Do Pittsburgh restaurants ban diners? What does it take to get banned from a Pittsburgh restaurant?

Local chef owners weighed in following last week’s culture-war face-offs at D.C. and Virginia restaurants — and their answers were as varied as the dishes they’re serving.

Over the weekend White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders was asked to leave the Red Hen in Lexington, Va., in the middle of dinner: She made the staff uncomfortable, owner Stephanie Wilkinson told the media afterward.

Ms. Sanders’ restaurant visit followed a week of heightened protest over the administration’s decision to separate immigrant children from parents at the borders, housing kids in cages at facilities around the country, often in different states from where their parents have been detained. More than 2,700 children have been separated from a family member.

Advertise with us

On June 19, Secretary of Homeland Security Kirstjen Nielsen was heckled by a crowd while she dined at a D.C. Mexican restaurant.

“How can you enjoy a Mexican dinner as you’re deporting and imprisoning tens of thousands of people who come here seeking asylum in the United States?” one of many hecklers shouted at Ms. Nielsen. And a few days earlier, White House policy adviser Stephen Miller — who orchestrated the child-separation policy — was called a fascist during his feast at a different Mexican restaurant.

On the decision by the Red Hen restaurateur regarding Ms. Sanders: “She did the right thing,” said Sonja Finn, chef/owner of Dinette in East Liberty. “In this darkest of times nationally and politically, we must live the resistance, fight with whatever little power we have,” she said. “That’s what Wilkinson did, knowing it could harm her business and livelihood and she would be under attack.”

President Donald Trump responded by lashing out over Twitter on Monday, calling the restaurant “filthy.” And Ms. Wilkinson has been doxxed, a form of cyberattack that entails passing around a person’s home address and phone number, social media info and more, so others can punish or shame someone for expressing her opinions.

The Washington Post editorial section condemned the action by the Red Hen restaurant to boot Ms. Sanders, while an Eater.com editor argued “Trump Officials Don’t Deserve Hospitality.”

Advertise with us

In her own restaurant, Ms. Finn said she has banned three diners in 10 years due to their behavior in the restaurant. She has never banned someone for his politics, “though after my recent [Pittsburgh City] Council run, I definitely have a list in my head.”

Ms. Finn ran in the March 6 special election for City Council seat for District 8, losing by a margin of 64 to 28 percent: a loss that was exacerbated by an 11th-hour attack by a powerful union, SEIU 32BJ, that endorsed rival candidate Erika Strassburger. The union is led by Mayor Bill Peduto ally Sam Williamson, whom Mr. Peduto appointed to the board of the Urban Redevelopment Authority in January. Both men backed Ms. Strassburger.

Other restaurant owners say they try to stay politically neutral. “There’s no place for politics in our restaurants,” said Bill Fuller, president of Big Burrito restaurant group, which includes Mad Mex locations, Casbah and Soba in Shadyside, Eleven in the Strip and others. “If you don’t want people to say ‘no’ to making wedding cakes, you can’t deny people dinner.”

He was referring to the Colorado baker who refused to make a cake for a same-sex wedding. The court case went to the Supreme Court, which handed down a 7-2 vote in June, a narrow ruling in favor of the baker’s position. The decision was tailored to the case in that the state law “can protect gay persons in acquiring products and services,” and that it must be applied in a manner that’s “neutral toward religion.”

According to the ACLU, “It’s not illegal for a commercial establishment to not serve someone they don’t like,” provided they’re not discriminated against due to the person’s gender, ethnicity, religion or race,” said Witold “Vic” Walczak, legal director of ACLU of Pennsylvania. “If [Ms. Huckabee Sanders] had asserted or could prove she was asked to leave because she’s a woman, or because she’s a Christian, that’s a different issue,” he said.

Advertise with us

But she didn’t. He did emphasize that in response to this cultural moment, “the ACLU does not encourage restaurants to exclude others.”

Back to Mr. Fuller: He’s not above banning someone from a Big Burrito restaurant — and he has, though it takes “an extreme nutbag” for the restaurant to move ahead with a ban. “It’s always over how customers treat our staff,” he said. “If you treat our employees like they’re not people, we are going to ban you.”

He told a few stories about customers coming on to staff saying things not fit for a family newspaper that has gotten people banned. Another guy was banned for being abusive at multiple Big Burrito restaurants, claiming bad food and bad service.

His staff handles situations as “a case-by-case basis,” but because there have been multiple bannings that are still in place, “I think it empowers staff in that they feel that we back them up.” But if, say, one of his chefs objects to the politics of a Sanders-type diner, the company would not allow him to ask her to leave.

Other restaurateurs have expressed similar policies.

Advertise with us

“Everybody has their opinions, but as an ownership we believe in hospitality that serves everybody without discrimination,” said Tolga Sevdik, partner in Richard DeShantz Group, which includes Meat & Potatoes, Butcher and the Rye, Pork & Beans, Downtown, and others. “If there is an inappropriate situation or conversation occurring, our general managers are to follow protocol to de-escalate the situation and, if that fails, patrons will be asked to leave,” he said.

Andrew Garbarino of Twisted Frenchman in East Liberty said he would “never ban anyone for political issues. I believe that we as a society have more problems to worry about.”

He will and does ban people who “treat my staff with disrespect” or “disrupt other guests in an inappropriate way, or generally speak harm about the establishment,” he said. “That’s negativity we just don’t want here. We all work hard as a team and we all look out for one another.”

Restaurant critics, of course, are often banned from restaurants, with this reporter having been banned from at least four in Pittsburgh, and Pittsburgh Magazine’s Hal B. Klein recently banned from a restaurant for a review that the owner did not like.

But when it comes to this political moment and this particular administration, “God, that’s so hard,” said Sherree Goldstein, owner of the Square Cafe in Regent Square. “I’d have a really hard time serving her right now,” she said if Ms. Huckabee Sanders visited the restaurant. She said she vocally supports “forward-thinking” candidates locally and nationally and that liberal policies like the Affordable Care Act have “given me a way to move my staff forward.”

Advertise with us

But she’s not into silencing anyone. “We want diversity. And we want to have challenging conversations,” she said. “On second thought, it might be a good thing.” She then asked her staff what they’d do if she visited the restaurant.

“Hi, Sarah,” said one server with a little extra attitude. “Have a seat.” Another answered, “Sarah who?”

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.