Pittsburgh-born Brent Young of The Meat Hook in Brooklyn has quietly parted ways with the Whitfield at Ace Hotel in East Liberty.
“It’s an amicable split,” he says, citing his own to-be-announced projects as reason for his departure.
The website still includes a nod to Mr. Young as co-founder, but the shout-out — “helmed by Pittsburgh natives Chef Bethany Zozula and James Beard Award-Nominated Pastry Chef Casey Renee” — reinforces that Whitfield, one of the city’s highest profile restaurants, is officially run by women.
Ms. Zozula comes from many years working under Derek Stevens at Big Burrito’s Eleven in the Strip District. Ms. Renee switched from savory cooking to pastry at New York’s Del Posto, known for its wild desserts. She was lured back to the area by the pastry position.
The duo oversees a 26-person kitchen staff, which includes four sous chefs, two butchers and four pastry chefs.
“We’ve been running things day-to-day since we opened,” Ms. Zozula says.
With the transition comes a check-in on how Whitfield has evolved since its 2015 debut:
A relationship with Pennsylvania’s Jubilee Hilltop Ranch is super important.
Mr. Young was instrumental in crafting the menu and setting the groundwork for sourcing through Neal and Cheryl Salyards’ Jubilee Hilltop Ranch, in Bedford County. A relationship with farmers is the cornerstone of the Brooklyn butcher shop he co-owns.
Grass-fed beef is prized in local, organic and foodie-centric circles. For some diners, however, it takes getting used to meat that’s not grain-finished beef, a feed associated with more industrial producers that’s not particularly good for the animal. While they’re often slaughtered when the animal is a little older than grain-finished cattle, an older animal can produce more flavorful beef.
It says a lot to work with one farm that can humanely raise animals — as opposed to switching producers and not giving the purveyor time to adjust.
As a result, whole-animal butchery remains the center of the Whitfield menu. The restaurant gets supplemental cuts along with a side of beef a week that’s broken down by in-house butcher Steve Beachy, who joined the team as a sous chef when the restaurant opened. Today there are two butchers.
Yes, there are tenderloins, strip, rib-eye and porterhouses on the menu. The less-desirable cuts have defined the bar menu by way of the burger, duck leg confit, beef jerky and a dish called the Sausage Party, a trio of links that may include kase kreiner, kielbasa and bratwurst, served with a slice of Pullman bread and mustard. Even duck cracklins dress up the snack mix.
Duck and trout are exceptionally popular.
“We cook so many ducks,” she says. It’s on the brunch menu as duck-leg confit, there’s the duck liver mousse starter, a duck breast entree, and duck fat kettle corn and cracklins in the snack mix, the latter two on the bar menu. The ducks are sourced at Joe Jurgielewicz & Son, a duck farm based in Berks County.
Over the summer, the restaurant has started to get Laurel Hill trout from Somerset twice a week.
Vegetables make a difference.
“When we started we didn’t have a lot of non-meat options,” Ms. Zozula says. “But the culture of Ace Hotel brings in a lot of vegetarians and vegans.”
Incorporating more veg-focused dishes was easy for her, since she grew up in a vegetarian household. The restaurant now has a vegetarian tasting menu. She’s noticed that tried-and-true vegetable sides sell — like roasted vegetables and mashed potatoes — over, say, scalloped parsnips and chicories.
The secret menu of the spring will feature Jamison whole lamb.
Look for a separate lamb menu like one featured on Jan. 31 and another coming Feb. 21, then every other week. Lamb from Jon and Sukey Jamison’s Latrobe farm will be showcased with its own menu, with plates that include rack, chops, meatballs or a roast. Snack-sized dishes like toasted leg of lamb on toast with whipped chevre and honey for $6 are featured alongside larger plates like rack of lamb with the Indian spice blend vadouvan, celery root and kale for $32.
Doughnuts are the brunch driver.
Whitfield launched with brunch every day, but “it wasn’t practical,” says Ms. Renee and Ms. Zozula.
Since then, weekend brunch has become one of the most popular meals at the restaurant, in part because of those brioche doughnuts that are fried to order. The spiced doughnut holes served warm with apple caramel are being switched out this weekend to blood oranged glaze served with citrus sugar, three for $5.
The passion fruit bombe is the best-selling dessert.
Even with items like mint chocolate chip cake, cranberry apple sundae or whipped butterscotch cheesecake, the passion fruit bombe is the most popular dessert.
“People come from Philly to eat it,” says Ms. Renee of the brown butter cake with brown butter brittle and candied hibiscus for $8. “I cannot take it off the menu.”
It’s a dessert that reflects Ms. Renee’s aesthetic of detailed-meets-disheveled, the latter an influence of her New York mentor, Brooks Headley, who’s known for assembling less-than-Instagram-friendly desserts.
“Every bite has to be worth it,” she says of her desserts. “It has to matter.”
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com; Instagram @postgazettefood; Facebook @postgazettefood



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.