Since Il Pizzaiolo opened a second location in Downtown’s Market Square in 2013, it has drawn throngs of diners looking for the same high-quality Italian ingredients and dishes that has made its flagship location in Mt. Lebanon so popular.
But you’ll no longer find the restaurant’s founder and chef, Ron Molinaro, at the Downtown spot.
Instead, he’s back running the kitchen at Mt. Lebanon’s Il Pizzaiolo, where he is the sole owner. He’s likely the first person you’ll see when you walk through the door — dressed in a chef coat and checked pants in front of the Forno Napoletano oven, pizza peel in hand.
In Market Square, former CEO of Douglas laboratories, L. Douglas Lioon oversees the six-person partnership, which still includes Mr. Molinaro as a shareholder.
The food in Market Square is now prepared by the same crew that has been with Mr. Molinaro for years. Some of the cooks and bakers — largely unknown to diners — have resumes as deep as the city’s most touted chefs.
Although there are many valued employees who made the transition from Mt. Lebanon, three key people are the core Downtown: pizzaiolo Kevin Konn, executive chef Richard Sphatt and general manager Ryan Conley.
Mr. Molinaro said he feels comfortable with the Downtown staff in place. “I support Kevin and Richie and I want them to succeed. They are my people.”
The pizzaiolo
Mr. Konn is a seven-year Molinaro acolyte who’s the head pizzaiolo — that’s pizza-maker in Italian — with a staff of three bakers.
When he was in college at the University of Pittsburgh, Mr. Konn was a regular at the Mt. Lebanon spot, which opened in 1996. Hanging around the restaurant eventually led to his attending culinary school at the now-closed Le Cordon Bleu Institute of Culinary Arts, Downtown.
After graduating in 2005, he headed to Seattle and eventually landed a job at Via Tribunali, a restaurant with a passionate following during the rise in popularity of Neapolitan-style pizzas across the U.S.
Here, Mr. Konn learned under Dino Santonicola of Naples, Italy. When Mr. Santonicola left Seattle for Dallas, Mr. Konn returned to Pittsburgh.
Mr. Molinaro, who first taught Mr. Konn during his culinary school externship, brought his former student on board.
“He was hard on me when I started,” said Mr. Konn, but the owner helped him gain a more nuanced understanding of how to monitor dough, and better assess how temperature, time, water and humidity affect the fermentation process.
Today, in glasses, T-shirt and baseball cap, Mr. Konn looks more science grad student than pizzaiolo. Instead of school research, his notebooks are filled with the science of baking, a job that requires repetition, patience and disciplined note-taking.
“I’ve gone through hundreds of dough recipes since I started with Ron,” Mr. Konn said. “There are so many variables. Ron taught me that I need to write down everything to see how they affect dough in the process.”
He arrives each workday morning around 7:30. On weekends, he plans for enough dough to make 250 to 300 pizzas for lunch and dinner.
Each starts with super-fine “00” General Mills flour at about 65 percent hydration, so it’s somewhat wet. It requires minimal handling and two periods of rest. Then, after all that prep time, when the dough is ready to be dressed with ingredients, each pizza bakes in about 90 seconds in a 1,000-degree oven. The results are often delicious.
Although pizzas are an anchor, they’re not the entire menu. It’s important to Mr. Konn to recognize the difference between his skill set and the rest of the kitchen’s.
“I am a baker,” he said. “I am not a chef.”
The executive chef
Mr. Konn met Mr. Sphatt way back when, before he went to culinary school, when they both briefly worked at Italian Village Pizza on Smithfield Street, Downtown. The company was owned by Mr. Sphatt’s brother-in-law, and Mr. Sphatt owned this particular shop for two years.
A Brooklyn native, Mr. Sphatt moved his family here after he had been laid off as a chef de cuisine at the Waldorf-Astoria in Manhattan, along with 700 other hotel staffers in the fallout of 9/11.
He had attended the International Culinary Center in New York, then worked under Christian Delouvrier of the now-closed Maurice. Mr. Delouvrier also was known for his other restaurants, Les Celebrites, Lespinasse and La Mangeoire.
At Italian Village, Mr. Sphatt was trying to get his legs, to put food on his family’s table and to figure out which restaurants in Pittsburgh would be a good fit for him.
Years later, Mr. Konn introduced Mr. Sphatt to Mr. Molinaro when he was looking for a head chef. In 2008, Mr. Sphatt was hired as chef de cuisine at the Mt. Lebanon location.
“When I met Ron, I knew he gets it,” Mr. Sphatt said, referring to Mr. Molinaro’s attention to detail with ingredients and cooking.
For example, every Thursday night, Mr. Molinaro goes to the airport cargo facility and picks up fresh buffalo mozzarella shipped in from Caserta, Italy. He also sources many of his ingredients from the super high-end Gustiamo, the Bronx-based Italian importer.
These days, Mr. Sphatt may not be using the same hard-to-get olive oil as Mr. Molinaro does, but he’s still sourcing that cheese he picks up at airport cargo, along with the DOP San Marzano tomatoes, although his are from La Valle foods rather than Gustiamo. He’s making fusilli as he learned during a trip to Italy with Ron, when an Italian grandmother taught him how to make the shape using a knitting needle.
And lately, he has been testing a dish that Pittsburghers would love: the spiedini alla Romana, a battered, grilled mozzarella cheese sandwich drizzled with white wine and lemon sauce, capers, anchovy and parsley and served on skewers. It’s a Friday special during lent.
The GM
Ryan Conley was one of the childhood friends who Mr. Konn used to visit at the restaurant when they were both in college. Today, Mr. Conley is the face of the front of the house in Market Square, managing 60 to 65 employees.
“You need an ebb and flow between the dining room and the kitchen,” he said. He’s now more comfortable orchestrating the pacing at the often crowded two-story restaurant, which is larger than the Mt. Lebanon location.
It’s not just the relationship between the kitchen and dining room that needs attention.
“We need to help each other to raise the skill level of cooks and management in this city,” Mr. Konn said, noting that many restaurants in Market Square share ingredients in a pinch — as well as stories and advice after work.
“We can all help each other improve,” he said. “ We should raise our expectations for ourselves and for each other. That’s what I’d most like to see happen here in Pittsburgh.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.