Grant Achatz’s restaurant Alinea in Chicago is among the most decorated in recent American history. To work there is to be in the most rarefied air of restaurant kitchens. So, it unlikely that it’s ever before been the stepping stone to owning a takeout pizza shop in … Millvale.
Pete Tolman cut his post-culinary school teeth there and at the equally elite Lautrec at Nemacolin Woodlands before hanging up his fine-dining toque to make the deep-dish, cheese encrusted Detroit-style pizzahe taught himself to make after trying it once in Colorado. His Iron Born Pizza replicates the style and was an instant sensation when it opened in the Strip District’s Smallman Galley restaurant incubator in June 2017.
Despite numerous offers to open a gleaming, full-service version of Iron Born in Oakland, Lawrenceville or Garfield, he’s settled on a pocket-sized former deli on Grant Avenue in the tiny borough.
“We went through at least three different deals that we almost signed. We signed two letters of intent. We were in major conversations” with deep-pocketed investors, he said.
“We had outside people offer everything from investments to points in the company to complete buyouts,” he said. “I had an offer for a total buildout, plus a salary.... That was too big for me. I didn’t feel comfortable.… I think I needed time to think about my own view of what the company could be and who I want to bring along with that journey and how we want to fund it and do it properly.”
He’s content to continue to perfect his product — both in the new space and at his Smallman Galley residency, which will end in June.
“I’m a cook, I don’t have money. I opened Iron Born on a small loan from a friend and I’m doing this the same way,” the 31-year old Kittaning native said.
Pending inspections, he hopes to sell food through this weekend’s Millvale Days Festival. At minimum he’ll likely at least have samples to give away. After the festival, he’ll close down again to put on the final cosmetic touches. Mr. Tolman’s landlord also owns an adjacent building that once housed a diner, and he said they’ve already loosely kicked around some ideas for that space.
“We are believers that Millvale is going to take off,” he said. “I truly believe that.”
Indeed, a bumper crop of craft breweries in recent years and the Pittsburgh Food Truck Park have made Millvale a regional destination.
He conceded that he would not have envisioned this route earlier in his career.
“I do think about that. I carried tweezers in my pocket for three years straight,” he said of the haute cuisine he once prepared.
Mr. Tolman noted that there’s been a national trend of elite fine dining chefs eschewing that world for more egalitarian fare. He cited another Alinea alum, Alex Stupak, a world-class pastry chef who now has a taqueria, and “he’s doing great.”
To that end, Mr. Tolman is placing a big wager on himself.
“How’s that saying go? You bet on the jockey, not on the horse,” he laughed.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.