With more restaurants competing for diners, rebranding is becoming more common.
The changeover from Verde Mexican Kitchen & Cantina at 5491 Penn Ave. in Garfield to Prairie in October is the latest local example of a rebrand — and there are more in the works.
Although rebrands are driven by increased competition, they’re not exactly new, here or elsewhere. Last year, for example, My Big Fat Greek Gyro, with the assistance of CNBC Prime’s “The Profit,” transformed into a modern, bright, fast-casual restaurant renamed The Simple Greek.
But the uptick in rebranding points to more fierce competition.
Verde/Prairie owner Jeff Catalina hatched the transformation in the thick of the Penn Avenue construction that started in August 2013 and lasted through the beginning of last year.
The two-phase, $10 million project made the neighborhood more pedestrian-friendly, with new facades on storefronts, wider sidewalks and more trees. But the detours and hassles for motorists pummeled restaurant business in the area. Salt of the Earth closed in August, and Verde closed for renovations over Labor Day weekend.
Five weeks later, Mr. Catalina’s Verde reopened as Prairie, a bourbon-and-beer-focused restaurant with accessible fare.
“We wanted to spark a change,” he said.
Since Verde opened in 2011, the market has been saturated with places that serve margaritas and tacos, with restaurants like Patron Mexican Grill in East Liberty, Tako Downtown and several locations of Steel Cactus.
In addition, he was taking a risk with his showcase liquor. Try as he might to convert the masses to artisan tequila, it proved to be a tough sell. “Pittsburgh is a beer and bourbon town,” he said.
Combine that with people’s appetite for conscientious sourcing and “non-fussy food,” and Prairie was his answer.
Shane Morrison of Acacia on the South Side consulted on the cocktail program while Mark Sampson, former executive chef at the now-closed Toast in Shadyside, runs the kitchen.
With the rebrand, the restaurant is just now beginning to see early Verde-level sales, he said. The recent Restaurant Week had been especially good to the place, bringing in more than 100 covers on Monday and Tuesday nights.
Chicken and biscuits are the best-seller, with gravy and a root vegetable hash. A Monday night hot chicken dinner is also popular, paired with drinks such as the $7 Woodford Reserve Lil’ Mule.
Mr. Catalina is optimistic about the neighborhood’s potential, citing new developments like the opening of Aldi; the September opening of the lounge/cafe Mixtape at 4907 Penn Ave.; Bantha Tea Bar at 5002 Penn Ave., also in September; and the Eastern European-inspired Apteka at 4606 Penn Ave., scheduled to open later this season.
He also pointed out details such as the new lit cube benches that remind residents of its role as an arts corridor.
“Finally, some positive developments out of all that construction,” he said. “I am excited about it.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.