Espresso in the United States has moved from a luxury drink to an everyday beverage with the rise of the coffee culture and the growth of specialty coffees.
“In Italy, espresso is what people drink several times a day,” said Matt Gebis, owner of Espresso a Mano in Lawrenceville, the shop he opened in 2009. “It’s to them what drip coffee is in the U.S.”
Places such as Commonplace Coffee in Squirrel Hill, Commonplace Voluto in Garfield and Espresso a Mano have helped fuel the transition, while soon-to-open shops such as 4121 Main are defining styles.
The 4121 Main venture hopes to open early this month, depending on inspections, in a charming 500-square-foot space in Lawrenceville. Frequent traveler Kira Hoeg, who designed and managed the coffee bar when Marty's Market in the Strip District opened in 2012, and artist Thommy Conroy are behind the project. It serves multiple purposes, housing Mr. Conroy’s florist work and event planning services and a gallery space and, of course, a traditional coffee shop with hours to be determined.
A reference to “fast“ (express) and “just for you” (expressly), espresso was introduced in Italy in the 1880s and grew in popularity through the early 20th century, with a boost from the invention of the steamless espresso machine by the Gaggia company in the late 1940s. In the U.S., espresso had been associated with Italian immigrants, cafes and counterculture types who hung out in them.
Serious coffee drinkers often steer clear of bigger brands. As the U.S. coffee culture has matured, it has sought out beans from Portland’s Stumptown, Chicago’s Intelligentsia and North Carolina’s Counter Culture.
But like boutique wines, more obscure coffee companies have an added allure, with single-origin beans more coveted than blends, especially because they have the feel-good element of a connection to farmers at the source.
Mr. Gebis has been excited about an Ecuadorian bean from farmer Fabian Lomas. The beans are roasted by local outfit Commonplace specifically for the shop, producing a pour-over with notes of molasses and sugar. He also sells beans from Verve in Santa Cruz, Calif.; Counter Culture, Forty Weight in Colorado; and Coava in Portland, Ore.
Bright and citrusy
Espresso drinkers can be cast into one of two camps, although “most espresso drinkers appreciate both styles,” said Mr. Gebis. The first prefers light, bright citrusy espresso, the result of brew ratios extracted by a barista. Coffee drinkers of this type enjoy espresso on its own as well as paired with steamed milk in a cortado or cappuccino.
This is Ms. Hoeg’s preference and mine, too. At 4121 Main, she’ll be serving coffee from Portland’s Heart Roasters, which no longer roasts beans specifically for espresso. Last year, the company announced that it was abandoning the practice because the dark roast ended up “flat and disappointing.” Newer styles roast minimally, with great precision, to bring out a range of flavors and nuances in the beans.
Rich and viscous
The other camp prefers a full-bodied concentrated drink, the result of a short extraction. Mr. Gebis cites The Big Trouble by Counter Culture, Streetlevel by Verve and most single-origin espresso roasts from Coava.
Mr. Gebis falls into this camp, but this wasn’t always the case. His obsession with coffee started at La Prima in the Strip District when he was a senior studying Italian at the University of Pittsburgh. He learned the shop’s style from owner Sam Patti, who opened it more than 25 years ago.
La Prima remains a leader among local coffee aficionados, and the shop encourages conversation in Italian, if possible. Roaster John Patalano said the shop sells three types of espresso blends. The Brazilian house blend is a recipe Mr. Patti sought from an Italian cafe years ago. The beans are a light roast and the espresso falls on the bright side. Mr. Gebis said he still appreciates an Italian-style espresso.
La Prima creates what Mr. Patalano considers a perfect espresso. With the work of a good barista, “it should have a really good crema,” he said, referring to the velvety top layer.
“And whether it’s chocolaty or nutty or has cherry notes, it should be smooth with a little sweetness,” he said. “It should also go down quick, so when you’re done you should feel like you should have another.”
The brew
Gear is also important in making an espresso. Mr. Gebis makes coffee with a La Marzocco GB5, the BMW of espresso machines. It has great temperature stability and allows adjusting of the brew temperature, “another in the myriad of variables when it comes to espresso,” he said.
Ms. Hoeg searched far and wide before settling on a Danish machine made by Kees van der Westen called the Spirit that was delivered a couple of weeks ago. This beautifully designed piece has more horsepower than older machines and ensures a more consistent pour.
Then there’s the brewing — temperature, time, volume and pressure — each of which can lead to an inside-baseball discussion among passionate coffee drinkers. And a barista’s style is a factor that gains fans, particularly at a place with “by hand” in the name such as Espresso a Mano. Ms. Hoeg also has quite a following.
At any serious coffee shop, owners work to cultivate a sensibility unique to their cafes.
On weekends, Mr. Gebis is proud to see La Prima regulars stop by for a visit, speaking Italian at a table next to young Lawrenceville newcomers.
Ms. Hoeg also wants to keep coffee as a social moment. Her shop will offer standing tables and no Wi-Fi so it doesn’t become a cafe workspace.
She was inspired to create this arrangement on a recent trip to Istanbul where a coffee shop owner told her about a fantastic place for dinner and directed her to a couple of must-see places.
“I want 4121 Main to be a place where people stop to find out interesting things going on in Pittsburgh.”
And as far as the coffee, “we are pushing coffee beyond what we could have had a couple years ago,” she said.
“The timing is right.”
Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.