When the great chicken sandwich debate of 2019 erupted online earlier this week, some Pittsburghers wondered whether the Steel City even had the right to participate.

Some background for the uninitiated: the fast-food chain Popeyes rolled out a new fried chicken sandwich nationwide Aug. 12 — an obvious challenge to the market dominance of longtime sandwich specialists Chick fil-A.

One week later, Chick-fil-A escalated things on Twitter, taking a dig at their new competitors by branding their own sandwich “the original.” Social media erupted, with many deciding to taste-test the two sandwiches to crown a king.

While both chains have locations in Pittsburgh, some locals have wondered whether a city so far north of the Mason-Dixon line should even be taking part in a debate about such a quintessentially Southern food, involving restaurants that began in Louisiana (Popeyes) and Georgia (Chick-fil-A).

Advertise with us

Take Atlanta native Nubyjas Wilborn, who covers the Pirates for the Post-Gazette. As badly as he wants to try the new Popeyes product, he wrote on Twitter Tuesday night that in his experience, the food at Pittsburgh’s locations just doesn’t compare to what they serve down South.

“So I’ll wait until the off season when I go back to [Atlanta],” he wrote.

But living by that standard would set an impossible precedent — we can’t deprive ourselves of all that Southern cuisine has to offer just because we’re stuck on the other side of the Appalachians. Besides, Popeyes’ sandwiches have been selling so fast that there may not be any left by the time Mr. Wilborn makes it to Atlanta.

As for my own qualifications, I may be a New York City native, but I am also a former employee of Pies ’n’ Thighs, a Southern joint in Brooklyn whose fried chicken has been ranked among the best in the country. In other words, I know good chicken when I taste it. So I set out Wednesday morning to put the two sandwiches head-to-head.

By 11:30 a.m., the line was already 12 deep at Popeyes’ Wharton Street location on the South Side. “Is anybody not here for the chicken sandwich?” a cashier called out. No replies — we all were.

Advertise with us

Demand was high enough that it took close to 10 minutes for my regular sandwich to arrive (they also serve a spicy version, as does Chick-fil-A), wrapped in paper and tucked in a foil-lined bag. It was worth the wait.

The sandwich ($3.99) is served on a glistening brioche bun, crisped ever so slightly and oozing with mayonnaise. It’s easier to appreciate the bun’s soft sweetness once you sink your teeth into the chicken: flawlessly crunchy, surprisingly moist, perfectly salty.

Then there’s the surprise highlight: the pickle slices lying under the chicken, each one cut generously thick and tasting like they’ve just come out of the jar. They tie the whole thing together seamlessly.

A fried chicken sandwich from the Wharton Street Popeyes on Pittsburgh's South Side. (Nick Garber / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Feeling greasy and satisfied, I headed east along the Monongahela River until I got to the Waterfront Chick fil-A, full for the 2 p.m. late-lunch rush.

My sandwich ($3.65) arrived, looking almost vacuum-sealed in a tight foil pouch. It’s the exact same format as Popeyes’ sandwich, minus the mayo, but it looks modest in comparison — it’s thinner, paler and where Popeyes’ hefty filet extends way out on both sides of the bun, Chick fil-A’s disc-shaped patty is entirely self-contained. It’s easier to hold, but a lot less fun to wrangle into your mouth.

Advertise with us

In nearly every category, it doesn’t quite measure up to Popeyes. Its bun is plain and dry where Popeyes’ is soft and buttery. The pickles are pale, thin and without much kick. And the chicken, though its peppery flavor outdid Popeyes’ relative lack of seasoning, didn’t have the crispiness that really makes the Popeyes sandwich special.

A classic chicken sandwich from Chick Fil-A's Waterfront location in Homestead. (Nick Garber / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Plus, there’s something to be said for the lovable unevenness of the Popeyes filet, an inch thick in some places and paper thin elsewhere. It looks like chicken that once was, well, a chicken — Chick fil-A’s patty feels almost factory-made.

Should you choose to head only to Chick fil-A, you’ll still come out satisfied — it gets the job done. But if you’re in search of something more indulgent, head to Popeyes. The hype is real.

Nick Garber: ngarber@post-gazette.com.