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.