Shrimp cocktail is back on restaurant menus, even if it seems like it never went away. Often served in a coupe glass, crustaceans fan around the rim like a flower, with a side of the cocktail sauce-horseradish combo and a wedge of lemon.
Today, there’s no shortage of where to get one. Two spots Downtown serve them: Eddie V’s Prime Seafood with “atomic horseradish” and spicy mustard for $16 and at Union Standard in the Union Trust Building, where it’s $2 per shrimp served with Old Bay vinaigrette and cocktail sauce. Shrimp is served shell-on in the Creole shrimp cocktail for $12 at Muddy Waters in East Liberty. Down the street, it’s on the menu at Bar Frenchman, served with a beet root cocktail sauce. And, of course, it’s available at Penn Avenue Fish Company in the Strip District.
Rise and revival
A nod to Continental cuisine, shrimp cocktail was first served in U.S. restaurants as early as the 1930s at a San Francisco restaurant on Fisherman’s Wharf for 20 cents. Locally, oysters and terrapin trumped shrimp in that era and became more popular with the rise of shrimp cocktail during the ’50s through the ’80s, according to menus in the New York Public Library national menu project.
“I’m really happy to see the shrimp cocktail coming back,” says Henry Dewey, co-owner of Penn Avenue Fish Company.
He said the volume of shrimp he’s been selling has gone up three times in three years — and the shop sells “more shrimp than just about everything else.”
People carry expectations with what they’ll get when they order a shrimp cocktail, says Andrew Garbarino, chef-owner of Bar Frenchman and Twisted Frenchman. “We switched up from prawns to shrimp that looks like those in a more conventional shrimp cocktail,” he says. He serves shrimp grilled, with a beet root cocktail sauce in the center ($15). Now it’s a top-selling starter, plated old-school style, “like it was in its glory days back in the ’70s and ’80s,” he says.
Shrimp cocktail is more popular now for a couple of reasons: For one, there’s a return to nostalgic dishes, like oysters Rockefeller, beef Wellington and prime rib, at places like Cure and Poulet Bleu in Lawrenceville. Two, there’s the renaissance of restaurant raw bars, with shrimp among the most popular items followed by oysters, crab claws and lobsters. And more imported shrimp along with a rebounding economy seems to have brought the dish back, according to purveyors.
By the numbers
When Mr. Dewey ran Benkovitz Seafood in the Strip — which had been the city’s oldest seafood company before it closed in 2013 — shrimp sales dropped off after 9/11 and people stopped spending, he said.
Today, “the economy is up there right now,” he says. More than ever, it appears that shrimp is an impulse purchase in that “it’s not something people feel they have to save up for.” The biggest ones are the best-sellers for the holidays, when 10 Gulf shrimp sell for about $36 per pound.
He’s also selling shrimp cocktail to-go at his new Downtown spot, Penn Cove Eatery, where an 8-ounce serving sells for $7.
Mr. Dewey says the price of shrimp “has gone up in price considerably” lately. This is unusual because there’s more of it coming into the U.S. Last year, the country saw a 10 percent year-over-year rise by volume and a 12 percent increase in value. Shrimp from India is leading imports, according to Undercurrent, the London-based seafood business news site.
Over at Land and Sea, a Monroeville distributor, vice president of sales Dan Schumacher also says that shrimp sales are up, compared to, say, 2014, because there’s more “high-quality, farm-raised” shrimp on the market. “Three years ago, it was at record highs and shrimp cocktail was expensive to menu,” he says.
Today, “a lot of shrimp is on the market,” citing 21- to 25-per-pound counts that cost about $4 per pound wholesale. Gulf shrimp -— as opposed to shrimp from India, Vietnam or China — might cost a little more at the moment because it’s right before the shrimping season begins in late May.
Prepping
Mr. Dewey’s favorite shrimp has “a snappy texture, tastes like a shrimp and imparts a little ocean flavor.”
In preparing it for shrimp cocktail, his staff poaches shrimp in a big pot, with salt, celery and lemon in the water. As shrimp cooks, “you want it to look like a lowercase ‘c,’ not a lowercase ‘e,’” he says. “Once the tail has curled up and the shrimp look tight, it’s overdone.”
Cocktail sauce is 50 percent of the dish; he makes the Penn Avenue version with ketchup, horseradish, black pepper, chili sauce and lemon.
Mr. Dewey has perfected their systems for making a shrimp cocktail he considers just right. He says, “I could pull our shrimp cocktail out of a lineup.”
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com; Instagram @postgazettefood; Facebook @postgazettefood.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.