The crowd-sourced site Yelp celebrated its 10th year in August and has nearly doubled its views since 2012, with 134 million unique monthly visitors last year. Elite Yelpers review under their real names next to a headshot as an avatar; they share opinions on all sorts of businesses, not just restaurants; and they interact with other members online and through events.

I made a reservation at Meat & Potatoes, a Downtown restaurant that’s been reviewed by Yelpers nearly 700 times and lands among the most popular restaurants on the Pittsburgh site. It’s owned by chef Rick DeShantz and Tolga Sevdik, who are about to open Tako in March, next door to their Butcher and the Rye, also Downtown.

Although restaurants aren’t the most frequently reviewed businesses, they may have the most fraught relationship with Yelp. A Yelp rating star can affect profits in a business that has tight profit margins as it is (Yelpers can give a maximum of five stars.) In 2012, University of California at Berkeley conducted a study that showed that reservations in San Francisco went up 19 percent with a half-star increase.

Yelp has also provoked anger that has gone viral — from chefs’ dramatic readings of bad reviews to TV food personality Andrew Zimmern denouncing Yelp as “a tremendous forum for a bunch of uninformed morons.” More calculated responses to the site include a litany of court cases as well as a class-action lawsuit over whether the site can delete positive reviews if a business doesn’t advertise on the site. Yelp says it doesn’t practice this, but the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decided it can.

Advertise with us

Sure, some Yelpers are not restaurant or cooking experts, or even good writers for that matter. But some writers are quite savvy. And whether they can cook a perfect omelet is irrelevant when it comes to where they choose to spend their money. And let’s face it: A collection of Yelp reviews can have the power to improve service.

Jonathan Danial (Jonathan D), a business analyst originally from Buffalo who now lives in Observatory Hill, is the most opinionated of the Yelpers I took to dinner. Just before I met him, he had wrapped up a post on his first visit to The Commoner at the Kimpton’s Hotel Monaco, Downtown. He found the place underwhelming. He also visited Butterjoint in Oakland recently, where he liked the warm environment. He also liked the cocktails, although he lamented how at most places the costs are going up. Among his favorite local places are Olive or Twist, Downtown; Point Brugge in Point Breeze; and Casbah in Shadyside.

He’s smitten with Meat & Potatoes because of the vibe. He likes the food there, but when it comes to the menu, he’s looking for change. “We all know your bartenders are extremely creative, so let's see some new items hit the menu,” he wrote recently. And he’s hesitant to visit for brunch because it has become “such a big to-do.”

Another elite Yelper was Stacie Clark (Stacie C), a veterinary employee who grew up in Shaler and also lives in Observatory Hill. It was her first time at Meat & Potatoes, which does not align with the places that she usually reviews: most often, it’s low-key businesses such as the Steer & Wheel food truck, Caliente Pizza & Draft House in Bloomfield, Beto’s Pizza on Banksville Road and Keystone Deli, Downtown. She’s especially enthusiastic about the city’s beer scene. Roundabout Brewing in Lawrenceville has been a favorite lately, and she’s becoming a regular. She feels as comfortable going with friends as she does on her own.

We were joined by a pilot for a major airline, Jeremia Feyrer (Jeremia F), who moved with his wife to Mt. Lebanon to be closer to her family. He says he reviews on Yelp to help people navigate what’s out there, something he values because he’s on the road so much. “I feel like it’s like asking a local,” he said.

Advertise with us

He asks himself a few questions when he visits a place. “Is it cool? Was the service good? Was the food what I expected? And were the prices within reason?” He said he rarely writes negative reviews. Instead, he cherry-picks the places that resonate with him.

As a pilot, Mr. Feyrer spends many nights on the West Coast and in the Caribbean. Most recently he reviewed Beirut Restaurant in Romulus, Mich., Original Pantry Cafe in Los Angeles and Brat Haus in Scottsdale, Ariz.

In Pittsburgh, he went to Altius in Mount Washington in early February, where he said he had “the best service he’s had in a really long time.” He gave it four of five stars.

Not only do the number of stars awarded affect restaurants, but also they make a huge difference to these elite Yelpers when choosing a restaurant. Yelp community programmer Ms. Carlson said when she’s on the road, “I won’t visit a place with less than four stars.”

Ms. Clark said she deliberates when she’s had a mixed reaction to a place. She said there is a big difference between giving a place three stars or four stars. Such was the case when she visited Szmidt’s in Greenfield last year, which is in the process of relocating to Downtown. The owner, Darren Smith, was overwhelmed by a mistake advertised in his Groupon and was testy during Ms. Clark’s first visit.

Advertise with us

“It wasn’t the customer’s fault,” she said. “And it really colored my first experience.” After her two-star review, Mr. Smith reached out to her and apologized, asking her back. She took him up on it and has enjoyed several visits since. She updated the place to four stars.

Even in her initial Szmidt’s response, Ms. Clark said she was conscientious about her tone. “I try to be honest and fair in a kind way,” she said. Although some reviewers are super snarky or stop short of troll behavior, all three Yelpers said they take pains to avoid it.

As for my feelings about the site, I’ve never seen Yelp as competition to more formal restaurant criticism. Occasionally, Yelp can yield tips as valuable as those I get over text message, email, phone calls or visits. Most often, I use it to see if something specific has come to this market. When I was missing khar zan hingar, a delicious Burmese soup that I used to get at Burma-Tokyo in Oakland, I turned to Yelp to see if a new Burmese place had opened yet — and found one that’s three months old in West View.

Of course, there’s a lot on Yelp that I find distracting, but I occasionally read it for what’s popular and what’s not and why. From there, I compare what Yelpers, foodies, tastemakers and Post-Gazette readers value. Interesting enough, they often do not align.

I may use the site for different purposes than restaurants or these Yelpers do. But I’m glad it’s here. And it was fun to meet this crew.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.