In opening Talia Cucina and Rosticceria Downtown in March, owner Julian Vallozzi was on track to build a standout restaurant in the Alcoa building, with a fancy rotisserie and a focus on design — with cushy leather banquettes, monogrammed glassware and an Italian art-deco logo. But he was also spread thin, with big changes among three restaurants and his Downtown market.
Around the time of Talia’s debut, Mr. Vallozzi lost the head chef at the Greensburg Vallozzi’s who had been there for over 30 years. In response, he rejiggered things so executive chef Josiah Henry of the Downtown location would oversee both restaurants, doing what makes both Vallozzi locations popular: Sourcing some really nice ingredients while the front of the house offers polished and personalized service.
Then there’s Market Street Grocery, with a corner dedicated to caneles and macarons, a counter for La Colombe coffee, and a tucked-away wine bar. The Vallozzis were partners in the venture when it opened in 2015, but following a clash of vision with other partners — developer Ralph Falbo and his stepson, David Priselac — the Vallozzis recently bowed out. They differed over what to sell at the market, along with the fate of the upstairs space, where the other partners have been considering whether to open a restaurant. Opening a second-floor restaurant was not on the Vallozzi to-do list.
In the middle of all this, Talia was clamoring for attention like an average student in an overcrowded public school. But with the help of the Vallozzi’s tightened focus, and the commitment of Talia’s executive chef Steve Lanzilotti, the restaurant is finding its footing.
Talia Cucina & Rosticceria
425 Sixth Ave., Downtown
Read More
412-201-5656
taliapgh.com

- Hours: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday to Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, all day Sunday.
- Prices: Lunch: antipasti and small plates $3 to $9, pizza $10 to $14, pasta and risotto $14 to $15, entrees $12 to $17. Dinner: antipasti $3 to $13, pasta and risotto $13 to $21, pizza $10 to $14, panini $12 to $14, rosticceria $26 to $42, small plates $5 to $15.
- Sound level: Comfortable.
- Details: Wheelchair accessible, OpenTable reservations.
- Wild card: Interesting wine and amari list; don’t miss the $10 porchetta for to-go lunch Thursdays.
Talia’s menu is divided by antipasti and small plates, pizza, pasta and risotto, followed by entrees for lunch. There are a few additional options for dinner, namely the rosticceria section, showcasing meats like a T-bone, porchetta and chicken, with the small plates from lunch listed below the meats to be ordered as accompaniments. It’s an adjustment from a meat-centric menu the restaurant debuted with, Mr. Vallozzi said, in that it includes more pasta and vegetable dishes.
Prior to its opening, Talia promoted itself as the more casual sibling to Vallozzi's, yet its prices, which are similar or higher, don't reflect that. For example, more than half the entrees on the lunch menu consist of $14 to $17 salads and sandwiches — a little steep for the genre.
There’s nothing wrong with these prices per se: It’s just that many items have something incongruous or superfluous, like the pink peppercorns on overcooked spaghetti with butter and Grana Padano ($14). Or brisket that weighs down ricotta gnocchi ($15, $23 for dinner). Or bell peppers that aren’t quite right on an otherwise excellent porchetta dish.

The use of outlier ingredients would not bother me if this were a chef who had established his reputation before taking the helm. But in the PG’s people to watch column in 2017, Mr. Lanzilotti said that after graduating from Pennsylvania Culinary Institute, he had worked for a string of failed restaurants and was about to take a different career path before he joined the Vallozzi team.
A few edits would be good: There’s no need to try and please diners with disparate tastes with stray ingredients or dishes like uni and scallops served with meatball sandwiches.

That said, I am a fan of Vallozzi restaurants, and I admire Mr. Lanzilotti’s commitment and passion.
So here’s a strategy for diners:
Go to Talia for dinner, for good service and an interesting Italian wine list, with varietals from Basilicata, Venice, Tuscany, Sicily and Abruzzo for between $10 and $16 a glass.
Commit to a few small plates if you’re hungry, like mixed greens ($12), the roasted beets ($6), octopus with white bean hummus ($15), or the rosemary-laced Tuscan beans ($5) that are quite nice, though needed salt and more lemon at the finish when I tried them.
Consider pasta to share such as fettuccine with artichoke pesto and breadcrumbs ($17). And there’s no need to get bent out of shape that Talia charges $3 for bread, since it’s served with nice butter and above-average olive oil.

Pay attention to the meats, namely that beautiful porchetta or the chicken. They’re often the most delicious items on the menu and at $20 and $42, they’re well-priced.

Save room for dessert, like a generous portion of orange olive oil cake ($9), or the espresso soft-serve they’re calling Cremespresso, that, served in a clear mug, is one of my favorite desserts of summer. And amari is a must, whether it’s the bitter sip of Cynar to the caramel-laced Nardini.
Talia is worth visiting through the restaurant’s growing pains, and here’s why: Mr. Lanzilotti and the Vallozzis care about the restaurant, about you, and about the food they’re serving. As more restaurant chains from elsewhere flood the Downtown market to make a buck, that’s saying something. And my prediction is that, like the Vallozzis namesake restaurants, the place will likely improve with age.

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.