French fine dining is coming back, with classic dishes inching onto restaurant menus in cities around the country. Having opened in August, Bar Frenchman is Pittsburgh’s newest example, one of two restaurants from chef-owner Andrew “Drew” Garbarino in the East Liberty building that had been the Royal York Auction Gallery.
Bar Frenchman is the more casual sibling to The Twisted Frenchman, a tasting menu spot that opened upstairs last month. Both restaurants marry French cuisine and modernist techniques, which, for the casual restaurant, translates to updates on steak frites, coq au vin and cassoulet.
Despite the menu, this is not a restaurant for a classicist, in part, because Mr. Garbarino likes modernist cooking gadgets along with pearls, powders and foams — which are sometimes relied upon at the expense of presentation and taste, for somewhere between $60 and $90 a person.
Bar Frenchman
5925 Baum Blvd.
East Liberty
412-665-2880
thetwistedfrenchman.com
Overall:

- Hours: 5 to 10 p.m. dinner, Monday to Thursday and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday; closed Sunday.
- Prices: Drinks $7 to $15; starters and chilled seafood $12 to MP; entrees $16 to $28; steak frites $22 to $100+ depending on the cut and sourcing; sides $5 to $8; dessert $3 to $11.
- Wild card: Weekday happy hour from 5 to 7 p.m. offers $8 glasses of wine and $6 house cocktails, with a similar deal during Friday late-night menu from 11 p.m. to 2 a.m. Add-ons like shaved truffles or scoops of ice cream can really raise the price of the bill.
- Noise level: Generally loud.
- Details: Wheelchair accessible. Parking on street. Reservations via OpenTable.
Less muddled than the cooking is a larger point: Mr. Garbarino wants diners to enjoy themselves, to have as much fun as he and his staff are having back there in the kitchen, turning out food on Hestan appliances, the Lamborghinis of kitchen equipment. His type of fun isn’t brazen or boozy. He wants his staff to take care of you, and they are good at it.
Why French fine dining is back
The comeback of old-school French cuisine started around the same time as the resurgence of French pastries — when the popularity of the macaron challenged the cupcake — followed by restaurants adding dishes like boeuf Bourguignon to their menus.
Then in 2013, Philadelphia-based restaurateur Stephen Starr stoked diners’ nostalgia for all things French, with the opening of Le Diplomate in Washington, D.C. — the wildly popular bistro serving hundreds of diners a night. It’s “a two-hour trip to Paris complete with crusty baguettes, steak frites and naughty pictures in the bathrooms,” wrote Roxanne Roberts of the Washington Post in a piece on the $6.5 million build-out and power brokers clamoring for a table.
Mr. Starr outdid himself three years later in New York with a fancier French restaurant, the high-profile Le Coucou with a what’s-old-is-new-again menu of pike quenelles in lobster sauce and Dover sole, with desserts like omelette Norvegienne, a mini baked Alaska.
Which brings us to 2017, with retro-styled French restaurants now opening at a faster clip.
I give this context to point out the degree to which new Pittsburgh restaurant concepts, menus and design are increasingly shaped by restaurants in bigger markets around the country. Nowhere more can you see it here than at Mr. Garbarino’s restaurants, who applies his love of Modernist cooking to the revival of French classics.
Big dreams
Two restaurants and two separate kitchens cost Mr. Garbarino and his partners millions to open, which includes buying the 120-year-old building for just under $1 million, and building kitchens from scratch on each level.
Before Mr. Garbarino’s epic pair of openings, diners had been getting to know him around 2015, when he opened the Twisted Frenchman around the corner on South Highland Avenue during a short-term lease. The restaurant picked up where Notion left off when it closed and the space allowed Mr. Garbarino to fine-tune dishes, decide on kitchen design and to monitor how diners would respond to his cooking.
By the time the lease ran out, he was well into progress on the new space. In between locations, Mr. Garbarino traveled and dined around the country — as he’s done with his family since he was a child — pulling ideas from famous restaurants, ranging from dishes to the decor.
Based on the design and the menu, those that most inspired Mr. Garbarino are Eleven Madison Park (New York), Alinea (Chicago), The French Laundry (Yountville, Calif) and Daniel (New York). These restaurants have stellar reputations, with Eleven Madison No. 1 in the “World’s 50 Best” restaurants this year. Their inspiration is especially apparent in his kitchens, in the upstairs lighting and the $800-a-piece chairs copied from Alinea.
Unlike those restaurants, which poured a ton of money into designers — like the architect Glen Coben who designed Mario Batali’s Del Posto in New York like an Italian palazzo — Mr. Garbarino designed the two dining rooms himself, with the ground-floor Bar Frenchman a cavernous, moody space accented by the building’s original tile floors.
Past the glass wall that looks out to East Liberty, tables are dressed with white tablecloths and candles. The bar leads to the glassed-in kitchen in the back of the building that beckons with its brightness. Elements of his South Highland restaurant remain, like the decorative colored glass sculpture above the bar.
Did I mention that it’s loud? This is not the place to bring a group if you want to hear across the table.
What to order
Straightforward fare is the way to go with a menu of chilled seafood, starters like escargot and foie gras, and mains like cassoulet, coq au vin and different cuts as the base for variations on steak frites. The aspirational dishes seem like they’re reinvented as training-wheel versions for diners who might consider classic preparations too fussy.
For the escargot ($14), snails are draped in mushroom ragout and hidden in creamy grits: Sure it’s unusual, but considering that it’s near impossible to find escargot with shallots and garlic on any Pittsburgh menu, why not offer it? Or better yet, why pair snails with assertive ingredients that bludgeon their flavor?
In another classic dish, the coq au vin ($26) starts with the rooster sourced in North Carolina that’s served with meat stripped from the bone in a departure from the traditional version. It’s easier to eat, though it takes away from the drama of serving a bird on a plate. And the potato puree in the dish is not so different from the escargot’s grits in terms of texture, in this case, paired with roasted parsnips and other root vegetables. And while it’s likeable, it falls short of the deliciousness of the original preparation, for which everything is cooked together and flavors marry.
Cassoulet — often served with sausage, lamb and/or duck confit as a casserole-stew with Tarbais beans — is memorable for the drippings that combine with bean starch, a creamy contrast to the crustiness baked into the edges. The vegan version seems like vegetables have been cooked sous vide, then finished as a saute and assembled into a shallow bowl. It’s on the dry side.
Still, you can eat well here, though the best dishes at Bar Frenchman are those you might find at other Pittsburgh restaurants, which reinforces the degree to which the city suffers more than ever from a staff shortage of very experienced cooks. It points to the kitchen’s embrace of component cooking over traditional techniques. And it suggests the difficulty of turning out labor-intensive classic dishes without modernist gadgets and space-age flourishes.
You can’t go wrong with the oysters on the half shell. And be sure to get a salad because the produce comes from a great source, Chef’s Garden in Huron, Ohio. The Caesar shows off lovely Baby Gem lettuce topped with grilled bread from La Gourmandine, laced with the savoriness of anchovy. Another starter, the French onion soup ($12) is an original take, with bourgogne brie rafted on crostini in a soup of crab, mushroom, and a demi-glace made of deep roasted vegetables, caramelized onions and a whisper of sherry and steeped thyme. It defies expectations and it’s satisfying.
Get excited about steak frites that start with choice: a flat-iron ($22), venison ($32), filet, and 50-day, dry-aged New York strip among them, served with a fine version of frites. Go a step further and consider another choice: Any cut is available Oscar-style (add $12), dressed with buttered crab and a bearnaise-like custard that is so decadent it draws attention from other tables (and might cause gout). Or get the 5-ounce Japanese wagyu, a marbled specimen that costs $100 a pop. It isn’t terribly French, but it is luxurious.
I haven’t yet mentioned the drinks, which can be compelling, from bottles of Beaujolais ($50) or chenin blanc for fair prices, to cocktails from bar manager Greta Harmon, like a sidecar or the two-drink minimum ($14).
The latter starts as a Manhattan served in a giant snifter, accented by an oversized ice cube made of Benedictine, Peychaud’s bitters and Angostura bitters, that, as it melts, turns the drink into a Vieux Carre. It’s two classics in a glass, with a modernist update that works.
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com; Instagram @postgazettefood; Facebook @postgazettefood



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.