Friends and family wanted to know. Co-workers and customers demanded answers. Owners and managers got close, leaned in and softy whispered, as if about to share a national secret.

“So,” they said in hushed tones followed by a long pause. “................ Who’s the best?”

We live in a culture that ranks things, after all, and without hierarchy, there's disorder. And in a country founded on order, it seems almost inconceivable that we could let something so unabashedly American as hot dogs fall into anarchy.

Sorry to disappoint.

Advertise with us
Troy Kallenborn, 26, left, of West Mifflin and Mike Bosway, 39, of West Mifflin stand in the kitchen of Jim's Famous Sauce in West Mifflin. (Anthony Conroy / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Dan Gigler, a Post-Gazette colleague who makes his living visiting area restaurants, and I recently embarked on a journey to boldly go where many others have gone before. The caveat? In honor of National Hot Dog Day, we tried to visit 12 places in the Greater Pittsburgh area — a dozen eateries known mostly for their hot dogs — in a day.

We failed, of course.

But we did do it in four, and, well, that's somethin’.

And while it may seem unfathomable that there would not be rankings for such an endeavor — indeed, what other project better lends itself to such treatment? — the explanation was simple:

It’s not about rating. It’s about celebrating.

Advertise with us
The Post-Gazette's Dan Gigler talks to Karen "Nana" Dobrzynski and Raheene Dodd at Nana's New York Hot Dogs in the North Side. (Anthony Conroy / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Here's the odd thing about traveling to so many points throughout the city for something as simple as hot dogs: You learn a lot about the people who serve them and their roles in the communities they serve. Then again, maybe it's not odd at all. Hot dogs, after all, are one of the most communal of foods.

On the Central North Side, where the neighborhood has been built up, broken down and built up again, Nana’s serves as a place for meats and meets — a diverse mix of regulars and walk-ins sit at the lunch counter on old-school stools shooting the breeze, downing dogs with cheese.

Karen "Nana" Dobrzynski talks to a customer at Nana's in the North Side. (Anthony Conroy / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Frankie’s also sits in a neighborhood in transition. But, unlike the North Side, where progress sometimes seems to stall and stagnate, Lawrenceville is one of the city's hottest destinations, driven by millennials jockeying for real estate in the shadow of institutions of higher education and the ever-expanding health and high-tech industries located nearby. New places and hot chefs move in, catering to crowds wanting the next great gastro-inventive trend. Frankie’s, a remnant of that neighborhood's blue-collar roots, holds its ground on Butler Street — a '57 Chevy cruising the boulevard while Ferraris buzz by.

Colleen Griffiths-Fignar of Castle Shannon gets ready to put some of her famous chili on two hot dogs at Hank's Hotdogs Too in Brookline. (Anthony Conroy / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In Downtown off of Market Square, Lee Yovanof continues to carve out his own niche. When the Macedonia-born Yovanof left his country and settled in Chicago, he fell in love with the city’s culture, sports and, of course, unique style of hot dogs. When he moved to Pittsburgh in the 1980s, he brought the poppy seed bun, tomato-covered delicacy with him. And so Yovi’s, located on the sub-floor of a building in a section of the city where rents continue to skyrocket, persists — an island of Windy City ’tude in the heart of Yinzerville.

Personally, there’s always been a special place in my chili-stained heart for Hank’s Hotdogs Too in Brookline. When I was in high school in the late 1980s and early '90s, the restaurant was called Hank's Doghouse and located on West Liberty Avenue. Some of my favorite memories from those days involve my friends and I sneaking off school grounds — a no-no at Seton LaSalle — and making a break for Hank's. Once there, we stood tightly packed and shoulder to shoulder with the regulars, munching on Hank's Specials or a Dudeburger and sharing good times. Owner Colleen Griffiths-Fignar and her late husband Joe rescued the place, and she is keeping that tradition alive. Thankfully, many of those old regulars — myself included — have followed her to the new spot on Brookline Boulevard.

Advertise with us

So please forgive us for tossing the rankings. The journey means so much more.

Anthony Conroy, left, and Dan Gigler, at Lock & Dam Dog Shop in Morningside near the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium. (Andrew Stein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

On the first day of “the tour,” Mr. Gigler and I ended the night at Essie’s Original Hot Dog Shop — better known to you and me as “The O” — where we met staff photographer Stephanie Strasburg for a photo shoot under The O’s neon lights. Then we ordered chili-cheese hot dogs and, for some reason, an order of french fries that we’re still trying to finish.

In front of us were small tubs of gravy, nacho cheese, hot sauce and ketchup. One dipped a fry into the cheese. One into the gravy. One dipped a fry into the chili-dog.

It was a beautiful moment. That one I’ll rank No. 1.

Anthony Conroy: aconroy@post-gazette.com.

Advertise with us
Gravy, cheese, hot sauce, and an unseen tub of ketchup accompany french fries and chili cheese dogs at Essie's Original Hot Dog Shop in Oakland. (Stephanie Strasburg / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
The Post-Gazette's Dan Gigler, right, and Anthony Conroy, left, dig in to their orders of french fries and chili cheese dogs at Essie's Original Hot Dog Shop in Oakland. (Stephanie Strasburg / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)