If you’ve been to Los Angeles and follow Sqirl on Instagram — the vegetable-centric daytime cafe that’s as popular with model types as it is with food cognoscenti — you’ll understand the 3-year-old Vandal in Lawrenceville.

There’s no world in which a Pittsburgh restaurant could get the quality ingredients that come with year-round sun that Angelenos take for granted. But it’s not surprising that a Pittsburgh restaurateur could be inspired by places like Sqirl, with a vaguely Scandinavian aesthetic that has captured the zeitgeist of an Instagram-ready restaurant serving beautiful food to beautiful people.

Back in Pittsburgh, the name The Vandal evokes a lawless street vibe, yet the spot from owner Joey Hilty and executive chef Csilla Thackray is the most manicured restaurant in Pittsburgh. With its white tables, white-tiled accent walls, blond shelving and opaque globe-pendant lights, it’s a look — assembled by the talented Emily Slagel — suited for the city’s Ace-Hotel era and Amazon embrace: not a single dated object in the place, Edison bulbs be damned.

 

Now hiring front of house | Please email résumés to Joey@thevandalpgh.com

A post shared by The Vandal (@thevandalpgh) on Jul 30, 2018 at 5:33am PDT

Ms. Thackray, a self-assured 27-year-old, has gotten more recognition in this post-#metoo moment that rightfully shines a light on women leaders in every field. Recently, she was a semifinalist for Eater Young Guns, which gives shoutouts to progressive industry folks under the age of 30 in restaurants around the country.

Advertise with us

Three years ago, The Vandal, which seats about 30, started as a counter-service place with a menu of fried chicken sandwiches and mac and cheese, beets and stracciatella, kale salad and cheeseburgers. With the recent nabbing of a liquor license, the restaurant has fully transformed from a daytime cafe to a dinner spot, with its most popular meal of the week — brunch — falling into second place.

Ms. Thackray has come up with a style that strays as far from the overabundance of meat-and-potato Pittsburgh servings as you can get. Instead, she delivers romance on a plate: wispy compositions accented by edible flowers and soft, stemmy lettuces and herbs, with ingredients plated rhythmically. Food & Wine  last year wrote that hers is “some of the prettiest food you will ever find in a Rust Belt casual cafe.”

The Vandal

4306 Butler St.

Lawrenceville

Advertise with us

412-251-0465

thevandalpgh.com

Overall:

  • Hours: Dinner, Tuesday through Friday from 5 to 9 p.m. and Saturday 5:30 to 10 p.m.; lunch, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. Tuesday through Friday; brunch Saturday and Sunday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.
  • Prices: Dinner: Starters $5 to $50, salads and small plates $10 to $13, entrees $15 to $32; brunch $8 to $16.
  • Sound level: Varied.
  • Details: Reservations accepted, street parking, wheelchair accessible.
  • Know before you go: Beer and wine for now, cocktails to come; keep an eye on Instagram for events.

Sometimes Ms. Thackray nails it: On one visit, I loved the scallop dish that announced spring, dressed with pea shoots and a quail egg. And I’d order the clean-tasting sea bass crudo with lemon balm curd and compressed fennel ($10) any day. The chicken leg crepinette is also quite nice, an exceptionally savory dish layered with peppers, polenta and chanterelles ($28).

Another night, my friend was impressed with the formidable serving of trout ($24), now served with heirloom peas, herb salad and red beet yogurt for drama. (I’d order that without yogurt, because I’m not a big fan of dairy and fish together.) If you really want to splurge, there’s the $50 caviar with black truffle creme fraiche, served atop salt-and-vinegar chips.

Advertise with us

Still, The Vandal is one of those restaurants that leads me to the question whether a restaurant’s cooking or design makes or breaks a place. In the era before the restaurant boom, I would have unequivocally said the cooking is the most important thing: the quality of the ingredients, the menu, the skill of the chef.

Lately I’m not so sure, especially as more people go out to dinner more often — looking for an engaging, stylish and more social spot than their own kitchens.

The role of design in a restaurant’s success was the subject of a recent episode of “Taste Buds,” the podcast from Corey Mintz of Canada’s Globe & Mail and other publications, who talks with the chef Jen Agg, founder of The Black Hoof (closing later this month) and author “I Hear She’s a Real Bitch” (Penguin 2017), a memoir about, among other things, being a strong woman in the restaurant industry. On the podcast, she argues that atmosphere, not food, is essential to a restaurant’s success, and it even manipulates diners’ perceptions of how food tastes — points that led to heated debate.

Through the lens of food-versus-design and value-versus-visuals, it’s easy to see how, in salt-of-the-earth Pittsburgh, The Vandal can be polarizing, despite the serenity of its white-on-white decor, its plant-filled patio and tables dressed with flowers. It swaps big portions and low check averages for something more aspirational, something outside of the city’s restaurant genre — and maybe just beyond the bounds of the staff’s experience.

The latter can lead to moments that can be mildly infuriating: such as when it’s clear the kitchen hasn’t correctly soft-boiled an egg presented in an egg cup, so peeling the shell off at the table is like picking up shattered glass.

Advertise with us

This was the case when I ordered the hostel breakfast with yogurt and preserves one Sunday, a dish that came with a homemade English muffin, along with a side of those soft, wispy dressed greens ($12). The rest of the order was under-salted but satisfying, especially that English muffin, although I’m sure I would have been satisfied with other options, including the soft scrambled eggs ($14).

The Vandal

Back to dinner service. When I stopped by for early evening appetizers with a friend who was moving out of town we ordered wine from a list assembled by Ms. Thackray’s fiance, Sean Rosenkrans, a sommelier at nearby Allegheny Wine Mixer. I ordered a Greco di Tufo from Campania ($12); she ordered Pax Mahle's Carignan (a red grape, $14), both of which were delightful.

The starters less so: A $5 tempura blossom order showed off two perfectly fine blossoms overstuffed with ricotta while a lone potato roll cost the same. Considering we each ate half a roll and one squash blossom, and the wines weren’t boutique showstoppers, I thought the prices were steep when our bill rolled around at $45 before tip.

 

A post shared by The Vandal (@thevandalpgh) on Jul 28, 2018 at 5:51am PDT

Even with those incidents, I like the place. If I’m concerned about price, I can go there for brunch. That, minus booze, can be less than $20 a person. Or I’ll go for dinner and order an entree, which may leave me hungry, and that’s fine: Not every restaurant needs to serve large portions.

Yet I understood when, the other day during brunch, a pair of older-than-millennial Pittsburghers walked out before ordering — despite that service was good and they had the best seats in the house.

Advertise with us

Maybe the menu didn’t resonate with them, or it was more than they wanted to pay. But for those who gravitate to The Vandal, in addition to some lovely dishes, it offers a portal into another world, one in which Instagram and real life coincide.

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.

Correction, posted Aug. 8 2018: Ms. Thackray’s fiance is Sean Rosenkrans, a sommelier at nearby Allegheny Wine Mixer: It was incorrectly spelled Rosenkranz in an earlier version of this story.