If Billy Joel were to reprise his 1989 classic “We Didn’t Start the Fire” to reflect the absurdities of the past two years, he might include Joe Exotic, QAnon, murder hornets and anti-vaxxers. The Piano Man also might rework one line to something like this:

Fast food chicken sandwich wars, I can’t take it anymore!

That’s because since the middle of 2019, we’ve been locked in an epic struggle for fried chicken sandwich supremacy.

It began that summer with Popeye’s introducing a fried chicken sandwich that was an instant, massive sensation and featured ads of people practically speaking in tongues after a bite.

Advertise with us

Chick-fil-A quickly put Popeye’s on blast, as the kids say, by proclaiming its status on social media as the original chicken sandwich king. Indeed, the lines of exhaust-spewing cars idling in their drive-thrus would suggest as much.

Yardbird bedlam followed, and scores of places nationwide have since introduced fried chicken sandwiches, including McDonald’s, Burger King and KFC, which should’ve canned the CEO for not thinking of it sooner. They now run a nonstop ad with an animated Colonel Sanders throwing heavy shade at the others for impinging on KFC territory.

As is usually the case, independent operators did it first. Over the past decade, fried chicken has seen a revival on restaurant menus and in food trucks, and enthusiasm has only continued to build for this most quintessentially American food.

Over the past four years in Western Pennsylvania, at least a half-dozen restaurants have opened with fried chicken sandwiches as either the sole focus or a featured menu item, and dozens more have added them to their menus.

One is The Coop Chicken and Waffles, where Justin Fitzgerald and partner Nicki Cardilli have made a big bet on a decades-old recipe by Mr. Fitzgerald’s Texan grandmother. They launched first as a food truck in 2016 and recently celebrated the one-year anniversary of their restaurant on East Ohio Street on the North Side.

Advertise with us

“I come from a family of folks who know what they're doing in the kitchen without actually having recognition for it. My mom, grandma, aunts — their cooking rivals some of the best and I picked up on tricks and techniques that they would use,” Mr. Fitzgerald said.

There’s a process with the chicken that sets it apart and it starts days beforehand, Mr. Fitzgerald said. “Our chicken has to be prepped according to that particular process.”

The Coop’s signature sandwich is “The Cooper”— fried chicken thighs and fried pickles on grilled Texas toast, topped with a house sauce.

Mr. Fitzgerald cites a confluence of factors in the rise of the chicken sandwich. First, cost.

“Chicken was cheap,” he said. “They were practically giving it away. You could make super high margins on a fried chicken sandwich.”

Advertise with us

Driven by Americans' insatiable appetite for Buffalo chicken, wings are typically the most expensive part of the chicken per pound. But prices and demand overall have since soared, owing to the chicken sandwich explosion.

Convenience: “It’s handheld and extremely easy to eat. I joke that you could eat one on a treadmill,” Mr. Fitzgerald said.

Connection: “People like to talk about them and compare them.” Not on the level of pizza or barbecue, but it’s growing.

And of course, there’s the taste.

In addition to all the savory notes, a good fried chicken sandwich is as much about texture as anything, with crispy skin giving way to tender meat.

Advertise with us

At Nanban in Lawrenceville, Korean fried chicken is the specialty. Chef-owner Roger Li says this variation is unique in its process. The chicken is lightly battered and fried and then tossed in sauce and stir-fried in a wok, resulting in a skin that’s “glass-shattering crispy,” Mr. Li said.

The toppings and bread are just as essential.

“The ratio between bread and chicken is important and how it holds together after the first bite,” he said, adding that pickles are a must.

“The acid [complements] the fattiness. It gives a hot and cold element and adds crunch,” Mr. Li said.

“It’s the best way to eat fried chicken. It’s handheld. It’s good. It’s not as messy. It’s filling. It looks nice. Cost-wise it's a little cheaper than everything else so you can make more money off it.”

Advertise with us

Like many in the service industry, South Side bartender Troy Beck found himself out of work during the pandemic. This winter, he turned to cooking as therapy.

“All I was hungry for was comfort food,” he said. “There was nothing to do, nothing to look forward to. No sports, no shows.”

His favorite foods from childhood were hoagies and fried chicken, so he combined them.

“I just started doing it on my own, guerilla-style for my friends,” Mr. Beck said.

But when an influential friend with 100,000 Twitter followers  — Michael “Mikey” Dougherty of the 96.1 KISS-FM morning show — gave him a bump, demand exploded.

Advertise with us

Mr. Beck enlisted a partner in Katie Peric, a classically trained chef, and since March the pair have worked out of a ghost kitchen in East Liberty. They’re exploring the possibility of a brick-and-mortar location.

“She's amazing... She’s why everyone loves [our product],” Mr. Beck said.

An Altoona native, he became obsessed with the hot fried chicken sandwiches at Pepperfire in Nashville when he lived there and worked for the Nashville Predators hockey team.

Mr. Beck said chicken is a more nostalgic product than say, hamburgers. Kids grow up eating chicken tenders and McNuggets, after all. And Pittsburghers love it.

“I’ll die on the hill that Pittsburgh is the true wing capital of the world,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Beck also likes the accessibility of fried chicken sandwiches after working in fine dining at the elite Kohanaiki private club in Hawaii.

“I could pair a cocktail with bone marrow, but that’s not what my Aunt Deb and Uncle Terry in Bridgeville want,” he said.

It might not be the best thing since sliced bread, but right now, fried chicken sandwiches are the best thing between sliced bread.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com.