Alla Famiglia has come a long way since the 1990s when it was an eight-table restaurant in an Allentown rowhouse.
That was when David Ayn opened the restaurant as a sibling to his now-closed Davio of Beechview. By 2005, his head chef, Jonathan Vlasic, had taken up his offer to buy the place. “Even then I was worried about filling tables,” Mr. Vlasic said.
Today, Mr. Vlasic and his wife, Brandy, need not worry, as it’s one of the most talked-about Italian-American restaurants in the city, with portion sizes that are exceptional. And now there’s an ornate dining room: The Vlasics bought the building next door years ago and reopened the revamped restaurant in January with a new entrance, a new upstairs bar, a lower-level open kitchen and plenty of seating — 150 in the dining rooms and more than 100 in the ballroom.
The menu has gotten more over-the-top, too, with one dish called “Under the Sea,” a starter of West Coast oysters, ponzu and Mikimoto pearls — for $6,125. There’s also the “The Submersible,” a switch-up with East Coast oysters and a Panerai Luminor watch for $6,250. And there’s still perhaps the city’s largest veal chop at 28 ounces for between $68 and $72, depending on how the chef prepares it.
The ultimate dining experience : An evening at Alla Famiglia
To add to the experience, Mr. Vlasic has built rolling carts to prepare meals tableside. They’re outfitted with space for butcher blocks and propane burners for dishes like canestri with Grana Padano and truffles shaved right beside diners. Called the Fallen Angel, the name is reinforced by a giant marrow bone served on the side.
Despite the expansion, the restaurant remains the kind of place that reinforces family — from the server who’s been there for decades to the three-generation team that works at the restaurant. Then there’s the driver of the Alla Famiglia Mercedes van, which picks up customers within a five-mile radius to bring them to the restaurant. He’s the father of a cook and the grandfather of a busser.
The restaurant has had a liquor license for years, but before the expansion, it didn’t have seats at the bar. It now has a sommelier, too, although Alla Famiglia still carries a favorite red of Mr. Vlasic’s, a versatile Malandrino Montepulciano from Abruzzo that he kept in the back decades ago — a gratis pour for customers who didn’t know the restaurant was then BYOB.
With these portions and prices, Alla Famiglia is for many a special-occasion restaurant. Though you’re as likely to see couples on dates as a group in collared golf shirts starting the night with a Super Tuscan bottle to kick off a guy’s night meat feast.
They’re likely not ordering the expensive watch with the oyster appetizer. No one had ordered it by early fall. “We do keep one along with those pearls in the back,” a server said, “Just in case.”
Who knows what lengths the Vlasics will go to in providing an all-out experience? It would not be surprising if at some point they one-up themselves by adding a giant slab of tiramisu for dessert — which comes with an Alfa Romeo.

Enter our Red Sauce special project
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.