Today I’m introducing an occasional series — a follow-up look at various restaurants in the region to note the impact of changes in chefs, management or style. A spot check after a formal review allows me to acknowledge improvements when a restaurant gets its rhythm. And it’s an opportunity to talk about a restaurant that started strong but may have faltered once it’s not in the spotlight.

Although I’ll acknowledge the original star rating from the previous review, I will not update the stars, because I’m not necessarily ordering from the menu as widely as I would for a full review.

Below, I’m addressing the effect of a chef change-up at The Commoner, a chef growing into his position at Kaya and how Stagioni excels.

The Commoner

Advertise with us

Management at The Commoner in the Hotel Monaco Pittsburgh Downtown has changed since I gave the restaurant three stars in March. Formerly directed by executive chef Dennis Marron, the kitchen is now run by Heather Terhune, a season nine “Top Chef” contender who left as head chef at BDK Restaurant & Bar in San Francisco (also a Kimpton property) to take the interim position.

After a recent lunch and dinner visit, I noticed that diners are paying more for the same dishes or pared-down versions of those on the January menu. Bread and butter are now $5 (before it was gratis), with less variety in a basket than when the restaurant opened. The brick chicken dish with roasted garlic potatoes, burnt leek puree and Brussels sprouts have lost the leeks and the Brussels sprouts arrive looking and tasting as if they had been boiled rather than kissed by fire. And the price has risen from $20 to $26.

Vegetables fall in the same price range, but the presentation is hit or miss. The succotash side ($8) with lima beans, corn, zucchini and red peppers is nice. But the eggplant salad on spinach ($8) is a disappointing ’80s-era remix. I wish the kitchen would focus on eggplant, the glorious summer vegetable that it is, rather than using the crutches of too-sweet balsamic and feta over naked greens. It made me miss the well-dressed hearty greens that, at $11, were infinitely more interesting because of the mix and the tart lemon vinaigrette: radicchio, kale and shaved sprouts served with barley.

Cocktails are better than they were at the opening, with the talented Brian Gastaldi as the bar manager. Prices are a notch higher or about the same, such as today’s Commoner Pimm’s Cup at $11, versus a $10 gin and tonic served back in March with housemade tonics in variations such as elderflower. A Hendrick’s negroni is $14.50 today while the oaked negroni had been $12.

Service in the bar and at the restaurant has also improved. Today, it’s more fluid and servers are warmer than they were in the opening months — likely because they are more comfortable in their positions. (458 Strawberry Way, Downtown. 412-230-4800)

Advertise with us

Kaya

Two things have changed since I reviewed Kaya in 2012 and gave it 1½ stars. (I docked the stars in part when I was served fried chicken that wasn’t cooked through.) For one, executive chef Ben Sloan is no longer new. “I was really fresh into the chef thing then,” he said recently. “I’ve obviously matured, and the position makes more sense to me now.” Mr. Sloan, 31, will celebrate his 10th anniversary with Big Burrito in October. He was first hired as a line cook and worked his way up to sous chef before he was chosen to run Kaya.

Among changes at the restaurant since he took over, Mr. Sloan said that the monthly vegetarian dinners — a four-course prix fixe for $39, with an optional $19 drink pairing — have become more popular. He also said the menu offers more tapas, with a focus on sharing.

Since that review, I have been back several times and have enjoyed good service from bartenders who knew the menu and were spot-on when recommending beer, wine and cocktails. I have enjoyed a satisfying burger that was obscenely tall, stacked with pickles, avocado, bacon, tomato, Chihuahua cheese, sunny-side up egg and Kaya sauce ($14). I have shared corn and lentil beignets ($9) and mussels that aren’t on the current menu. Jamaican jerked wings ($10) can hold their own to any wings in the city. And the field green salad with lime cilantro vinaigrette and pepitas ($7) remains a healthy crowd-pleaser.

Which brings me to another point about Kaya. As a new arrival to Pittsburgh, which I was in 2012, I saw Kaya through a different lens, not knowing the Big Burrito hierarchy. I wondered why there were burgers at a Caribbean restaurant. I wondered what made Pittsburghers so loyal to a menu with a little bit of everything rather than a more focused concept.

Advertise with us

Becoming more familiar with the city’s dining scene and Kaya’s role in it helps me understand why Pittsburghers are so fond of the place and have kept it lively for more than 20 years. The restaurant also has been the launchpad for several chefs on the rise, including Kevin Sousa of Superior Motors and Sean Ehland, now at Aster Restaurant in San Francisco. Learning these things has brought me a more nuanced understanding of its role here.

Mr. Sloan acknowledged that Kaya is a training ground for Big Burrito chefs. “I just got a line cook who was promoted to sous chef here, while one of my sous chefs was moved to Casbah,” he said. “It’s the sous chef shuffle.” (2000 Smallman St., Strip District. 412-261-6565)

Stagioni

With 2½ stars, Stagioni on the South Side remains one of my go-tos, although I find the events more polished than everyday dining. On one hand, casual is nice because it is familiar and can be familial. On the other, when it’s a business dinner — as it was in my case — and the restaurant doesn’t have enough menus to go around and the dining room isn’t full, it was awkward, especially when the no-menu moment was followed by missing silverware after the first course was served.

The food made up for it. One reason I enjoy Stagioni is for chef/owner Stephen Felder’s dishes that are simple and often quite lovely. Stagioni remains one of the few ambitious restaurants in the polished-but-not-fine-dining genre that refrains from the Pittsburgh trend of providing too many ingredients, which can come off as overwrought.

Advertise with us

For starters, I love the lupini beans with gray salt ($4) and the giardiniera, especially for the pickled fennel ($6). I also like a restaurant that’s not afraid to serve something very bitter, such as grilled radicchio ($6). And on several visits, even when a table’s diners think one of the polenta variations they’re ordering will be the best-of-show, the whole branzino with cucumber, dill, red onion and vinegar ($24) always wins.

If you haven’t made it here lately, start with an event, but you’ll need to plan ahead. The monthly Sunday dinners, for example, are often sold out well in advance. Yet there’s still room for an Oct. 1 white wine dinner, followed by a Sardinian five-course feast with wine pairings on Oct. 29. These kinds of experiences display Stagioni at its best. (2104 East Carson St., South Side. 412-586-4738)

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.