A few months ago, The New York Times reported on a chemistry professor from Brooklyn who came on hard times yet continued to dine out, racking up $40,000 on his credit card, primarily from restaurants.
Dining out in Pittsburgh isn’t so expensive that it would warrant such debt, but the cost of going out to eat here has been creeping up. Unless you’re hitting a fast-casual spot or a diner, it’s fair to say that a drink plus an appetizer and main dish at more restaurants than ever will cost upward of $60 a person. That’s not terrible, but if you’re someone who likes to go out to dinner often, dropping more than $120 for two, several times a week, can get pricey.
Pie for Breakfast
200 N. Craig St., Oakland
412-315-7342
pieforbreakfastpittsburgh.com

- Hours: 8 a.m. to 3 p.m Monday, 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Sunday.
- Prices: Daytime menu items range between $6.75 to $10.99, with add-ons between $1 and $3, pie is $4.50 a slice; Dinner menu items range between $6 and $16 including breakfast all day; alcoholic beverages start at $5 and are no more than $9.5 for an individual pour.
- Sound level: Occasionally loud when it’s crowded.
- Details: No reservations, but you can hold a space in line on nowait.com; Wheelchair-accessible; street parking or across the street pay lot.
- Wildcard: Interesting beer to-go selection; tea towels, mugs and t-shirts available.
Enter Pie for Breakfast: It’s chef-owner Trevett Hooper’s least expensive, most accessible restaurant, following siblings Legume and Butterjoint on the same stretch. With an orange sign emblazoned on a building that sits on a corner, it’s an update on the diner with a menu that showcases mostly dishes that feature a meat-and-three sides.
There’s a lot to like about Mr. Hooper’s convivial new spot, with comfort-food menus — more pork chops and green beans than burgers and mac’n cheese — that deliver value. In short, Pie for Breakfast has what it takes to become a go-to place, even if pie for breakfast isn’t your thing.
The interior has personality without it being a simulacrum of a mid-century diner. A stainless steel counter runs down the room, framed by wood-backed orange-cushioned bar stools. Sky blue walls juxtapose plate-glass windows, and an oil painting of an athlete is both innocuous and notable in that it’s not an overt image of a Pittsburgh pro sports team.
The daytime menu averages about $7 before sides and add-ons, with listings on the menu like buttermilk pancakes, or two eggs and home fries served with salt-rising bread, a funky-scented, flavorful bread that originates in West Virginia. The dinner menu — it changes — can include smallish pork chops with plum sauce, ocean perch with grapes, stuffed cabbage, chopped lamb steak with harissa yogurt, braised tempeh, or a hearty salad, for somewhere between $9 and $16.
Even with its diner vibes, which usually means no alcohol, Pie for Breakfast serves booze. Choose among spritzes and mules for $7 to $9.50 or wines from American vintners for under $10. Drafts such as Bluepoint Lager, Penn Pilsner or Great Lakes Porter cost $5 or $6; there’s also a cooler of cans from breweries such as Sixpoint and Evil Twin for dine-in or to-go.
This is the kind of place where I sat next to a woman and her date who grabbed stools at the bar on a not yet busy Saturday night, and before the woman even ordered a drink, she asked the bartender if she could still get an order of pancakes. For her, a nostalgia dish like pancakes for dinner, slathered in butter and real maple syrup, was worthy of delight, maybe even with a glass of wine.
Her companion got biscuits and gravy, a dish I had enjoyed at another visit: I highly recommend them. I’m less enthusiastic about the porky greens I ordered on the side, a variation on collards served down South that were too sweet for me. If you’re craving Southern sides, go with cheese grits. An alternative starch would be the mujadara — rice and lentils — that I hadn’t ordered myself, but my companion did during a different visit, and, even though they were bland, I kept stealing bites. I preferred it because it didn’t deliver a sweet element, which is my biggest criticism of the menus: There’s too much sweet in the savory dishes.
Overall, though, I love this place. Mr. Hooper uses quality ingredients, and it shows. But the dishes aren’t particularly photogenic: As restaurants are revamping interiors and plating with Instagram in mind, it’s refreshing when a restaurant is less concerned about how things will photograph.
In the least Instagrammable order of the week, I ordered a brown plate. It started with meatloaf, a dish so humble yet beloved that a columnist wrote an entire book about it last year called “A Meatloaf in Every Oven.” The dish (not the book) was a little dense but perfectly seasoned and delicious. It paired well with a cucumber and pickled onion salad, housemade applesauce and black-eyed peas.
That night marked one of those restaurant meals I was thrilled about — not to mention, with a beer and dessert, the whole meal cost just over $20 before tip.
By all means, leave room for dessert. I was reminded how many customers are lured by the restaurant’s name when a guy made a beeline from the entrance to the bar at 9 p.m. to order oatmeal raisin cookies to go, except they weren’t on the menu. He went with chocolate chip cookies instead, and, paired with a frothy latte, it was fuel for his Saturday night.
I’m sure the cookies were great, but he should have ordered pie. Thumbs up for a simple slice of vinegar pie. Get the shoofly if you’re into molasses. Or consider a slice of pear, like the one I ordered after that meatloaf.
Now, if this slice were served at Butterjoint or Legume, it would have been hot, paired with a side of just-whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla melting against the heat of the pears. Regardless of how it's served, this is probably one of the best pear pies around, with its flaky, buttery crust, with an oat crumble atop generous layers of pears.
I would have fallen in love with it if it were brought up to room temperature. But at a less expensive, no-fuss place, it’s a still-cold slice from the fridge — just like you’d eat it for breakfast. And here, for many reasons, it is perfect.
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.