Lidia’s Pittsburgh in the Strip District has gotten a facelift. It’s not just a nip and tuck but a gutting that exceeds the construction costs of many new restaurants opening around town.
Lidia’s Pittsburgh
1400 Smallman St.
Strip District
412-552-0150
lidias-pittsburgh.com
Opened 15 years ago, Lidia’s has retained its backlit wine wall in the renovation, but has made many other updates: A once open kitchen is now closed. A massive white marble bar replaces a gray slab. Italian honeycomb tiles now line the barroom floor. And a TV that doubles as a mirror will be installed this week.
Furniture has been replaced, too. In the bar, oversized wood stools swap out red cushioned ones. The rail that had been across from the bar is now a row of tables for two. Tables and carpet have been updated in the dining room, and the banquet room upstairs seats more diners.
The restaurant’s renovations, courtesy of parent company Batali & Bastianich Hospitality Group, point to more than just a new look. An expensive renovation like this one is an acknowledgment of Pittsburgh’s changing dining scene and Lidia’s commitment to keep pace.
While these changes are welcome, the restaurant needs to make a few more adjustments to deliver a warmer experience.
From the sounds of it, the restaurant is working on them. Matt Green, the interim general manager, for example, is here from Kansas City to hire his replacement, an essential role in the restaurant.
First, let me point out that I think Lidia Bastianich is a culinary treasure. Her restaurants around the world remain destinations. She has educated us about regional Italian cuisine. For some, she’s up there with Julia Child in teaching us how to cook.
Lidia’s restaurants are special to me personally. In my 20s when I lived in New York, my childhood friends worked as servers and bartenders at Becco and Casa Mono. The staff there helped educate me about Italian wines, especially those under the Bastianich label. And as I learned to cook, Lidia’s cookbooks were one of many ways my father and I bonded over food.
With her contributions to cooking and dining, Lidia’s Pittsburgh should have a much higher profile amid the influx of new and innovative restaurants opening throughout the city. Among recent challenges, the restaurant has been hampered by road construction that’s made access difficult.
Here are a few reasons to come back. There’s a happy hour every weekday from 5 to 7 p.m. when diners can order house wines, beers and small plate menu items for $5 apiece. They include dishes like fritto misto, sausage and polenta as well as antipasti.
There’s also a generous brunch for $29, which includes pastries as well as a collection of interesting salads displayed on a table in front of the fire. For the main course, I recently enjoyed a delicious lasagna Bolognese — one of the few times I’d order it in a restaurant.
I also like a few regional specialties on the dinner menu like the sarme — cabbage rolls filled with beef and pork. The dish may resonate with Pittsburghers who had their share of them at family gatherings, though it’s also a dish from Istria, the Croatian peninsula across from Venice where Lidia is from.
The polipo (octopus) can be a crowd pleaser. Though it’s traditionally boiled, executive chef Nicole Neely serves octopus grilled, with potatoes, olives, red onions, capers and French cut beans.
But there are more substantive ways for Lidia’s to draw diners.
• It would help Lidia’s Pittsburgh to acknowledge the ways in which Pittsburgh’s tastes are changing.
For one, it can find ways to bring in diners past 9 p.m., whether it’s those who live in the new buildings in the Strip, or people staying in the new hotels in the area. The restaurant’s closing is a full hour earlier than Eleven a block away. For diners who walk in at 8:45 p.m., it would be great if they didn’t feel chased out, or alone, as I did, when I was told I had 10 minutes to order before I took off my coat. I know that the server wanted to be accommodating, but that’s not the greatest way to welcome someone.
• Keep the lights low and the fireplace going. In the four times I visited the restaurant in the cold weather, the fire — a focal point of the restaurant — was going only at brunch.
• Court guests who want to learn about Bastianich wines by the glass and the bottle. They are far superior to the house wines, and they’re tough to find at Pennsylvania liquor stores. Have bartenders more pointedly educate diners and change the menu to more prominently offer flights of the family’s wines. One bartender who served me several times clearly knew the wines — when I asked — while another directed me to the Bastianich website.
• Show more care in serving wine, period. When I ordered first a glass of Rosato and then a Friulano, both were flaccid like they’d been open too long.
• Serve dishes made to order. My dish of pollo al limone — a chicken breast of a standard thickness, served with olives, capers and lemon — was scorchingly hot. And the lemon sauce had formed a film over it.
These suggestions are just a start, and they’re easy fixes.
When Lidia opened her restaurant here she told the Post-Gazette, “When we decided to take our restaurant concept out of New York, we wanted to look at mid-sized cities that are being revitalized. Our style appeals to both a local and international clientele,” she continued, “but we also want to be part of our community. That can’t happen in a large city. In Pittsburgh there is new construction and we sense a new energy. I need to feel comfortable and Pittsburgh makes me feel good.”
Pittsburgh is happy Lidia’s is here. And we’re especially pleased when she comes to visit.
But when she’s not overseeing the restaurant, it would be great for a re-energized staff to accommodate the tastes of a changing Pittsburgh, offering the kind of hospitality that renews loyalty and builds fans.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter@melissamccart





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.