For today’s column, I’m focusing on two questions that I’ve received from several readers, both regarding customer etiquette.
The first: How long is too long to camp out at a coffeehouse?
You see it all the time, people sitting in coffee shops with their faces glued to their laptop computers, surfing online or pounding out reports. Some people actually use coffee shops as their workplaces, spending hours conducting business from one of the small tables or communal counters.
“As long as you're still consuming something you′ve bought from the establishment, you're entitled to a table,” etiquette guru Henry Alford wrote in an email. He is the author of “Would it Kill You to Stop Doing That? A Modern guide to Manners.”
“Obviously, this needs to be conducted within reason: you can’t take more than an hour to sip a single cup of coffee,” he wrote. “Or, if you do, you need to accessorize that coffee with a doughnut or a cookie. If you're worried that you’ve overstayed your welcome, buy something. The more passive you are, the more you should buy: if you’re having an animated conversation with another person, you can get by with one coffee per 90 minutes; if you're writing on your laptop, maybe a coffee or pastry every hour; reading a book, coffee or pastry every 45 minutes; watching a video, you should be attached to an IV unit of coffee.
“I tend to be more lenient toward these hoggers of space than other people are,” Mr. Alford continued, “but that’s only because I’m in the habit of spying at the screen of their computers, and thus I know the sad truth: every one of them harbors an unproduced screenplay.”
Most of the time it’s not hard to find a seat at a Pittsburgh coffee shop, although popular magnet places in some neighborhoods have been attracting more customers, which requires patrons to be mindful when others are milling around looking for a seat. In other cities when there’s a full house, owners report having customers refuse to leave or cursing at them when they ask them to make room.
Even when there’s a wait, a full house doesn’t necessarily translate to profits, which is sometimes the case, for example, at the Commonplace Coffeehouse on Forbes Avenue in Squirrel Hill.
“We know we’ll have a lot of students,” said manager Jamie Lesh. “And while they don’t stay all day, they’ll stay for a few hours’ stretch.” Like several places, the shop offers customers placards to put on their table that read, “Please share my table,” to make room for as many patrons as possible. But “it’s almost always the same three people who use them,” he said.
The crowds have increased since the place opened in 2010, and the shop does an average of 300 transactions a day. What has changed mostly is that more people are coming through the doors ordering coffees to go.
Other places are adding seating to accommodate rising demand. In a high-traffic area on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, Espresso a Mano closed for a day for light renovations in April so owner Matt Gebis could swap a couch for bench seating along a back corner wall. He also added a counter for standing that parallels the coffee bar. He exchanged bulky tables for leaner ones and reconfigured the room.
“The motive was simply to open up the space in the cafe. The old tables were too large, and there wasn’t enough space to move around when it got crowded,” he said. “Really, every time I do something, the goal is to make the experience better for my customers, whether that be through improving the flow, or the aesthetics, or somehow trying to make the coffee better.”
Is there a time limit at the shop? Mr. Gebis is flexible.The general rules are to buy something every hour. Be nice. And don’t forget to tip.
Newer places or businesses opening soon in Lawrenceville, Bloomfield and the South Side are debating whether to offer Wi-Fi.
Some smaller shops are opening without it, emphasizing design, prioritizing connection to the space and in-person interactions. Coffee shop 4121 Main in Lawrenceville has a set-up that encourages standing and talking. The bright room is filled with artwork and arrangements from Kira Hoeg’s partner at the shop, Thommy Conroy.
“We want people to engage with the space and enjoy their moment here,” said Ms. Hoeg. “We wanted to create a beautiful aesthetic that serves as a retreat from daily life.”
A bigger independent operation, the Vandal from Joe Hilty and Emily Slagel, hopes to open at 4306 Butler St. in Lawrenceville in about a month, serving casual breakfast, lunch and dinner. Mr. Hilty said the place will have Wi-Fi, but how he’ll navigate people camping at tables will be a case-by-case assessment.
“I’d be happy they’re conducting business in our space, but if there’s a line out the door, customers should be aware of that,” he said. “You want customers to be happy, but a business has a responsibility to customers and to itself, to make money and to stay true to what the place was designed to be.”
So it appears that how long is too long depends on the shop. But customers should pay attention to whether a place is crowded and talk to staff as to what works best.
Question No. 2: How much are you supposed to tip a barista or counter staff?
According to the Emily Post website, customers have no obligation to feed the tip jar; however, patrons should “tip occasionally if your server or barista provides a little something extra or if you are a regular customer.” It does not say how much to tip.
“Tipping is something we talk about all the time,” said a barista at Espresso a Mano in Lawrenceville. She said there’s a difference between putting a scone in a bag versus making a coffee drink or a sandwich. The first doesn’t require a tip while the latter warrants one.
Still, some coffee shops encourage customers to choose a tip percentage — 10, 15 or 20 percent — when signing the credit card receipt on an iPad. The process practically shames customers into leaving more than 10 percent, and perhaps that’s rightly so, although the practice has led to “tip creep,” as The New York Times and Washington Post reported over the winter.
Pulitzer Prize-winning food writer Jonathan Gold in Los Angeles has suggested tipping $1. “The nice woman at the coffee place who remembers how you like the foam on your double macchiato?” he wrote. “A buck in the jar. Which, if you end up buying a scone or something, will end up being about 20 percent.”
For takeout orders, Emily Post again says there is no obligation, but it should be 10 percent if the restaurant employee offers curb service or he or she is handling a complicated order.
When it comes to the guy who takes a to-go order at a counter, it’s 10 percent. But otherwise, it’s 20 percent, says Mr. Gold, including when you’re getting counter service and you’re eating in, when you order Chinese food delivery, and when you’re getting drinks at the bar, where, by the way, you shouldn’t leave coins.
And unless you’re at Bar Marco in the Strip District, where tipping has been abolished, the Emily Post website suggests tipping those providing table service 15 percent to 20 percent, pre-tax.
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.