Derek Stevens and Mike McCoy began their respective service industry careers at a Chuck E. Cheese in the North Hills and a Carl’s Jr. in southern California. They intersected in the Strip District in 2004 as members of the opening crew of Eleven — Mr. Stevens in the kitchen, Mr. McCoy in the front of the house. They helped build what remains one of the city’s most prominent restaurants, and went on to run and create several more elite establishments.

But over the last year, they went back to basics: flipping burgers. Or smashing them, to be precise. And now, MoonLit Burgers, the wildly popular pandemic pop-up the pair started last summer, will soon have a permanent home in October at 1426 Potomac Ave. in Dormont.

“We’ve have talked for years about doing something together,” Mr. Stevens said.

His solo restaurant, Union Standard in the Union Trust Building Downtown, was an early COVID-19 casualty. It closed for good in early June.

Advertise with us

“Last summer, when everything was all [fouled] up, Mike called me and said, ‘Why don’t we just buy a griddle and do this burger thing that we’d talked about and start doing pop-ups and see what happens?’”

So they did. They created a signature specialty: a Los Angeles/In-N-Out-style “smashed” double patty with American cheese, griddled onion, pickles, and their proprietary “Moon” sauce on a Martin's potato roll. They connected with Millie’s to do a summer cookout on the patio of the ice cream parlor's Shadyside location.

“The first time we did it, we had no idea what to expect so we said, ‘Let’s bring a hundred burgers,’ and they were gone in a couple hours,” Mr. Stevens said. The next week, “we came back with 300 burgers and we sold out in two hours. So it was like, OK, maybe we’re on to something here. Let’s keep trying to build it.”

That led to regular gigs around the city and suburbs and an immediate cult following. Its first brick-and-mortar home is an 1,800-square-foot building at the intersection Potomac and Glenmore avenues that was most recently Fire Bar & Grill. It will have seating for 50 and a fast casual service model. There will be a full bar, and an expanded menu including fried chicken and hot dogs, more sides and appetizers, salads, plant-based burgers, gluten-free options and ice cream and milkshakes via a partnership with Millie’s Ice Cream.

After a professional career working in upscale restaurants, both men are ecstatic about moving into a more universal concept.

Advertise with us

“Oh my God it feels so good,” Mr. Stevens said. “It’s been a lot of fun already, for us and for customers. It’s moderately priced and accessible to more people. I’m really looking forward to moving forward. My 15-year-old son has been helping with all of the pop-ups and it's such a blast working with him and having him be a part of it.”

“When we started talking about doing something, we said, ‘We don’t wanna do fine dining,’” Mr. McCoy said. “I don't wanna wear a suit. We just want to do something simple and good.”

If things go well, it should be the first of at least a few restaurants in the Pittsburgh area.

“We sure hope so,” Mr. Stevens said.

“That’s the plan,” Mr. McCoy added.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com.