WINDBER, Pa. — This little town in Somerset County has been losing population since the peak of coal mining. But on Graham Avenue, tucked among houses, a church and an old Italian social club, there’s Rizzo’s, a restaurant established in 1937, where today, even in a town of fewer than 5,000, the restaurant pulls in more than 800 reservations every year for New Year’s Eve.
Customers visit for the veal-, eggplant- and chicken Parmesan or spaghetti with golf ball-sized meatballs. They’re here for mozzarella sticks breaded in-house, the best-selling steak tips, or the house-special chicken Captiva, with its creamy mustard sauce.
In a town that’s been hollowed out by a changing economy, Rizzo’s maintains its sense of community: a giant, welcoming, lively one. Depending on the day, three to 10 family members will work at the 250-seat restaurant, from expediter Dominick “Butch” Rizzo in his 60s, who’s worked in the kitchen for over 40 years, to sauce maker and general manager Dominick Chippie, 40, who has toggled between the front and back of the house since he was 16.
Just like their father did, Mr. Chippie’s young daughters Talia and Sienna also work here: Sienna has already been learning how to make carrot cake and cannoli, and she knows the secret recipes for the steak and marinara sauces. Sienna doesn’t even try red sauce at other restaurants anymore — she calls it “foreign sauce” — though her sister does.
The spirit of Mildred “Millie” Rizzo infuses the place — even though she’s likely sitting in her upstairs apartment watching the stock market report. The oldest member of the family at 96, her apartment is accessed by a staircase across from the stove in the kitchen.
Mrs. Rizzo, who retired from the restaurant long ago, is most proud of the pasta dishes and she’s glad that after all these years, it’s still the place in town “where people get together,” she says.
A tie to Pittsburgh is Nick Rizzo — a third-generation Rizzo, one of the few in his clan who isn’t currently working in his family’s restaurant. But he did bus tables in his youth and on the line during high school and college summers. He’s the former general manager of the handful of restaurants formerly owned by Yves Carreau of the now-defunct Big Y Group, and he’s been bartending at a pop-up spot as he awaits the opening of a new restaurant where he has accepted a management job.
Back in the kitchen in Windber, a cook like Brent Blough might be making meatballs, while another such as Sonny Wright stirs the vat of sauce. “It changes throughout the day,” Marie Chippie says about the sauce. She’s Butch’s sister and says she’s semi-retired from Rizzo’s. What she calls “new sauce” starts the night, and it changes in its complexity throughout service, she says.
In the week between Christmas and New Year’s, a lighted tree anchors the host stand, while paper snowflakes and poinsettias lend the season’s cheer to the dining room. The front of the house that starts filling up at 5 p.m. is fastidiously maintained, with its polished family photos, painted tin ceilings, carpeted floors and stained glass. Nearly 20 servers and 12 to 14 cooks will be working New Year’s Eve, along with nine bussers and, likely, all four dishwashers — one who has worked here for more than 20 years.
Most of the staff used to be lifers — or at the very least, they worked here more than a decade. Now, “the circle of people who have worked here for more than 10 years is smaller than those who have worked here two or three,” says Norma, the mother of Nick Rizzo, who handles the reservations and special events. Nick’s father, David, died in 2001.
Dominick Chippie acknowledges that even in Windber, hiring and keeping restaurant staff is tough, as it is in Pittsburgh. There aren’t enough people in the area, let alone enough of those who want to commit to hard restaurant work. “Staff that stays for two or three years?” he says. “I’ll take it.”
Many customers book big tables for the New Year, whether they’re coming at 5:30 or 9 p.m. While diners may be familiar with price gouging that can go on for New Year’s Eve — when usually moderate-priced restaurants offer special menus for significantly higher prices — there’s none of that here. New Year’s Eve ordering is the regular menu a la carte, with family specialty prices that run from $15.95 for a chicken Parm, to $18.95 for that chicken Captiva. That’s the way it has always been.

Nick Rizzo has pointed out his mother Norma’s meticulous method for taking reservations: no OpenTable, NoWait or another online reservation app. She takes calls and writes in reservations on a Xeroxed sketch of the dining-room layout, where she pencils in names, as she’s done since she married into the family back in the ’70s.
Norma says that New Year’s reservations are full; there will be a few seats for walk-ins. “We have so many standing reservations: repeat groups of people that we know,” she says, as well as customers from Bedford, Pa., about 40 miles away in Bedford County. It’s the second biggest day of the year for the restaurant, with Mother’s Day the busiest.
Sometimes Norma gets calls from people looking to reserve a seat at Rizzo's Malabar Inn in Crabtree. That's recent — "since the rise of the Internet" — there's no relation. “We have the other restaurant’s phone number on hand,” she says, “and we coach anyone who calls for reservations with a 412 or a 724 area code to confirm they’re calling the right Rizzo’s.
Rizzo’s didn’t always use to be called Rizzo’s, but it has always been an all-in-the-family kind of place. In 1924, the website reads, Celestine and Mary A. Rillo, who had immigrated in the early 1900s from north-central Italy, built this spot where they lived in apartments on the second floor and operated a general store and meat market on the first floor. They opened the attached restaurant, then called Fairway Cafe, in 1937, where the Rillos made a living selling dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, pizza and salad. In 1965, the restaurant was passed down to Mildred and her husband, Anthony Rizzo, and with that, the name of the restaurant changed.
After Anthony Rizzo died in 1983, Millie and her children, Dominick, Tony Jr., Marie and David, maintained the family business.
For customers who walk through the Graham Avenue door, one of two entrances, they’re closest to the bar, a cozy spot manned by Dave Petrilla, who’s been pouring drinks here since the ’80s. It’s the easiest place to talk to regulars, such as one couple that comes four or five nights a week when they’re not living in Florida.
They sat at seats closest to the kitchen doors as a nearby diner feasted on mozzarella sticks, calamari and fried smelt. Another dish, the eggplant, isn’t a beauty plate, leaving customers to wonder what’s under the layer of sauce. But it is a favorite, delicate and perfectly cooked, ladled with the night’s “new sauce.” Those steak tips — also dressed in a secret sauce — recently surpassed every other dish as the restaurant’s best seller. “People take home the sauce for these too,” says Sienna.
As the bar room filled up, the youngest Rizzos went back to the host stand, while Butch returned to the kitchen, and Mr. Petrilla fulfilled customers’ drink orders.
Reservation clipboard in hand, Norma summed up why the restaurant has maintained such a following.
"All of us are here," she says, making sure to praise their staff. "There aren't many places left where there’s always an owner in the building."

Enter our Red Sauce special project
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.