Explanations for the number are as varied as the types of seafood dishes prepared for Feast of the Seven Fishes on Christmas Eve.
The feast, aka La Vigilia, is said to have originated in southern Italy with an emphasis on fish from the centuries-old custom of abstaining from eating meat to honor the sacrifice of Jesus. The number is believed to be seven for the seven sacraments, the seven days of creation, the seven days it took Jesus and Mary to travel to Bethlehem and the Seven Hills of Rome. But there also are three fish dinners that represent the wise men, 12 fish ones for the 12 apostles and 13 for the apostles plus Jesus Christ. And the overly ambitious knock themselves out with 21 and even 25 fish courses.
“QED Cooks” host, Chris Fennimore, remembers feasting on fishes prepared by his grandmother on Christmas Eve with his extended Italian-American family when growing up in Brooklyn, N.Y., and not being allowed to eat until after the midnight Mass. “We would be up until 3 a.m.,” he says.
There were no rigid rules as to what the fishes were or the number. “It could be four or five or six fishes. No one counted them then. Only people who want seven fishes count them,” he says, laughing.
But when it comes to dining out, restaurants are anticipating the counters at the feast and so are keeping to the seven-fish rule in some fashion, or at least serving a minimum of seven fishes.
La Tavola
A six-course dinner that features eight fish dishes starts with salmon rillettes and swordfish tonnato (tuna-flavored sauce) with crostini and followed by a mint-infused pea soup with lump crab and fried shallots. Caesar salad with fried smelts, fried polenta rounds with shrimp salad and fish meatballs are all part of the third course.
Cod fish stew with potatoes was a traditional Christmas Eve dish at chef Jolina Giaramita’s home when she was growing up and she features a riff on it for the fourth course — baccala with potatoes, red sauce and pasta.
“I change the menu every year and can be creative to do whatever I like. But if I don’t include the baccala and potatoes my father [who owns the restaurant with her mother] gets upset, and I will get into trouble,” she says, laughing.
Barramundi with onions and pancetta is the last fish dish before dessert, which is sweet potato mousse with amaretti crumble, marshmallow cream and balsamic syrup.
6:30 p.m. Dec. 20. 1 Boggs Ave., Mount Washington. 412-481-6627. Cost: $75 plus tax and tip. BYOB (cork fee included).
Talia
Owner Julian Vallozzi is honoring his family tradition by featuring seven types of fish that will be prepared separately but served together as one course. The octopus, calamari, shrimp, salted cod, mussels, clams and scallops will be served with a tomato sauce on a plate, almost like a plated cioppino or brodetto.
“We initially had discussed doing a seven-course dinner, but that is just not the way our family celebrates the Seven Fishes. Our family prepares several different fish dishes and serves them family-style at one time, rather than one course at a time,” he says. “But we thought it would be too challenging and distracting for the restaurant to bring multiple dishes together for one course. So this was our way of honoring that ‘family-style,’ one-course tradition.”
Since Talia is closed on Sundays and on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day, it will hold three feasts from Dec. 20 through 22 alongside its regular dinner service.
5-10 p.m. Dec. 20 and 5 to 11 p.m. Dec. 21-22. 425 Sixth Ave., Downtown. 412-456-8214. Cost: $35. There will be an option of a wine pairing.
Senti
Italian cooking is known for its nonna-style comfort foods but the cuisine has evolved and taken on a modern flair just like any other cuisine, says Annette Ishida, who co-owns the restaurant with her husband Franco Braccia. So for their seven-course feast they offer a “menu that is not too traditional but still is one that would be expected.”
There is no baccala, but other familiar fishes are included, with some having an Asian accent because new chef Jon Sterrett, who shares the kitchen work with Antonio Garcia, wanted to acknowledge Ms. Ishida’s half-Japanese heritage.
The menu starts with oysters garnished with roe on the half shell and served with the classic mignonette sauce. For the second “trio de pesce” course, tuna tartare comes on a truffle rice cracker; octopus is served with fennel salad and blood orange foam; glazed salmon comes with pearls of soy sauce. Calamari, shrimp and a shellfish are part of the mixed seafood soup, which is followed by the pasta course — tagliolini with sea urchin, miso butter sauce and garnished with nori. Pan-seared Japanese sea bass with roasted carrots and haricots with truffle vinaigrette finishes the fish-centric dinner. Dolce is praline with chestnut cream.
4 to 10 p.m. Dec. 24. 3473 Butler St., Lawrenceville. 412-586-4347. Cost: $90 without tax and tip.
Lidia’s Pittsburgh
Foods from the old and new worlds come together in chef Daniel Walker’s three course, eight-fish menu.
So for the antipasti course he has the classic 15th century Venetian baccala mantecato, a whipped salt cod, on crostini as well as the nouveau lobster cappuccino, a ragu with whipped potatoes that is finished with a dusting of paprika and served in espresso cups. Fried calamari and an arancini with crab and tomato also will be served in this course.
Mr. Walker has fond memories of making baccala with the grand dame Lidia Bastianich during the Christmas season when he was a sous chef at Felidia in New York City. He remembers the smell wafting through the restaurant when she boiled the cod to make large batches to give as gifts while chef Fortunato Nicotra would warm aromatics such as orange peels, cinnamon sticks and star anise in saucepans.
Two types of pasta are part of the second course — large tube paccheri pasta is served with langoustine in brodetto, which is basically mini lobsters in broth, and squid ink spaghetti in a white clam sauce.
For the secondi course, there is a choice of fillet of sole stuffed with spinach and lemon-caper butter; grilled tuna with winter caponata, an eggplant salad; baked lobster; and seafood soup with a tomato-saffron broth. An assortment of biscotti cookies finishes the meal.
Starts at 6 p.m. on Dec. 24. 1400 Smallman St., Strip District. Cost: $75 plus tax and tip.
Bar Marco
Bar Marco and Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream are not co-hosting the four-course feast but their owners are. It’s the fourth year that Justin Steel of Bar Marco and Chad Townsend of Millie’s will be getting together in the kitchen, and they are featuring nine fishes.
The first course comprises fritto misto (mixed fried things) with smelts, baccala and calamari; clams casino (where the clams are propped on their half-shells); lobster bisque; Caesar salad with anchovies; and a focaccia studded with anchovies. Rock shrimp from the Florida Keys flavored with garlic, white wine and Calabrian chili is served with spaghetti for the second course. Scallops piccata in the classic sauce made with lemon juice, butter and capers and snapper acqua pazza (which translates to crazy water) make up the third course.
For dessert, it’s Millie’s multilayered and flavored spumoni.
5 to 10 p.m. Dec. 18. 2216 Penn Ave., Strip District. 412-471-1900. Cost $80 includes tip.
Pino’s
Seven types of fish, prepared in southern-Italian style, will give a nod to owner Joseph “Pino” Mico’s heritage at the feast that will start with fried calamari with marinara sauce, fried smelts with spicy salsa rossa and whipped baccala, along with garlic-rosemary challah bread and a glass of complimentary prosecco.
Fennel-orange-arugula salad will be served as a palate cleanser before the three main entrees. Shrimp spiedini, aka Italian kebabs, will come with lemon aioli and hard-boiled egg; baked Calabrian swordfish with the tangy Sicilian sauce, salmoriglio; and squid ink spaghetti, made with a pasta machine imported from Italy, with mussels and clams.
A three-layer spumoni and almond biscotti will be served at the end along with Italian or American style coffee.
Starts at 6 p.m. on Dec. 16. 412-361-1336. 6738 Reynolds St., Point Breeze. Cost: $80 includes tax and tip. Wine, beer & spirits will be available for extra cost. It’s also BYOW for no charge.
DiAnoia’s Eatery
This is the first year that co-owners Aimee DiAndrea and husband Dave Anoia are hosting a fish-loaded feast but they are pulling out all the stops by holding it for four evenings.
Served family-style where the dishes will be scaled to the number of people in the party, the dinner will begin with four types of fish for the appetizer course — baccala fritters with fennel aioli; branzino crudo simply flavored with lemon juice, olive oil and sea salt; anchovy fried dough with hot peppers; and calamari with shrimp sausage in a prosciutto broth and served with the tiny tubular ditalini pasta.
The pasta course features octopus sugo with paccheri pasta and tomato sauce and scallops in a lemon cream sauce with angel hair pasta.
Pan-roasted branzino with a crispy skin is served with roasted potatoes, tomatoes and lemon for the entree, which is the final course. For an additional $12, caviar can be added to any item.
5 to 9 p.m. Dec. 19-20; 5 to 10 p.m. Dec. 21-22. 2549 Penn Ave., Strip District; 412-918-1875. Cost: $55 plus tax and tip. There will be a wine pairing for an additional $25 featuring a choice from two wines for each course.
Roman Bistro
It is more like the feast of 10 fishes here. The buffet-style features several stations such as pasta, ice (for clams and oysters) and cold salads where the fish faithful can go back for seconds and thirds for deep-fried calamari served with marinara and remoulade sauces, fried smelts and clams, shrimp pelini cocktail, smoked salmon, pecan-crusted Atlantic salmon that is roasted on cedar wood, cream of herring, mac ’n’ cheese with lobster, Maine lobster to be precise, pan-seared tilapia with olives, tomatoes and onions, baked Atlantic cod with lemon-white wine butter sauce and Caesar salad with anchovies.
For a sugar rush and something a whole lot less fishy, pizzelle, apple pie, coconut cream pie, chocolate mousse and mini cheesecakes complete the feast.
“It is a very big setup and takes up the entire space in the dining room,” executive chef Justin Richel says.
3 to 8 p.m. Dec. 24. 2104 Ardmore Blvd., Forest Hills. 412-871-3704. Cost: $28 plus tax and tip.
Stagioni
When Stephen and Cara Felder started the fish feast six years ago, they offered it only on the first Sunday in December. “It was so popular that we decided to serve it the first three Sundays of the month,” Ms. Felder says.
This year, it has grown to four dinners with the first two selling out quickly. The menu changes for every feast and includes some mainstays along with a few new additions each year. It is not revealed until a few days before each event.
Her grandmother, who emigrated from Abruzzo, Italy, when she was 16, used to make baccala fritters with a “pleasant addition of cauliflower” every Christmas Eve. And Ms. Felder’s father carried on the tradition. For the first dinner this year on Dec. 1, the Felders included the fritters.
PG staff writer Dan Gigler, who “feasted” last Sunday, had a refreshing salmon crudo with chopped beet, fennel and apple; smoked mackerel with roasted potato and romesco sauce; rock shrimp and braised chickpeas with an herb salad (pictured) and a positively addictive brandade — salted cod whipped into potatoes with milk and olive oil and served with still warm focaccia.
The multicourse dinner is served family style at large tables.
Starts at 6 p.m. on Sunday and Dec. 23. 2104 E. Carson St., South Side. 412-586-4738. Cost: $60 plus tax and tip. There’s a full bar and no corkage fee for BYOW.
Meat & Potatoes
Feast of Seven Fishes has become a tradition at M&P since it opened in 2011, says Jigmed Latshang, and so is branzino.
“It is almost always on the menu,” says the regional manager of the Richard DeShantz Restaurant Group.
Oysters on the half shell are served with a fresno chili mignonette and red snapper crudo with radish and avocado. Under the guise of fish and chips, smelts come with lemon aioli and salt-and-vinegar chips. Fried chickpea cake, harissa and preserved lemon give the crispy octopus a North African flair while the scallop goes on a nouvelle Italian spin with boursin risotto, tomato foam and caviar and the bronzino takes on a French accent and is served with gnocchi Parisienne, mushroom broth and watercress. Cavatelli has not one but two kinds of seafood — lobster and sea urchin are tossed together with basil and chili.
A flourless chocolate cake with candied almonds and honey-poached cranberries rounds out the dinner.
5 to 9 p.m. Dec. 24. 649 Penn Ave., Downtown. 412-325-7007. Cost: $85.
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.