It was a little less than two years ago when Andrew Garbarino set about moving his pocket-sized tasting-menu-only restaurant The Twisted Frenchman from Highland Avenue in East Liberty into a much larger dream space a block away: a two-story affair with the upstairs dining room serving intricate, upscale French cuisine, and downstairs a French style bistro and brasserie, Bar Frenchman, dealing in more hearty and rustic French fare.

Not everything went according to plan.

Instead of creating two distinct but similarly named concepts under one roof, the result was a confusing customer experience in which he found his own restaurant was competing against itself and some diners scratching their heads as some expected one experience and got another. The downstairs was briefly rechristened as Le Riviera, so as to avoid the confusion, but that didn’t solve the problem.

So when life gave Mr. Garbarino lemons, he made limoncello.

Advertise with us

Though it had been in the works for a few months, he and his staff made a quick pivot, closed La Riviera for about a week and reopened as Garbarino’s Restaurant 4th Gen, serving classic Italian and Italian-American dishes. The name is an homage to Mr. Garbarino’s great-grandaunt Louisa, an immigrant from Genoa who in 1945 opened Garbarino’s Restaurant in Lynbrook on Long Island, and ran it until it closed in 1996.

“I never wanted an Italian restaurant,” the Johnstown native said. He’d studied at the prestigious Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y., and while he has been drawn to creating food that pushes boundaries, a return to his roots was appealing. And given the early results at Garbarino’s, one might wonder why he didn’t consider it sooner.

The cool blues and grays of the dining room walls have been replaced with warm golden walls; frites have given way to focaccia; escargot to eggplant parm and coq au vin to calamari.

But just don’t call it a red sauce joint, Mr. Garbarino said, referencing the rich spaghetti Bolognese sauce with a base of prosciutto and rendered guanciale fat, and tomatoes and diced carrots that help give it a distinctive hue.

“It’s an orange sauce,” he said. “My grandmother always said there are too many damn red sauce recipes.”

Advertise with us

Garbarino’s 4th Gen Restaurant: 5925 Baum Blvd., East Liberty; 412- 665-2880; http://garbarinos.com/

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412