A BYOB restaurant since it opened in 2009, Avenue B is an oasis on this corner in Shadyside that has been built up with apartments and amenities such as Market District, a Crossfit studio and a salon.

Although outdoor tables here are a commodity, the setting is a little chaotic because it's also on a bus stop. Inside, it's quieter than recently opened restaurants around the city, without the restaurant theater that comes with open kitchens or high-designed restaurant concepts.

Taupe walls are flanked by oversized chalkboard menus. Pendant lighting accents the room with Edison bulbs while eggplant-colored tablecloths are dressed down with butcher paper. The service is really tight, with servers having mastered the balance of being present and polished yet unobtrusive.

Avenue B

Advertise with us

5501 Centre Ave., Shadyside

412-683-3663

avenueb-pgh.com

  • Hours: Lunch 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. and dinner 5 to 10 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday; lunch 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. and dinner 5 to 11 p.m. Friday; dinner 5 to 11 p.m. Saturday.
  • Basics: Avenue B is a tailored BYOB neighborhood restaurant with a seasonal menu and very good service.
  • Dishes: PEI mussels with smoked tomato nage; local greens with herbs and a sherry vinaigrette; smoked trout and spinach salad; Wagyu beef meatloaf; wild-caught fish and chips; lamb meatballs with beans and greens with romesco, smoked almonds and saffron; grilled branzino with tabouleh and Romaine.
  • Prices: Lunch menu/beginnings $6 to $14; main events $12 to $19; dinner menu/beginnings: seasonal menu $7 to $14, chalkboard menu $9 to $16; main events: seasonal menu $22 to $25, chalkboard menu $22 to $33.
  • Summary: Street parking, credit cards, reservations, wheelchair-accessible.
  • Noise level: Quiet to moderate.

In other words, there is little to distract from your company and the meal. And there’s no chef ego on display, although there could be: Chef Chris Bonfili’s sourcing is thoughtful, and his cooking can be on point.

He's had plenty of experience. Before Avenue B, he cooked at restaurants in Boulder, Colo., and Park City, Utah. He was also the executive chef of the former Red Room Cafe in East Liberty, which is now Spoon. He is also behind B Gourmet, which opened in Sewickley in 2012, with high-end prepared foods and counter service.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bonfili opened Avenue B with his wife, Jennifer, during the peak of the new American bistro revival, when celebrity chefs Laurent Tourondel and his BLT restaurants and Daniel Boulud and his DB Moderne were updating the genre throughout the country. This was right before the burger craze took over and pared-down, street food-inspired menus became commonplace.

The new American bistro shows an appreciation for technique and culture, with carbonara from Italy, tzatziki from Greece and nage from France. A bistro-inspired menu is still prevalent at Avenue B, although the two menus at one restaurant suggest the place is in transition -- even if it isn't.

The seasonal menu features crowdpleasers, while the chalkboard menu offers an ever-changing palette of creative dishes. It's Mr. Bonfili's attempt to please regulars as well as diners looking for something new.

His cooking is colorful and bold. Flatbreads ($11) are intriguing with arugula and bresaola topped with an egg. Another starter, the raw deal ($14-16) is Instagram-friendly, a trio of luxury bites with precise-cut, seasoned vegetables, raw fish or carpaccio; it changes nightly.

Seafood makes a mark elsewhere on the menu, served with stylish sides. Although I prefer mussels ($14) served simply, I like the creamy, smoked tomato nage that dressed the shellfish, and I used the toast to clean the bowl. The smoked trout and spinach salad ($11) also falls among my favorites because of the Laurel Highlands-sourced fish. When I was there, it displayed a sweetness with a brown-butter strawberry vinaigrette. (It will no longer be on the menu as of this week.)

Advertise with us

The wild-caught fish and chips can be striped bass, walleye or barramundi. I chose tempura-fried over a pan-seared preparation, served with mandolined fingerling fries, a tart Napa cabbage slaw and malt aioli ($25). The grilled branzino ($27) was also near perfect: sweet, flaky fish, served with grilled greens alongside black and green garbanzos. It's an interesting presentation of quality beans slow-cooked until tender.

Meat eaters won't be disappointed by the Wagyu meatloaf, Mr. Bonfili's answer to the burger, served with goat cheese-whipped mashed potatoes, crispy onions and tomato jam ($24). Wagyu also appears in his version of steak frites which may be hanger steak one night, flank another, updated with mashed sweet potatoes, favas, mint and black garlic ($33).

Sometimes sides steal the show, whether it’s fried Brussels sprouts with candied bacon, sweet potato fries or grilled asparagus. They change often and speak to the season.

After dinner, a honey ice cream was a conversation stopper; it was so deliciously intense, served with a shortbread crumble.

As much as I enjoy Avenue B, there are two things I wish for here.

Advertise with us

One: The kitchen would benefit from restraint with the aioli or squirt bottle designed-plates. Mr. Bonfili is using very good ingredients that would become more apparent with a less-is-more approach.

Exhibit A is the artisan pasta dish ($15), a cauliflower carbonara, garnished with arugula and an overcooked 5-minute egg that would be more satiating with less of everything, even the cream and bacon. Same goes for the halibut and butter miso scallops ($29), with somen noodles, mushroom dashi and sea beans that does not come together.

Two: I wish Avenue B gave a clearer sense of Mr. Bonfili. A few edits would do it, such as carving out one menu instead of two.

While there's enough to engage diners on multiple visits, a more harmonious experience would round out Avenue B's potential as a very good neighborhood restaurant.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.