There is fish and seafood. Sausages and meats. A globe’s worth of cheeses. Bread. Coffee. Fresh produce. Candy. Specialty goods from Mexico to Poland to Greece to Japan. Diners and high-end restaurants. Craft beer and booze. Iconic, big honkin’ fry-filled sandwiches.

And now: pizza.


First of a series on best neighborhoods for pizza in the ’Burgh.

For more than a century, the Strip District has been Pittsburgh’s pantry, the epicenter of food in the region. Certainly, pizza has always at least been in the background in the Strip. Pittsburghers of a certain age fondly recall grabbing big and wonderfully sloppy slices from La Pizza Del Pazzo on the produce terminal loading docks on their lunch breaks or after late nights at Metropol.

But with a recent combination of new young blood — or sauce, rather — and some longtime veterans, the Strip has arguably emerged as the city’s pre-eminent pizza destination, boasting a strong roster with a deep bench and a wide variety of styles and options.

Advertise with us

There’s Sicilian, Neapolitan, Roman, Detroit, New York, Lebanon, Pa., and the good old not-thick-but-not-thin cheesy Pittsburgh hybrid. Some of these pizza makers are classically trained chefs. Some of them fell into the profession almost by accident. They range in age from their late 20s to their early 60s; boomers and millennials that might well loathe each other’s music and world view. But they all share a fanatical passion for pizza that runs a spectrum from cerebral to quasi-religious — often at the same time.

We asked these pizzaiolos and dough mongers for some of their thoughts on why pizza is such a downright emotional food, their favorite pizza memories and their personal pizza philosophies.

Belle Notte

“I grew up eating Aiello’s, Mineo’s and Vinnie Pies and I remember sitting down with my three brothers and my family and eating and talking. It’s nostalgic. Families get together over pizza. Friendships are built over pizza. If you move into a new apartment, you buy your neighbors that might have helped you out beer and pizza,” Dan Hahn explains.

Mr. Hahn, 34, of Shadyside, runs the pizza operations at Belle Notte, the offshoot of Nino Sunseri’s bakery, which for nearly 20 years has teemed with people on Saturday afternoons. They come for the big cuts, 44 beers on draft and sidewalk seating that spills out of the building’s old garage bay doors.

Advertise with us

Mr. Hahn worked at Rialto’s Pizza in Greenfield in college and remembers coming to this building as a kid when it was still a market, then later getting slices after late nights in college when Strip District nightlife was at its peak. After working in corporate accounting and “hating” it, he took a pause and started slinging pies. That was nine years ago, and he hasn’t looked back.

They routinely bake 300 pizzas on Saturday afternoons (in addition to making hoagies and calzones) and he said, “Every time my team works together well, that’s a great pizza memory. We have a great product with top-of-the-line ingredients. It’s fresh, it’s quality. Watching the team come together on a Saturday and put out the product we strive to, that’s a good pizza memory.”

That, and one other. After getting his driver’s license, he was allowed to take his father’s new convertible Mazda 626 to pick up a pizza from Vincent’s in Forest Hills. When his dad went to use the car later, he informed his son that he was grounded. The reason: “The pizza left a huge grease spot on the seat.”

1914 Penn Ave.; 412-281-4488; https://www.bellanottepgh.com/

Colangelo’s Bakery

Advertise with us

Stars in their eyes. That’s what Denese Colangelo remembers from her first weekend in business.

“The first weekend we were open here, we would slide all the fresh hot pizzas on top of the bread case, and my favorite memory was just seeing the look in people’s eyes when they see the pizza. They get stars in their eyes when people see pizza. They don’t see you, they don’t see anything, they just see the pizza.”

It’s a family affair at Colangelo’s, where Denese Colangelo, her son Nicholas, and Abruzzi-born ex-husband Nick bake pizzas and Italian pastries and goodies in the former location of Il Piccolo Forno. They took the spot over from the Branduzzis after patriarch Antonio died in 2007. They’d previously worked there for several years, before briefly running their own restaurant in Monroeville.

“We knew how to make all their stuff, so we could continue on the tradition of his pastries and we did our own stuff too,” she explained.

Their philosophy is straightforward: “Keep it simple. Keep it fresh. Keep it Local. A lot of people overdo it. Just keep it simple. My favorite pizza is a margherita with mozzarella and red sauce. And it’s good every day of the week, even for breakfast. Which we do — we have pizza in the case at 6 in the morning!”

Advertise with us

207 21st St.; 412-281-7080; http://colangelopgh.com/

Enrico’s Cafe

“Everybody has an epiphanal pizza,” Larry Lagatutta explains. “Not necessarily their favorite, but the pizza that once you eat it, you go, holy [heck] what have I been doing my whole life?”

“For me, it was at a little pizzeria outside of Sorrento, this beautiful pizza came to the table and it was like a work of art. Spectacular. And then you took a bite, with that mozzarella, and that flour, and that little kiss of salt. Basil. The tiniest bit of olive oil. I still get goosebumps just thinking about it.”

That was more than 30 years ago.

Advertise with us

His bakery, Enrico Biscotti is a household name, and when he acquired what he said was the city’s first modern wood-fired, brick pizza oven (Ron Molinaro at Il Pizzaiolo in Mt. Lebanon, beat him to the punch, but that’s in the suburbs) for Enrico’s Cafe, he carried that memory with him.

“We do it Come Napoli — exactly the way they do it in Naples. No shortcuts.”

Roberto Caporuscio, his first pizzaiolo, was born in Pontinia, Italy, and trained in Naples. He taught Mr. Lagatutta the trade and has since gone on to pizza stardom at Keste in Manhattan.

The 61-year old Mount Washington native, who used to skip high school lunch at St. Justin’s to pile in a car with friends to get Fiori’s slices, has a borderline spiritual view of pizza.

“If pizza is not communal and fraternal, with fellowship, then you’re just shoving food in your mouth.”

Advertise with us

2022 Penn Ave.; 412-281-2602; http://www.enricobiscotti.com/the-cafe/

Iron Born Pizza

“Joy. Warmth. That homey feeling. It makes you happy.”

Pete Tolman knows the fuzzies that pizza gives, but the approach he takes to his Detroit-style pizzas is decidedly more direct.

“Our philosophy is to take it seriously. The whole process. Sourcing your flour — why did you choose that flour? Why is your recipe written [the way it is], or why do you do it that way? The ingredients that go on top. All of the cheeses. So there’s a lot of research and we try to combine all of those things together to make a high-quality product. We want to make it as good as we can, with what we have.”

Advertise with us

That process made his pizzas the darling of his class at Smallman Galley, when he introduced them in 2017. He’s since opened a takeout shop in Millvale, and will soon open a flagship location — likely before Thanksgiving — a few blocks from the small stall where he started.

The new Iron Born will be a 2,000-square-foot, eat-in or take-out location with 42 seats, with a full bar run by Olive Beals (formerly of Union Standard). Pasta dishes will be provided by fellow Smallman Galley alum Ryan Peters, as well as desserts, entree salads and sandwiches.

It’s been quite a journey for Mr. Tolman. He worked in the rarified air of Grant Achatz’s restaurant Alinea in Chicago and at the equally elite Lautrec at Nemacolin Woodlands before hanging up his fine-dining toque to make the deep-dish, cheese encrusted Detroit-style pizza he taught himself to make after trying it once in Colorado.

But post-high-school-hockey-practice pizza will always be the Kittanning native’s favorite. “We would order from this place called Sirena’s pizza, and it had thick cut Sicilian pizza. As a kid, it was the greatest damn thing in the world.”

1806 Smallman St.; https://ironbornpizza.com/

Advertise with us

Osteria 2350

After a post-culinary school career that took her to fine-dining kitchens at resorts on Florida’s Gulf Coast, Dormont native Meghann Walsh was ready to come back home. While she was looking for jobs, she picked up shifts for a few months at her brother Sean’s new pizza shop, Nobby’s, on Vanadium Road in Scott.

“That’s how I learned to make pizza,” she said “I got a feel for a different side of the business.”

That was 11 years ago and shortly after, she went to work for Cioppino, bringing fine-dining experience and a crash course pizza “internship” to her role as the pastry chef for that restaurant and its sister establishment, Osteria 2350. That’s where she now makes the house dough with a sourdough starter that adds an extra tang to the flavor, which complements the cheese from nearby neighbors Penn Mac and meats from Parma Sausage.

2350 Railroad St.; 412-281-6595; http://osteria2350pittsburgh.com/

Advertise with us

Pizzeria Davide

His first try was a disaster.

Dave Anoia was preparing to open his widely lauded Strip District restaurant DiAnoia’s Eatery when he started noodling with pizza recipes for the menu. He made several pies for his wife and business partner Aimee to sample.

“They were terrible,” he laughed and said they questioned whether this was a good idea.

But the fine-dining-trained Mr. Anoia, a bona fide polymath of Italian cooking, was undeterred. Constant trial and error finally yielded what the signature pizzas, he touts as “Old World” style — no reference to Naples, Rome or Palermo, but rather Lebanon, Pa., where he grew up on Pete’s Pizza. The pies are layered first with sliced, sharp provolone, tangy red sauce and finished with basil, parmesan and oregano. They’ve been a smash hit.

Advertise with us

On the strength of those pizzas, he opened Pizzeria Davide earlier this year behind DiAnoia’s, and early next year will open a second location in Carnegie.

“Keep it light and airy. Keep it super simple, and super fresh,” he says.

2551 Penn Ave.; 412-904-4139; https://www.pizzeriadavide.com/

Romulus Pizza al Taglio

Much has been made of the demise of Century III Mall, but if you try and enjoy one of Kevin Konn’s Roman-style slices, you can thank that bygone West Mifflin temple of consumerism.

Advertise with us

Mr. Konn took a high school job at the Italian Village Pizza there, and it planted a seed for a love of pizza making. He attended University of Pittsburgh briefly, but dropped out to attend the now-closed Le Cordon Bleu Institute of Culinary Arts, Downtown. After graduating in 2005, he went to Seattle and worked at Via Tribunali, where he learned pizza-making under the tutelage of Dino Santonicola of Naples, Italy.

He returned to Pittsburgh and worked at the side of local legend Ron Molinaro at Il Pizzaiolo in Mt. Lebanon, and helped open the Downtown location, where he met chef Justin Balla, of Baldwin. The pair frequently don blue “LA” caps, in tribute to a dear friend and former colleague and Los Angeles Dodgers fan, Michael Schichilone, who passed away in 2016.

Numbers, symbols, chemical equations and periodic table shorthand are scrawled in day-glo markers and pop from the bright white symmetry of the subway tile behind their second-floor counter in the PA Market Building, like the formulas of mad geniuses. They wouldn’t look out of place in a “Breaking Bad” montage and are the basis of a recipe that might be only slightly less addictive than Heisenberg’s “Blue Sky.”

“It’s all about the dough,” Mr. Balla said. In addition to adding New York and Neapolitan pizzas to their menu, they’d like to open a pizza training school. “We want to bridge that gap between old school and new,” Mr. Konn added.

But despite their technical wizardry and academic aspirations, pizza is “so ingrained in our DNA. We put all of our love and passion into this,” Mr. Konn said, and they get creative with the help of their resident chef, McCall Brooks.

Advertise with us

“Pizza is like chicken noodle soup when you’re sick,” Mr. Balla said. “It’s just so comforting."

108 19th St., 2nd floor;https://www.facebook.com/Romulus.Dante

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412