With the city’s restaurant renaissance in full swing, it shouldn’t be overly ambitious to seek out a place that serves good specialty coffee drinks and interesting craft beers under one roof.

Marty’s Market

2301 Smallman St.

Strip District

Advertise with us

412-586-7177

martysmarket.com

  • Hours: 8 to 11 a.m. breakfast, 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. lunch, Monday through Friday; 5 to 10 p.m. Wednesday through Saturday; 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. brunch, Saturday and Sunday.
  • Basics: Marty’s is a specialty grocery store, coffee bar, bottle shop, bar and restaurant with straightforward dishes that aim to please many appetites.
  • Dishes: Pickle jar, beef heart, pierogies (all), fall salad, chopped salad, kielbasa, whole trout, brick chicken, pappardelle, greens, mashed potatoes, fingerling potatoes, pig’s head torchon (brunch).
  • Prices: Dinner starters, $6; pierogies, 2 for $5; salads, $5; plates, $10 to $16; sides, $4. Lunch salads, $9 to $13; plates, $11 to $12; sides, $3 to $6; sandwiches, $9 to $15. Breakfast plates, $6 to $10; omelets, $11 to $12; sides, $2 to $4.
  • Summary: Wheelchair-accessible; street and garage parking, credit cards, event space.
  • Noise level: Moderate to loud.

But it’s been a hard find in Pittsburgh, partly because of the liquor laws as well as the city’s history of championing a different kind of pairing.

Whether you’re an old-fashioned, shot-and-a-beer type, or you prefer a deep, rich espresso before a coffee stout, you can now swing both ways at Marty’s Market in the Strip District.

A market cafe that’s home to a destination coffee bar with a rotating cast of baristas, Marty’s isn’t new, but the booze and brews are.

Advertise with us

Dinner was introduced when owner Regina Koetters landed a liquor license in July. It dialed back the market space and expanded the restaurant and its hours, which now include variations on breakfast, lunch and brunch seven days a week, as well as dinner Wednesday through Saturday.

What strikes me about dining at Marty’s is that it’s refreshingly modest, which can be unusual in the era of the chef-driven restaurant. Simple dishes here point to a young kitchen staff, a reliance on fresh ingredients (and salt, which I appreciate). It’s a welcome break from the stacked components and spoon-pushed sauces of cheffy plating.

One reason I suspect there’s little ego here is because it has been far from an easy ride since Marty’s opened in July 2012.

For starters, the vast space had been a cursed location before, and when the place initially opened, with restaurant rows and bigger grocery stores pulling customers to other neighborhoods. And while Marty’s had its share of supporters before it secured a liquor license, in the big picture, it has has battled flat sales, high staff turnover and, at times, infuriatingly inept service.

Like many Pittsburgh restaurants or purveyors that need an infusion of money, Marty’s Market got itself a liquor license, as well as the determination to build something that would please the neighborhood.

Advertise with us

So far, the place is on track.

Dan Lamb, the former kitchen manager of Franktuary, is running the kitchen. In creating a dinner menu of starters, salads, sides, plates and pierogies, he has considered the cravings of vegetarians and meat lovers alike, with standbys like mac and cheese and boundary pushers such as beef heart.

While in the past, I’ve been frustrated by Marty’s artisan prices for wilted produce at the market, the restaurant prices are fair, with most of the menu falling around $4, $5 or $6. Entrees run between $9 and $16, with lunches a bit more expensive than dinner, which is priced to bring in repeat visits from locals.

Here’s why: “We want to become a place for people who live in the neighborhood,” said bartender Brandon Muske.

Ms. Koetters agreed. “We want this to feel like a very social extension of your living room.”

Advertise with us

As I ordered a negroni alla Vaniglia ($9) and my friend chose the delicious baked pear highball over crushed ice ($9), Mr. Muske told us about one regular who has dashed over from one of the apartments in pajamas just for a beer and an order of mashed potatoes.

That same bartender says he gets the beef tartare a couple of times a week, a cake of raw meat with a quail egg in the center, served with cornichons, pickled shallots and caper aioli. I’d probably get something else. While the egg yolk is lovely and bright, the meat was made too many minutes ago and looked a little oxidized.

Also among starters, there’s a terrific pickle jar and a cheese board so full it’s a blizzard of feta, a triple cream Campo de Montalban, brie, fruit and baguette. It’ll please diners who like cheese and big portions, but may disappoint a cheese snob for a lack of variety and restraint.

I love the whole trout, perfectly cooked, liberally salted and dressed with herbs and a hint of sweetness from the pecan brown butter. The halved brick chicken is also a crowdpleaser, a juicy specimen from Gerber Farms, served with salsa verde. I’m also into the kielbasa, made from in-house Rustbelt Sausage Co., a budding food business that’s turning out a good product. Here, it’s served with roasted grapes and German brown mustard.

The laundry list of sides is also smart, a collection of well-prepared vegetables. The greens are killer, collards and kale served with plenty of potlikker laced with a trace of apple cider vinegar. Shitake mushrooms with fennel and shallots are cooked to the right texture and arrive well-seasoned and garnished with flat leaf parsley.

Advertise with us

The barley risotto is less satisfying, served in a moat of beef stock, a reminder that risotto is hard to make in a restaurant a la minute. I’m also not into the fries dusted with “Ranch flavor” and served with Sriracha aioli because they taste processed. Local tomatoes in late September are almost there, but a little too past season, masked with an order of creamy burrata.

By the time dinner was over, I had switched from a negroni to Troeg’s Dreamweaver Wheat, a beer from Hershey that’s one of a handful on tap from Great Lakes, Fathead’s, Draai Laag and North Country, although the selection changes.

For those who have priorities beyond a coffee and beer pairing when they’re dining out, here’s what I’ll tell you. Marty’s is often fine, sometimes good, and occasionally great. The combination of all-day dining, simple, fairly priced dishes, a well-edited selection of beer, wine and cocktails, along with a coffee bar that runs through dinner is why I have given Marty’s two stars.

I realize that Marty’s comeback hinges on staff growth, good management and consistency that allows it to develop a following. I am rooting for the place.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.