The 1996 independent film “Big Night” is a cult classic in the restaurant world which continues to inspire. Several Pittsburgh chefs share their own personal “Big Nights” — when a night that was supposed to be perfect went badly awry through no fault of their own.
Matt Christie, Streets on Carson, South Side
“The Dog”

Eight or nine years ago I worked for a prominent, high-end caterer in Philadelphia. This guy wants us to do his wedding. He looked like the Gorton’s fish sticks guy, with the beard and the yellow slicker. And his fiancee was half his age. He has an organic farm near West Chester and says that we can come out and pick whatever ingredients we want to design a menu. The Amish are going to donate chickens, lamb and ice cream. I thought, sweet, I’ve never done anything like this. So we go out there and plan this great menu.
So, we show up for the event. We had a 29,000-pound box truck with a full mobile kitchen in back. People are dropping off tents, doing setup. They have a Grateful Dead cover band. And the florist gets there, and they’re setting flowers up. I’m on the back of our truck and all you hear is a loud whimpering “raaaaawwrrr.” And we’re all like, “What the hell was that?”
The florist ran over the dog. Killed these people’s dog while they were leaving the farm. The bride is out there holding the dog, sobbing. The uncle took the dog to the vet, but it was dead. Needless to say, the mood of the event swung quite a bit.
Read More
Chef Matt Christie of Streets on Carson on his "Big Night"
Pete Tolman, Iron Born Pizza at Smallman Galley, Strip District
“The Misunderstanding”

I was 23 years old and working at a [internationally recognized] fine-dining restaurant as a mid-level cook — not at the top and not at the bottom. And when you’re in that spot, as a cook … you do not want to make the chef angry, or get anywhere on his radar. We used to have this pork dish that I’d come in on my day off to marinate, we’d poach it for three days, sous vide it. It was in a spicy pork broth with miniature bok choy.
At the time, I had a friend and his girlfriend who wanted to come in for their anniversary. They were still in college — so to eat in this restaurant was a huge deal. … Any time you cook for someone in this dining room, it’s very exciting. They’re dressed real nice, she looked beautiful.
So it gets to this pork dish. I plate the dish. I know it’s good. I’ve tasted it. I know 100 percent it’s dead on.
My girlfriend at the time was serving their table … When she cleared the table and asked about that specific course, my friend looked at her and said, “I loved it, but I found it a little tough to eat.” And what he meant was the [bok choy], not the pork.
She relayed that to the chef, who thought he meant the pork.
All of a sudden I see a head pop on to my station.
“Your friend thinks my pork is tough to eat? The only time it’ s tough to eat is if you rip it out of the bear’s claws.”
From that moment on, my friend is in the dining room having the best meal of his life and I’m in the kitchen getting destroyed — too salty, too sweet not hot enough, not cold enough.
I know what I put out was good … This pork would fall apart if you touched it … But that one little word ruined my week.
Pete Tolman of Iron Born Pizza on his "Big Night"
Stephen Felder, Stagioni, South Side
“The Storm”

A few years ago, we did a farm dinner and had been checking the weather compulsively from 15 days out.
It’s a nice day toward the end of the summer. We built a huge fire to cook everything on. We roasted all the vegetables and planned five or six different dishes and had a huge cauldron that we made a pork sugo with tomatoes and peppers. Fire, metal, salt, oil … everything was going swimmingly.
Then we see rain off in the distance but think this will pass over. The sky kept getting grayer. But we still thought we’d be OK. Then the sky opened up and just poured. Like insane. A monsoon. It just kept going and blowing sideways, and we’re covering dishes. These poor servers are drenched. Maximum saturation. It’s loud, it’s really dark and we’re calling audibles as we’re doing it. As far as plating, there was none. The plan, we threw it out.
That year the final dish was meatballs that had been braising all night in the cauldron along with this beautiful heirloom produce, with bread grilled on the fire. So we served everybody, and, of course, it stopped raining. And we’re like, “What just happened?”
But we ended up having a cool food moment — we’re having these warming, comforting meatballs and sauce that had been cooking for hours with this wonderful bread. And everyone left happy. Wet but happy.
Christian Frangiadis, Spork, Bloomfield
“The Walk-in”

In the late 1990s, I had this place called Christian’s in Turtle Creek. And I was young and arrogant, and I thought, it doesn’t matter, I’ll go there and cook and people will come. And I’m across from this burned-out foundry in a building with no windows. Nothing. I didn’t have any money — enough to buy some wine glasses and paint the inside like the color of a salmon and put up a sign.
We had a tiny staff, but we won best new restaurant in Pittsburgh Magazine. I was absolutely floored. The same week that we won that, [longtime former Post-Gazette dining critic] Woodene Merriman came in and gave us a 4-star review. That was the convergence of the perfect storm to get busy. Everything at once.
That weekend it was like 96 degrees and 100 percent humidity, and the air re-circulator went down. And there’s people lined up out the door. It’s like 125 degrees in my kitchen. And my cook, Marge, was a wonderful middle-aged woman who was very heavyset. And we’re cooking, and I’m seeing fishhooks from near heat stroke. I’m delirious. I had to step outside. I come back in, and Marge says she’s going down to the refrigerator to get a tenderloin. And she doesn’t come back up. My other cook goes downstairs and comes back up and says, “Chris! Marge passed out. But it’s OK, I put her in the walk-in [cooler].”
And my mind wasn’t even working right. It was like cooking drunk. We were pushing all this food out. And, the long and the short of it, is, we forgot about Marge. We had this old bartender, Edwin, and he goes downstairs later that night to get some alcohol and I hear him shout, “CHRIS! CALL AN AMBULANCE!”
And then the ambulance comes, and at first they thought it was for me. But they went and got her on the gurney, and as they’re coming back up the steps, they drop her. Needless to say I went to the hospital after the night was done. She was OK, though. But I thought we almost killed her.
Chef Christian Frangiadis of Spork on his "Big Night"
Fiore Moletz, Della Terra, Harmony; and Burgh’ers, Harmony and Lawrenceville
“The Ignoramuses”

It’s almost every day. I feel like Italian food is so bastardized that when you try to keep it traditional everyone thinks they know better. Regardless of the trips to Italy to work or the chefs from Italy you’ve worked with or the books you’ve read and translated about Italian culture and tradition, or the fact that your entire family is from southern Italy, everybody else knows better than you.
Places like the Olive Garden, Bravo! make it hard for us to not have the Big Night experience every night. A couple prime examples: “There isn’t enough sauce on this pasta”; “Can I have cheese for my linguine alla vongole”; “Do you have balsamic for my olive oil” “My pasta isn’t cooked all the way” (it’s al dente!). Countless photographs of undressed pasta with sauce poured on top (always cook the pasta in the sauce!) with meatballs piled high. We had one customer say they were going to go across the street to [a pizza shop] for a “real Italian meal.”
Steve Lanzilotti, Talia, Downtown & Jared Lordon, House of 1,000 Beers, Cranberry
“The Audition”

Steve Lanzilotti: We were working at a South Side chop house and the chef had moved on and the owner kept the restaurant rolling and gave us a chance to make it our own. The menu was going to be all us and we were planning concepts for months. We planned a tasting dinner for the owner and his friends that was to be our unveiling and instead was …
Jared Lordon: Our demise. … We were young dudes. We were like, ‘This is our shot.’ Like Rocky or Eminem. We were working our butts off. We did handmade pasta, we made beautiful sausage with pistachio, truffles and pecorino. We did red wine poached pears with ice cream we made.
SL: That excitement and enthusiasm, we were like, ‘Let’s make it happen.’ We put our heart into that food.
JL: They were supposed to be there at 6:30 p.m. Everything was coursed out. They were nearly two hours late, and when they showed up — they weren’t at church. They were sitting at a bar. When they smiled to say hello, all I could see was purple teeth.
SL: You would have thought we were sitting down with the Top Chef panel, the way they were critiquing everything as soon as we put it out. Everything could’ve been different, could’ve been better, could’ve been this, could’ve been that. Or, they had [a similar dish] at this other place like that and it was better. And, did you mean it to be like this? There wasn’t one thing.
JL: I’ve had hardcore chefs that I’ve worked for critique me less. They ripped everything. We had been there since 9 a.m. They ate for two hours, then spent two hours tearing us apart. One guy stood up, tapped his cigarette on the table and said — I’ll never forget it — “some dishes were good, some were absolute failures.” I thought it was some of the best food we made together.
SL: Then the next day it was like it didn’t happen. The owner wasn’t a foodie by any means. So The menu never changed. And the place went out of business a few months later.
JL: We both almost changed careers after that. But we stuck it out and things are good now.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.