The well-worn maxim location, location, location is as applicable to restaurants as it is to real estate, and when it comes to that subject, restaurateurs can be as superstitious as sailors.

To that end, Vincent and Candice Perri could hardly have done better in finding a building with good mojo at 1211 Penn Ave. in the Strip District to open their first restaurant, Supper on Penn.

Mr. Perri said the building dates to the 1860s, and it has “been serving liquor and or food since then,” he said, even if some of them — including a prohibition-era bar and a brothel — operated on the periphery of the law. For the past 20 years, it was Crystal, a popular but low-key watering hole for Strip District workers. Mr. Perri took the space over in mid-July and opened for business Wednesday.

“It’s pretty great. It’s been gut-wrenching at times. We’ve gone through a lot to get to this point,” he said. “That we’re open now after so much anticipation is a good feeling.”

Advertise with us

A native of Weirton, W.Va., Mr. Perri was the opening executive chef for Downtown’s Revel + Roost before joining the inaugural lineup at the Federal Galley on the North Side with his Supper concept.

Supper on Penn is an expansion on that where they invite “Carnivores, Vegans and Everyone in-between.” The menu, broken up into bites, snacks, sandwiches and plates, reflects that with items from a chilled corn soup or a seitan and tofu remoulade to a BLT with a thick cut of confit pork belly or a ribeye with red-eye gravy. As much as possible is done in-house from smoking and grinding meat to making ice cream or sourdough bread.

“We don’t have anything that’s super-fine dining,” he said. “It’s all simple and straightforward but we make 100% all of it.”

Exposed brick and tin-stamped ceilings harken to the old days, as does a slate of vintage cocktails.

Along with the building, Mr. Perri inherited a framed undated photograph (that appears to be from at least the early 1900s) of one of the building’s former tavern keepers behind the bar.

Advertise with us

“Apparently, one of his relatives comes in once a year and takes a picture with that picture,” he said, adding that he looks forward to meeting them and learning about the history that he’s now a part of.

Supper on Penn: 1211 Penn Ave., Strip District; 412-235-7608; https://supperpgh.com/

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412